Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care
FeaturesPerception of HIV and Safer Sexual Behaviors among Lesbians
Section snippets
Review of Literature
In a study of 4,501 U.S. female physicians, Brogan, Frank, Elon, and O'Hanlan (2001), used three concepts to measure sexual orientation: (a) sexual identity only, (b) sexual behavior only, and (c) identity and behavior combined. In contrast to other researchers, they described almost 100% consistency between sexual identity and behavior. The high level of education and medical knowledge of their study population may have skewed study results. For this study, both individual behavior and sexual
Method
Approval was obtained from the Hartford Hospital's Human Subjects Committee and the Board of Directors of the North East Women's Musical Retreat. A yearly occurrence since 1981, the event is attended by women diverse in age, race and ethnicity, education, occupation, and sexual orientation. Their common bond is a belief in “women's culture” and enjoyment of “women's music.”
Procedure
The lesbian community has several subcultures with particular norms and values. In some communities, certain behaviors such as intravenous drug use and having sex with men are not acceptable. However, women may not admit to such practices in order to maintain acceptance or status in their community. Consequently, an anonymous survey was essential and distributed in the registration packet of the women's music festival.
A sealed box in a separate but public area at the music festival and a
Results
A convenience sample of 78 women predominately White (86%) with a master's degree education or beyond (49%) and income above $35,000 (45%) participated in the study. Mean age was 46 years (SD = 8.6). Women reported not having a partner (29%), living separately from a partner (27%), living with a partner (27%), and in a same-gender committed relationship (17%).
Discussion
Lesbian women's belief that they are not at risk for contracting HIV is a repeated finding and has been termed lesbian immunity. This belief may expose WSW to a much higher risk for contracting HIV than is generally perceived. In this survey, only 30% of women worried about contracting HIV and 53% believed they were at low risk. This result is similar to the findings of Montcalm and Myer (2001) in which 39% of lesbians surveyed did not perceive that they had any risk for contracting HIV.
Implications for Nursing
Nurses and nurse practitioners take sexual orientation and risk behavior histories as well as provide education on safer sex. Many health care providers feel awkward in this process with any patient and even more so with someone whose lifestyle is unfamiliar. Additionally, WSW are often reluctant to disclose their sexual orientation or their sexual behaviors due to fear of rejection, misunderstanding, discrimination, or negative consequences, or perhaps due to not perceiving the need for health
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank Rose Maljanian, MS, for research assistance; Sheryl Horowitz, PhD, for statistical analyses; and Valerie Banfi for library assistance. We also express appreciation to the women of the North East Women's Musical Retreat for their participation.
References (21)
- et al.
Receipt of preventative health care services by lesbians
American Journal of Preventative Medicine
(2000) The importance of the sexual health history in the primary care setting
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, and Neonatal Nursing
(2001)- et al.
Sexuality and safer sex: The issues for lesbians and bisexual women
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, and Neonatal Nursing
(2001) - et al.
Behavioral risk factors for disease and preventative health practices among lesbians
American Journal of Public Health
(2001) Lesbian health and health care
Annual Review of Nursing Research
(2001)- et al.
Methodologic concerns in defining lesbian for health research
Epidemiology
(2001) - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (1999). HIV and U.S. women who have sex withwomen (WSW). CDCNational...
Revised guidelines for HIV counseling, testing, and referral and revised Fishman, Anderson / Perception of HIV and Safer Sexual Behaviors 55 recommendations for HIV screening of pregnantwomen
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
(2001)- et al.
Lesbians’sexual history with men: Implications for taking a sexual history
Archives of Internal Medicine
(1999) - et al.
Sexually transmitted infections and risk behaviours in women who have sex with women
SexuallyT ransmitted Infections
(2000)
Cited by (36)
Gaps in sexual health research about women who have sex with women. A scoping review
2022, Gaceta SanitariaCitation Excerpt :Nine studies focused on comparing WSW and WSWM. In addition, seven studies were addressed specifically to African American WSW and two specifically identified only lesbians in their study population,20,21 23 studies (59%) were focused on specific STIs and 17 (43.6%) were interested in other aims or included STIs in general, as added information. Regarding STIs specifically in WSW, eight studies were interested on Bacterial Vaginosis, with proportions varying from 14,4% to 43%.
Sexual rights but not the right to health? Lesbian and bisexual women in South Africa's National Strategic Plans on HIV and STIs
2016, Reproductive Health MattersCitation Excerpt :These findings were unexpected, given that there is little comparable data showing a similar burden of disease elsewhere, and a lack of analysis in both high‐income and low‐ and middle‐income countries about a range of lesbian and bisexual women’s sexual and reproductive health concerns, including risk of acquiring HIV. There is a common misperception that WSW are not at risk of acquiring STIs, including HIV,1 resulting in many WSW having a sense of invincibility to HIV transmission through same‐sex relationships,14 and hence a “much higher risk for contracting HIV than is generally perceived.”15 Although data on incidence and prevalence of HIV and other STIs among WSW in South Africa are limited, there are many self‐identified lesbians living with HIV in South Africa who argue that the exclusion of WSW from South Africa’s HIV policy, research and prevention initiatives can no longer be justified by assertions that WSW face “no risk” of HIV transmission in same‐sex relationships.
Reproductive health screening disparities and sexual orientation in a cohort study of U.S. adolescent and young adult females
2011, Journal of Adolescent HealthCitation Excerpt :Lesbian adolescents and young adults had lower odds of having a Pap smear, both over their lifetime and in the past year. Again, possible factors contributing to this disparity include a lower risk perception [31], poor patient–provider communication [10], lack of insurance [13], or other healthcare system factors [32]. Regardless of a patient's reported sexual orientation identity, clinicians must offer a Pap test to every individual who meets age guidelines.
Sex in placemaking activism: lesbians’ and queer women’s sex-based sociality in Sydney, Australia
2022, Gender, Place and Culture