Hostname: page-component-6b989bf9dc-mbg9n Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-14T22:44:54.733Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Assessing dietary intake: Who, what and why of under-reporting

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 December 2007

Jennie Macdiarmid  and
John Blundell
Jennie Macdiarmid
Affiliation:
Bio Psychology Group, School of Psychology, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK.
John Blundell
Affiliation:
Bio Psychology Group, School of Psychology, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK.
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Under-reporting of food intake is one of the fundamental obstacles preventing the collection of accurate habitual dietary intake data. The prevalence of under-reporting in large nutritional surveys ranges from 18 to 54% of the whole sample, but can be as high as 70% in particular subgroups. This wide variation between studies is partly due to different criteria used to identify under-reporters and also to non-uniformity of under-reporting across populations. The most consistent differences found are between men and women and between groups differing in body mass index. Women are more likely to under-report than men, and under-reporting is more common among overweight and obese individuals. Other associated characteristics, for which there is less consistent evidence, include age, smoking habits, level of education, social class, physical activity and dietary restraint.

Determining whether under-reporting is specific to macronutrients or food is problematic, as most methods identify only low energy intakes. Studies that have attempted to measure under-reporting specific to macronutrients express nutrients as percentage of energy and have tended to find carbohydrate under-reported and protein over-reported. However, care must be taken when interpreting these results, especially when data are expressed as percentages. A logical conclusion is that food items with a negative health image (e.g. cakes, sweets, confectionery) are more likely to be under-reported, whereas those with a positive health image are more likely to be over-reported (e.g. fruits and vegetables). This also suggests that dietary fat is likely to be under-reported.

However, it is necessary to distinguish between under-reporting and genuine under-eating for the duration of data collection. The key to understanding this problem, but one that has been widely neglected, concerns the processes that cause people to under-report their food intakes. The little work that has been done has simply confirmed the complexity of this issue. The importance of obtaining accurate estimates of habitual dietary intakes so as to assess health correlates of food consumption can be contrasted with the poor quality of data collected. This phenomenon should be considered a priority research area. Moreover, misreporting is not simply a nutritionist's problem, but requires a multidisciplinary approach (including psychology, sociology and physiology) to advance the understanding of under-reporting in dietary intake studies.

Type
Research Article
Information
Nutrition Research Reviews , Volume 11 , Issue 2 , December 1998 , pp. 231 - 253
Copyright
Copyright © The Nutrition Society 1998

References

Acheson, K. J., Campbell, I. T., Edholm, 0. G., Miller, D. S. & Stock, M. J. (1980). The measurement of food and energy intake in man—an evaluation of some techniques. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 33, 1147–1154.Google Scholar
Ballard-Barbash, R., Graubard, B. I., Krebs-Smith, S. M., Schatzkin, A. & Thompson, F. E. (1996). Contribution of dieting to the inverse association between energy intake and body mass index. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 50. 98–106.Google Scholar
Barrett-Conner, E. (1991). Nutrition epidemiology: how do we know what they ate? American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 54, 182S–187S.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beaton, G. H. (1994). Approaches to analysis of dietary data: relationship between planned analyses and choice of methodology. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 59, 253S–261S.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bingham, S. A. (1987). The dietary assessment of individuals; methods, accuracy, new techniques and recommendations. Nutrition Abstracts and Reviews A 57, 705–742.Google Scholar
Bingham, S. A. (1991). Limitations of the various methods for collecting dietary intake data. Annals of Nutrition and Metabolism 35, 117–127.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bingham, S A., Cassidy, A., Cole, T. J., Welch, A., RunswickS. A, S. A,, Black, A. E., Thurnham, D., Bates, C., Khaw, K. T., Key, T. J. A. & Day, N. E. (1995). Validation of weighed records and other methods of dietary assessment using the 24 h urine nitrogen technique and other biological markers. British Journal of Nutrition 73, 531–550.Google Scholar
Bingham, S. A. & Cummings, J. H. (1985). Urine nitrogen as an independent validatory measure of dietary intake: a study of nitrogen balance in individuals consuming their normal diet. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 42, 1276–1289.Google Scholar
Bingham, S. A., Gill, C., Welch, A., Cassidy, A., Runswick, S. A., Oakes, S., Lubin, R., Thurnham, D., Key, T. J. A.. Roe, L., Khaw, K. T. & Day, N. E. (1997). Validation of dietary assessment methods in the UK arm of EPIC using weighed records and 24-hour urinary nitrogen and potassium and serum vitamin C and carotenoids as biomarkers. International Journal of Epidemiology 26, 9137–9151.Google Scholar
Bingham, S. A., Gill, C., Welch, A., Day, K., Cassidy, A., Khaw, K. T., Sneyd, M. J., Key, T. J. A., Roe, L. & Day, N. E. (1994). Comparison of dietary assessment methods in nutritional epidemiology: weighed records v. 24 h recalls, food-frequency questionnaires and estimated-diet records. British Journal of Nutrition 72, 619–643.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Black, A. E. (1996). Physical activity levels from a meta-analysis of doubly labeled water studies for validating energy intake as measured by dietary assessment. Nutrition Reviews 54, 170–174.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Black, A. E. (1997). Under-reporting of energy intake at all levels of energy expenditure: evidence from doubly labeled water studies. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 56, 121A.Google Scholar
Black, A. E., Goldberg, G. R., Jebb, S. A., Livingstone, M. B. E., Cole, T. J. & Prentice, A. M. (1991). Critical evaluation of energy intake data using fundamental principles of energy physiology. 2. Evaluating the results of published Surveys. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 45, 583–599.Google ScholarPubMed
Black, A. E., Jebb, S. A., Bingham, A., Runswick, S. A. & Poppitt, S. D. (1995). The validation of energy and protein intakes by doubly labelled water and 24-hour urinary nitrogen excretion in post-obese subjects. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics 8, 51–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Black, A. E., Johansson, G., Welch, A. & Bingham, S. A. (1997). Energy intake:basal metabolic rate (E1:BMR) for the evaluation of reported energy intake of individuals. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 56, 122A.Google Scholar
Briefel, R. R., Sempos, C. T., McDowell, M. A., Chien, S. & Alaimo, K. (1997). Dietary methods research in the third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey: under-reporting of energy intake. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 65, 1203S–1209S.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chaiken, S. & Pliner, P. (1987). Women, but not men, are what they eat: the effect of meal size and gender on perceived femininity and masculinity. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 13, 166–176.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colhoun, H., Prescott-Clarke, P., Dong, W., Hedges, B., Lampe, F. & Taylor, A. (1996). Health Survey for England 1994 London: HMSO.Google Scholar
de Castro, J. M. (1991). Weekly rhythms of spontaneous nutrient intake and meal patterns of humans. Physiology & Behavior 50, 729–738.Google Scholar
de Castro, J. M. (1994). Methodology, correlational analysis, and interpretation of diet diary records of the food and fluid intake of free-living humans. Appetite 23, 179–192.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
de Castro, J. M. (1997). How can energy balance be achieved by free-living human subjects? Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 56, 1–14.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
de Vries, J. H. M., Zock, P. L., Mensink, R. P. & Katan, M. B. (1994). Underestimation of energy intake by 3-d records compared with energy intake to maintain body weight in 269 nonobese adults. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 60, 855–860.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Durnin, J. V. G. A. (1996). Energy requirements: general principles. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 50 (Suppl. 1.) S2–S10.Google Scholar
Fogelholm, M., Männistö, S., Vartiainen, E. & Pietinen, P. (1996). Determinants of energy balance and overweight in Finland 1982 and 1992. International Journal of Obesity 20, 1097–1104.Google Scholar
Garrow, J. S. (1995). Human nutritionists' guilty secret. BNF Nutrition Bulletin 20, 103–108.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Garrow, J. S. (1996). Obesity. Where are we going? BNF Nutrition Bulletin 21(Suppl.) 50–55.Google Scholar
Goldberg, G. R., Black, A. E., Jebb, S. A., Cole, T. J., Murgatroyd, P. R., Coward, W. A. & Prentice, A. M. (1991). Critical evaluation of energy intake data using fundamental principles of energy physiology. I. Derivation of cut-off limits to identify under-recording. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 45, 569–581.Google ScholarPubMed
Green, S. M. & Burley, V. J. (1996). The effects of snacking on energy intake and body weight. BNF Nutrition Bulletin 21, 103–108.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gregory, J., Foster, K., Tyler, H. & Wiseman, M. (1990). The Dietary and Nutritional Survey of British Adults: a survey of the dietary behaviour, nutritional status and blood pressure of adults 16–64 living in Great Britain. London: HMSO(Office of Population Censuses and Surveys).Google Scholar
Grogan, S. C., Bell, R. & Conner, M. (1997). Eating sweet snacks: gender differences in attitudes and behaviour. Appetite 28, 19–31.Google Scholar
Hallfrisch, J., Steele, P. & Cohen, L. (1982). Comparison of seven-day diet record with measured food intake of twenty four subjects. Nutrition Research 2, 263–273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haraldsdóttir, J. & Sandsträm, B (1994) Detection of underestimated energy intake in young adults. International Journal of Epidemiology 23, 577–582.Google Scholar
Hebert, J. R., Clemow, L., Pbert, L., Ockene, I. S. & Ockene, J. K. (1995). Social desirability bias in dietary self-report may compromise the validity of dietary intake measures. International Journal of Epidemiology 24, 389–398.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Heitmann, B.L. (1993). The influence of fatness, weight change, slimming history and other lifestyle variables on diet reporting in Danish men and women aged 35–65 years. International Journal of Obesity 17, 329–336.Google Scholar
Heitmann, B. L. & Lissner, L. (1995). Dietary underreporting by obese individuals—is it specific or non-specific? British Medical Journal 311, 986–989.Google Scholar
Heywood, P., Harvey, P. W. J. & Marks, G. C. (1993). An evaluation of energy intakes in the 1983 Australian National Dietary Survey of Adults. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 47, 604–606.Google ScholarPubMed
Hill, A. J., Oliver, S. & Rogers, P. J. (1992). Eating in the adult world: the rise of dieting in childhood and adolescence. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 31, 95–105.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hirvonen, T., Männistä, S., Roos, E. & Pietinen, P. (1997). Increasing prevalence of underreporting does not necessarily distort dietary surveys. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51, 297–301.Google Scholar
Isaksson, B. (1980). Urinary nitrogen output as a validity test in dietary surveys. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 33, 4–6.Google Scholar
Johansson, G., Callmer, E. & Gustafsson, J.-Å. (1992). Validity of repeated dietary measurements in a dietary intervention study. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 46, 717–728.Google Scholar
Johansson, L., Solvoll, K., Opdahl, S., Bjørneboe, G.-E. Aa. & Drevon, C. A. (1997). Response rates with different distribution methods and reward, and reproducibility of a quantitative food frequency questionnaire. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51, 346–353.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Johnson, R. K., Goran, M. I. & Poehlman, E. T. (1994). Correlates of over- and underreporting of energy intake in healthy older men and women. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 59, 1286–1290.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Klesges, R. C., Eck, L. H. & Ray, J. W. (1995). Who underreports dietary intake in a dietary recall? Evidence from the second National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 63, 438–444.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knight, I. (1984). The Heights and Weights of Adults in Great Britain: reporr of a survey carried out on behalf of the Department of Health and Social Security covering adults aged 16–64. London: HMSO (Office of Population Censuses and Surveys).Google Scholar
Kuczmarski, R. J., Flegal, K. M., Campbell, S. M. & Johnson, C. L. (1994). Increasing prevalence of overweight among US adults: the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys 1960 to 1991. JAMA—Journal of the American Medical Association 272, 205–211.Google Scholar
Lafay, L., Basdevant, A.. Charles, M.-A., Vray, M., Balkau, B., Borys, J.-M., Eschwège, E. & Romon, M. (1997). Determinants and nature of dietary underreporting in a free-living population: the Fleurbaix Laventie Ville Santé(IT%) study. International Journal of Obesity 21, 567–573. FLVS study.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lichtman, S. W., Pisarska, K., Berman, E. R., Pestone, M., Dowling, H., Offenbacher, E., Weise, H., Heshka, S., Matthews, D.E. & Heymsfield, S.B. (1992). Discrepancy between self-reported and actual caloric intake and exercise in obese subjects. New England Journal of Medicine 327, 1893–1898.Google Scholar
Lissner, L., Habicht, J., Strupp, B. J., Levitsky, D. A., Haas, J. D. & Roe, D. A. (1989). Body composition and energy intake: do overweight women overeat and underreport? American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 49, 320–325.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lissner, L. & Lindroos, A.-K. (1994). Is dietary underreporting macronutrient-specific? European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 48, 453–454.Google Scholar
Livingstone, M. B. E. (1995). Assessment of food intakes: are we measuring what people eat? British Journal of Biomedical Science 52, 58–67.Google ScholarPubMed
Livingstone, M. B. E., Prentice, A. M.. CowardW. A, W. A,, Strain, J. J.. Black, A. E., Davies, P. S. W., Stewart, C. M., McKenna, P. G. & Whitehead, R. G. (1992). Validation of estimates of energy intake by weighed dietary record and diet history in children and adolescents. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 56, 29–35.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Livingstone, M. B. E.. Prentice, A. M., Strain, J. J., Coward, W. A., Black, A. E., Barker, M. E., McKenna, P. G. & Whitehead, R. G. (1990). Accuracy of weighed dietary records in studies of diet and health. British Medical Journal 300, 708–712.Google Scholar
McColl, K. A. (1988). The sugar–fat seesaw. BNF Nutrition Bulletin 13, 114–119.Google Scholar
Macdiarmid, J. I. & Blundell, J. E. (1997). Dietary under-reporting: what people say about recording their food intake. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51, 199–200.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Martin, L. J., Su, W., Jones, P. J., Lockwood, G. A.. Tritchler, D. L. & Boyd, N. F. (1996). Comparison of energy intakes determined by food records and doubly labeled water in women participating in a dietary-intervention trial. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 63, 483–490.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mela, D. J. & Aaron, J. I. (1997). Honest but invalid: what subjects say about recording their food intake. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 97, 791–793.Google Scholar
Mertz, W., Tsui, J. C., Judd, J. T., Reiser, S., Hallfrisch, J., Morris, E. R., Steele, P. D. & Lashley, E. (1991). What are people really eating? The relationship between energy intake derived from estimated diet records and intake determined to maintain body weight. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 54, 291–295.Google Scholar
Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAFF). (1940–1995). Household Food Consumption and Expenditure. London: HMSO (annual publication).Google Scholar
Mori, D., Chaiken, S. & Pliner, P. (1987). “Eating lightly” and the self-presentation of femininity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53, 693–702.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Nederhof, A. J. (1985). Methods of coping with social desirability bias: a review. European Journal of Social Psychology 15, 263–280.Google Scholar
Nelson, M. (1995). Editorial—can we measure what people eat? Journal of Human Nutrition & Dietetics 8, 1–2.Google Scholar
Perkins, K. A., Sexton, J. E. & DiMarco, A. (1996). Acute thermogenic effects of nicotine and alcohol in healthy male and female smokers. Physiology & Behavior 60, 305–309.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Poppitt, S. D., Swann, D., Black, A. E. & Prentice, A. M. (1995). Is under-reporting of energy intake in obese women macronutrient specific? Covert measurements in a metabolic facility. International Journal of Obesity 19 (Suppl. 2.) 29.Google Scholar
Porrini, M., Gentile, M. G. & Fidanza, F. (1995) Biochemical validation of a self-administered semi-quantitative food-frequency questionnaire. British Journal of Nutrition 74, 323–333.Google Scholar
Prentice, A. M., Black, A. E., Coward, W. A., Davies, H. L., Goldberg, G. R..Murgatroyd, P. R., Ashford, J., Sawyer, M. & Whitehead, R. G. (1986). High levels of energy expenditure in obese women. British Medical Journal 292, 983–987.Google Scholar
Prentice, A. M. & Jebb, S. A. (1995). Obesity in Britain: gluttony or sloth? British Medical Journal 311, 437–439.Google Scholar
Price, G. M., Paul, A. A., Cole, T. J. & Wadsworth, M. E. J. (1997). Characteristics of the low-energy reporters in a longitudinal national dietary survey. British Journal of Nutrition 77, 833–851.Google Scholar
Pryer, J. A., Vrijheid, M., Nichols, R., Kiggins, M. & Elliot, P. (1997). Who are the “low energy reporters” in the Dietary and Nutrition Survey of British Adults'. International Journal of Epidemiology 26, 146–154.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rosenthal, R. & Rosnow, R. L. (1991). Essentials of Behavioral Research: methods and data analysis, 2nd edn. New York : McGraw-Hill, Inc.Google Scholar
Rutishauser, I. H. E. (1995). Is dietary underreporting macronutrient specific? European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 49, 219–220.Google ScholarPubMed
Sawayer, A. L., Tucker, K., Tsay, R., Willett, W., Saltzman, E., Dallal, G. E. & Roberts, S. B. (1996). Evaluation of four methods for determining energy intake in young and older women: comparison with doubly labeled water measurements of total energy expenditure. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 63, 491–499.Google Scholar
Schoeller, D. A. (1990). How accurate is self-reported dietary energy intake? Nutrition Reviews 48, 373–379.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Schoeller, D. A., Bandini, L. G. & Dietz, W. H. (1990). Inaccuracies in self-reported intake identified by comparison with the doubly-labelled water method. Canadian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 68, 941–949.Google Scholar
Schofield, W. N., Schofield, C. & James, W. P. T. (1985). Basal metabolic rate—review and prediction, together with an annotated bibliography of source material. Human Nutrition: Clinical Nutrition, 39C (Suppl. 1), 96 pp.Google Scholar
Seidell, J. C. (1997). Time trends in obesity: An epidemiological perspective. Hormone and Metabolic Research 29, 155–158.Google Scholar
Shetty, P. S., Henry, C. J. K., Black, A. E. & Prentice, A. M. (1996). Energy requirements of adults: an update on basal metabolic rates (BMRs) and physical activity levels (PALs). European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 50 (Suppl. 1.) S11–S23.Google Scholar
Smith, A. F. (1993). Cognitive psychological issues of relevance to the validity of dietary reports. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 47 (Suppl. 2), S6–S18.Google Scholar
Smith, W. T., Webb, K. L. & Heywood, P. F. (1994). The implications of underreporting in dietary studies. Australian Journal of Public Health 18, 311–314.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Stockley, L. (1985) Changes in habitual food intake during weighed inventory surveys and duplication diet collections. Ecology of Food and Nutrition 17, 263–269.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stuart, R. B. (1967). Behavioural control of overeating. Behaviour Research and Therapy 5, 357–365.Google Scholar
Stuart, R. B. & Davis, B. (1972). Slim Chance in a Far World: behavioural control of obesify. Champaign, IL: Research Press.Google Scholar
Stunkard, A. J. & Messick, S. (1985). The three-factor eating questionnaire to measure dietary restraint, disinhibition and hunger. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 29, 71–81.Google Scholar
Stunkard, A. J. & Sobal, J. (1995). Psychological consequences of Obesity. In Eating Disorders and Obesity: a comprehensive handbook, pp. 417–430(Brownell, K. D. and Fairburn, C. G., editors). London: Guildford Press.Google Scholar
Subar, A. F., Thompson, F. E., Smith, A. F., Jobe, J. B., Ziegler, R. G., Potischman, N., Schatzkin, A., Hartman, A., Swanson, C., Kruse, L., Hayes, R. B., Lewis, D. R. & Harlan, L. C. (1997). Improving food-frequency questionnaires: a qualitative approach using cognitive interviewing. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 65, 1317S–1318S (Abstr.).Google Scholar
Summerbell, C. D. (1996). Differences in reported macronutrient composition of the diet in overweight and lean individuals dependent on validity of reported energy intakes. Proceedings of the Nutrition Sociefy 55, 232A.Google Scholar
Tarasuk, V. & Beaton, G. H. (1992). Day-to-day variation in energy and nutrient intake: evidence of individuality in eating behaviour? Appetite 18, 43–54.Google Scholar
Tjønneland, A., Overad, K., Thorling, E. & Ewertz, M. (1993). Adipose tissue fatty acids as biomarkers of dietary exposure in Danish men and women. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 57, 629–633.Google Scholar
Wardle, J. (1988). Cognitive control of eating. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 32, 607–612.Google Scholar
Whybrow, S. & Kirk, T. R. (1997). Nutrient intakes and snacking frequency in female students. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics 10, 237–244.Google Scholar
World Health Organization (1985). Energy and Protein Requirements: report of a joint FAO\WHO\UNU expert consultation (Technical Report Series no. 724). Geneva: W.H.O.Google Scholar
Wrieden, W. L., Bolton-Smith, C., Brown, C. A. & Tunstall-Pedoe, H. (1994). Nutrient intakes in North Glasgow: results from the Scottish MONICA studies 1986 and 1989. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics 7, 199–207.Google Scholar
Yuker, H. E., Allison, D. B. & Faith, M. S. (1995). Methods for measuring attitudes and beliefs about obese people. In Handbook of Assessment Methods for Eating Behaviors and Weight-related Problems, pp. 81–118 (Allison, D. B., editor). London: Sage.Google Scholar