Elsevier

Public Health

Volume 114, Issue 4, July 2000, Pages 254-259
Public Health

Articles
The mandatory collection of data on ethnic group of inpatients: experience of NHS trusts in England in the first reporting years

https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.ph.1900662Get rights and content

Abstract

This paper reports the findings of a questionnaire survey of the experience of NHS trusts' mandatory collection and the use of ethnic group data of hospital inpatients in the South Thames Region, and the analysis of the ethnicity field in the Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) database for England. High levels of invalid ethnicity coding in hospital episode statistics, 44.0% (regional range 31–76%) in 1996/97 and 62.9% (range 43–90%) in 1995/96, render the data unusable. Over a third of NHS trusts felt there were other ethnic group categories for which data should have been collected, especially a subdivision of the white group. Only one in five trusts found the collection of ethnic group data useful and almost nine-tenths of trusts had made no use of the data, all but one trust stating that collection had not influenced the way services were provided. High levels of incompleteness of ethnic coding and data of questionable quality make it impossible to interpret the relative access of the ethnic minority population to hospital services and such collection is, arguably, at variance with Caldicott guidelines on patient-identifiable information. A high political priority must be accorded to the operationalisation of mandatory collection in order to meet new government objectives on fair access to services.

Public Health (2000) 114, 254–259

References (26)

  • Ethnic group data collection. DSC Notice: 54/94/P40 (October 1994)

    (1994)
  • J Gabbay et al.

    Evaluation of audit of medical inpatient records in a district general hospital

    Qual Health Care

    (1992)
  • Cited by (24)

    • Name analysis to classify populations by ethnicity in public health: Validation of Onomap in Scotland

      2011, Public Health
      Citation Excerpt :

      Due to the potential sensitive use in the targeting of individuals, filtering questions have been introduced, ensuring that questionnaires are sent to those of Polish ethnicity, thus illustrating the need for care before using Onomap and other name-based ethnicity classifications. There is a policy drive to improve ethnicity recording in routinely collected health datasets.3,11–13 Nevertheless, improvements are unlikely to extend to all disease registers and administrative datasets in the near future, and the need for alternative means to identify population groups by ethnicity remain.

    • Names-based classification of accident and emergency department users

      2011, Health and Place
      Citation Excerpt :

      We are aware, however, that analysis of ethnic differences in healthcare utilisation using routinely collected data is far from straightforward, because of enduring issues of data incompleteness. Such issues frustrate efforts to extend and improve coverage of hard to reach groups (Aspinall, 2000; Kumarapeli et al., 2006; Raleigh, 2008; Sangowawa and Bhopal, 2000). The contribution of this research is to classify individual health records according to patient cultural, linguistic and ethnic group, using information derived from given and family names, in order to increase our understanding of differential healthcare usage according to ethnicity.

    • Harms and benefits: Collecting ethnicity data in a clinical context

      2009, Social Science and Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      The assumption is that providing equitable, quality care requires race and ethnicity data, but to date research has not shown that knowledge about health inequities leads to better healthcare services at the individual level. Indeed in the UK, Aspinall (2000) found that little use was made of ethnicity data collected in healthcare settings. Aspinall and Anionwu (2002) reported that although the ethnic identities of patients were obtained for an annual total in England of over 11 million admissions, the information has only been used to produce indices of quality, not to improve the quality of care provided.

    • Recent literature on government information

      2001, Journal of Government Information
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text