Community financing of health care in Africa: An evaluation of the Bamako initiative

https://doi.org/10.1016/0277-9536(93)90381-DGet rights and content

Abstract

The Bamako Initiative, a controversial attempt to strengthen Primary Health Care using community financing and community participation and management was launched at a meeting of African Ministers of Health in 1987.

This evaluation focuses particularly on the community financing aspects of the Initiative. Previous experiences of community financing highlight particular lessons for the development of the Initiative and issues likely to be encountered in implementation attempts.

Four country case studies of the Initiative at its early stages of implementation (in June, July and August 1991) were conducted in Burundi, Guinea, Kenya, and Nigeria. Similar activities in Uganda were also studied. These were short studies of one month each and utilised methods of rapid evaluation. The studies aimed to direct implementers quickly to issues requiring attention rather than to reach overall conclusions regarding the success of the Initiative which would be premature at this stage.

Price structures used by the Initiative need to consider the access of marginalised groups more than is the case at present. In addition, there is a need to ensure against over-prescription and commercialisation and to ensure that incentives for utilising most appropriate levels of care are maintained.

The evidence suggests that most people do find amounts of money to pay for health services which are large in relation to their income. This is probably a tribute to extensive community support mechanisms. Nevertheless, it highlights the plight of those who fall through this safety net for whom even charges for very basic care may be prohibitive. On the other hand, it appears that in most cases, the Initiative's activities provide a service which is cheaper when all costs to the household are taken into account, than was available before.

The quality of services included in the Initiative's activities in the five countries was highly variable. Success in raising substantial revenues has also been mixed. In some countries however, substantial funds have been generated and used to achieve real improvements in health services.

Overall, the experiences of the five countries appear to have been highly dependent on a number of ‘environmental’ characteristics: a tradition or not of ‘free’ services; the adequacy of current resource availability and that immediately preceding the introduction of the Initiative; the existing stage and nature of decentralisation within the country; and the competition the Initiative's activities face with alternatives.

References (30)

  • P. Eklund et al.

    Prepaid Financing of Primary Health Care in Guinea-Bissau, An Assessment of 18 Village Health Posts

    Policy, Research and External Affair, World Bank PHN Working Paper

    (1990)
  • C.N. Myers et al.

    Health Care Funds in Thailand

    (1987)
  • S. Fabricant et al.

    The Financing of Community Health Services in Sierra Leone

  • D. de Ferranti

    Paying for Health Services in Developing Countries: an Overview

    World Bank Staff Working paper, No. 721

    (1985)
  • L. Miller

    Equity in the context of community financing of primary health care: who pays and who benefits?

  • Cited by (110)

    • Maternal mortality and the metempsychosis of user fees in Liberia: A mixed-methods analysis

      2019, Scientific African
      Citation Excerpt :

      In a 1987 report, Financing Health Services in Developing Countries, the World Bank promoted the use of user fees at government health facilities in order to generate increased revenue for health services, reduce overconsumption of health resources by shunting patients to lower cost primary care services, and subsidize rural health care by diverting money collected in urban areas [59]. This mode of cost recovery was enshrined in the 1987 Bamako Initiative, which committed many African ministries of health to establish universal access to primary care by decentralizing health decision-making and promoting user fees [60]. Such lofty goals were seldom realized, however.

    • The role of government and community in the scaling up and sustainability of mutual health organisations: An exploratory study in Ghana

      2018, Social Science and Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      Most of the people in the communities are peasant farmers, artisans or fishermen, whose financial availability is seasonally directed. The study postulates that it is the socio-economic indicators, health status and people's desire for an efficient and effective health system that are the propellers of a workable health reform policy similar to an earlier observation (McPake et al., 1993). In Ghana, the sense of community feeling is motivating people to contribute to the development programmes such as health financing in their neighbourhoods as previously noted (Carrin et al., 1999).

    • National Health Systems: A Historical Overview

      2016, International Encyclopedia of Public Health
    • Investigating the affordability of key health services in South Africa

      2013, Social Science and Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      While some households are able to use savings, others face the need to reduce consumption, particularly food (Rugalema, 1998; Tibaijuka, 1997). Other frequent coping strategies are the sale of assets (Kabir, Rahman, Salway, & Pryer, 2000; Sauerborn, Adams, & Hien, 1996; Wilkes, Hao, Bloom, & Xingyuan, 1997) and borrowing, either from family and friends or from a money lender (McPake, Hanson, & Mills, 1993; Nahar & Costello, 1998). One could regard the two different approaches to assessing affordability of health care costs respectively as being:

    • " We charge them; otherwise we cannot run the hospital" front line workers, clients and health financing policy implementation gaps in Ghana

      2011, Health Policy
      Citation Excerpt :

      Despite documented inequities associated with user fees [1–6], they remain an important financing mechanism in low and middle income countries (LMIC) not easily decreed away [7].

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text