Table 1

Characteristics of the included studies

Index testSound conductionPain from vibration
Bache and Cross7Moore6Lesho9Kazemi and Roscoe2Dissmann and Han8Wilder et al10
Number of participants1003752464945
Age (years)MeanRangeMeanMeanRangeMean
797–60253012–8431
SettingEmergency departmentUniversity sports clinic/orthopaedic centreArmy medical centreEmergency departmentEmergency departmentRunners clinic
Suspected fracture typeFemoral neck fractureAny fractureTibial stress fractureAny fractureAnkle inversion injuries*Stress fractures in legs and feet
Reference testX-rayX-rayBone scanBone scanX-rayX-ray and bone scan
Time since symptom onsetNot reported<7 days oldNot reported0–10 daysNot reportedNot reported
  • *Patients had tested positive to the ‘Ottawa ankle rule’.