Table 2

Assessment of included studies based on two components of the Medical Research Council11 criteria for complex interventions

AuthorsTheoretical qualityStandardisation of delivery
A Warrens, personal communication, 2013Minimally groundedAuthors allow for and explain variation in intervention delivery
Standard training offered to educators delivering intervention
Allen and Stillwater26Minimally groundedAuthors indicate variation
Alvaro et al31Moderately groundedStrict standardisation (due to intervention design)
Alvaro et al20Well groundedStrict standardisation—authors undertook unannounced site visits and developed standard reporting tools for completion at intervention sites
Andrews et al13Moderately groundedAuthors indicate variation
Arriola et al14Well groundedStrict standardisation
Callender et al25Well groundedAuthors indicate variation
Cárdenas et al18Moderately groundedStrict standardisation
Thornton et al17No theoretical groundingStrict standardisation
Fahrenwald et al28Well groundedStrict standardisation
Feeley et al19Moderately groundedAuthors allow for and explain variation
Frates et al29Moderately groundedStrict standardisation (due to intervention design)
Harrison et al15Well groundedStrict standardisation of media and print info. Variation but no explanation or assessment of variation in interpersonal elements
Hebert et al32Moderately groundedStrict standardisation (due to intervention design)
Radosevich et al15Moderately groundedStrict standardisation due to intervention design)
Resnicow et al12Moderately groundedStrict standardisation. Standard training offered to educators delivering intervention
Salim et al30Minimally groundedStrict standardisation (due to intervention design)
Salim et al24Minimally groundedStrict standardisation