Table 2

Data merging procedures

VariableLester et alPop-Eleches et alMbuagbaw et alIPD* Meta-analysis
AgeYearsYearsYearsYears
GenderMale/femaleMale/femaleMale/femaleMale/female
Level of educationNo formal educationNoneNoneNone
Lower primary
Upper primary
Completed primaryPrimaryPrimary
Lower secondary
Upper secondary
High school
Completed secondarySecondarySecondary or higher
Middle college and UniversityUniversity
Duration on ARTMonthsMonthsMonthsMonths
InterventionSMS short dailySMS short daily
SMS short weeklySMS short weeklySMS short weekly
SMS long dailySMS long daily
SMS long weeklySMS Long weeklySMS long weekly
ControlNo SMSNo SMSNo SMSNo SMS
AdherenceYes (>95 at 6 & 12 months)Yes (≥95% from 12 to 48 weeks)Yes (>95% at 6 months)Yes (as reported in studies)
Final outcomeLost to follow-upLost to follow-upLost to follow-upLost to follow-up
DeathDeathDeathDeath
WithdrewWithdrewWithdrewWithdrew
Transferred outTransferred outTransferred outTransferred out
  • *Individual patient data.

  • SMS, short message service.