Study identification | Type of SCI/control | Patient characteristics | Jadad score | Cessation rate |
---|---|---|---|---|
Wolfe et al8 | SCI: advice on NRT use | Intervention: 61 (22.3%) over 80 years, 126 (46.2%) female, 76 (27.9%) smokers | 3 | N intervention=21 of 76 (27.6%) |
Control: usual care | Control: 50 (20.2%) over 80 years, 118 (47.8%) female, 78 (32.2%) smokers | N control=22 of 78 (28.2%) | ||
Follow-up: 1 year | ||||
Ellis et al9/McManus et al10 | SCI: discussion with nurse specialist on lifestyle modification in regards to smoking cessation | Intervention: 64.3 (95% CI 62.4 to 66.1, 95% CI) mean age, 54 (54.0%) male, 36 (36.0%) smokers | 4 | N intervention=1 of 36 (2.8%) |
Control: usual care | Control: 65.8 (95% CI 64.0 to 67.5) mean age, 52 (49.5%) male, 42 (40.0%) smokers | N control=0 of 42 (0.0%) | ||
Follow-up: 42 months | ||||
Papadakis et al11 | SCI: counselling and cost-free quit-smoking medications (NRT, bupropion, varenicline) with follow-up | Intervention: 55.4 (12.4 SD) mean age, 53.3% male, 15 (53.6%) smokers | 4 | N intervention=4 of 15 (26.6%) |
Control: usual care + prescriptions to pharmacotherapy | Control: 53.5 (8.1 SD), mean age, 69.2% male, 13 (46.4%) smokers. | N control=2 of 13 (15.4%) | ||
Follow-up: 26 weeks | ||||
Frandsend et al12 | SCI: counselling and cost-free NRT (gum, tablets, patches, nasal spray) with follow-up | Intervention: 29 (59.2%) age 50–65, 17 (34.7%) female, 49 smokers | 4 | N intervention=16 of 49 (32.7%) |
Control: 1 time 30 min counselling support | Control: 21 (46.7%) 50–65 age, 22 (48.9%) female, 45 smokers | N control=13 of 45 (28.9%) | ||
Follow-up: 6 months |
NRT, nicotine-replacement therapy; SCI, smoking cessation intervention.