Table 1

Characteristics of included systematic reviews and meta-analysis

CharacteristicForm responseN (%)
Journal in which systematic reviews were published
(n=127)
Addiction30 (23.6)
Drug and Alcohol Dependance18 (14.2)
Addictive Behaviors14 (11.0)
Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment14 (11.0)
Nicotine and Tobacco Research12 (9.4)
Alcohol and Alcoholism6 (4.7)
Other*33 (26.0)
Conflict of interest (COI) statement
(n=127)
All authors report no COI81 (63.8)
No COI statement present18 (14.1)
One or more authors report a COI28 (22.0)
Intervention type
(n=127)
Pharmacologic64 (50.4)
Procedure2 (1.6)
Behavioural therapy/psychosocial treatments53 (41.7)
Prevention8 (6.3)
Affiliation of first author
(n=127)
Public academic institution92 (72.4)
Private academic institution15 (11.8)
Government14 (11.0)
Public academic institution, government1 (0.8)
Non-profit institution4 (3.1)
Private-for-profit1 (0.8)
Affiliation of last author
(n=127)
Public academic institution94 (74.0)
Private academic institution15 (11.8)
Government13 (10.2)
Public academic institution, government1 (0.8)
Non-profit institution3 (2.4)
Private-for-profit1 (0.8)
Author source of funding
(n=127)
No funding received33 (26.0)
No statement listed19 (15.0)
Private/industry2 (1.6)
Public66 (52.0)
University4 (3.1)
Public and university3 (2.4)
Self-citation of primary studies
(n=127)
No, did not include self-cited primary studies109 (85.8)
Yes, included one or more self-cited primary studies18 (14.2)