Table 1

Description of the included studies

Author,
year,
country
Study designSampling timePopulationInterventionComparisonOutcomes
Farasatkish et al, 2009,
Iran33
Two-group after studyMay 2007 through
August 2007
N=1716, open-heart surgery, ASA class III–IVPre-anaesthesia consultation clinic (3–10 days before surgery)Usual care (within 24 hours of surgery)Cancellations
Kamal et al, 2011,
England34
Two-group after studyApril 2005 through
April 2009
N=1445, complex elective orthopaedic surgery, ASA class III–IVPreoperative anaesthetic assessment clinic (timing not stated)Usual care (day of surgery)Admissions, length of stay, mortality, cost
Kamau et al, 2017,
Kenya31
CBAAugust 2000, April 2001, November 2001N=51, elective non-cardiac surgery, ASA class not statedPre-anaesthesia clinic consultation (≥48 hours before surgery)Usual care (day before surgery)Anxiety (STAI score)
Klopfenstein et al, 2000,
Switzerland30
Two-group after study (parallel)No dataN=40, elective endoscopic urological surgery, ASA class I–IIIPre-anaesthetic consultation (1–2 weeks before surgery)Usual care (the evening before surgery)Anxiety (MAACL, VAS)
Lee et al, 2012,
China35
Two-group after study (parallel)March 2007 through November 2009N=352, elective surgery, ASA class I–IVAnaesthesia consultation clinic (≤3 months before surgery)Usual care (the evening before surgery)Quality of recovery score, cost, cancellations, length of stay, satisfaction, anxiety (VAS), willingness to pay
Mendes et al, 2005,
Brazil36
Two-group after study (parallel)April 2007 through
June 2007
N=52 254, surgery, ASA class not statedPreoperative outpatient evaluation clinic (timing not stated)Usual care (timing not stated)Cancellations, length of stay, PAC evaluations, outpatient procedures
van Klei et al, 2002,
The Netherlands32
Two-group after studyNovember 2012N=21 553, elective surgery, ASA class not statedPreoperative outpatient evaluation clinic (average 3 weeks before surgery)Usual care (day before surgery)Cancellations
  • ASA, American Society of Anesthesiologists; CBA, controlled before–after; MAACL, Multiple Affect Adjective Check List; PAC, Preanesthetic assessment clinic; STAI, State-Trait Anxiety Inventory; VAS, Visual Analogue Scale.