Table 1

Characteristics of the studies included in qualitative analysis

Total studiesTotal pop.Structural gene primersStructural and non-structural
gene primers
Non-structural
gene primers
Not reported
N studiesN pop.N studiesN pop.N studiesN pop.N studiesN pop.
Total8521 53022426531548431232911 658
Location
 Asia (excluding China)63782534325
 China2812 187818021730473123247215
 Europe1257574528899344236
 North America1030018188221119
 Global2071207
Primers
N—single112016112016
E—single47594759
S—single14121412
N, E22262226
S, N48524852
ORF1Ab, single259259
RdRp, single164164
E+ORF1Ab2111921119
E+RdRp22592259
M, E148148
N+ORF1Ab142703142703
N+E+RdRp43334333
S, N, E, RdRp, ORF1ab113113
N, E, ORF1ab133133
N, RNAse P11901190
S, N, RdRp, ORF1ab, E, M152152
N, S, RdRp12731273
N, E, S, RdRp23492349
S, ORF1Ab11121112
Sample source
 Upper respiratory236748357592633164103476
 Upper and lower respiratory152152
 Upper respiratory+other*975133682441383301
 Lower respiratory+other*12731273
 Upper respiratory+serum206407714739143243502
 Upper respiratory+serum+other*49412840180121
 Upper and lower respiratory+other*467812803398
 Upper and lower respiratory+serum+other*251811321386
 Serum1823766729444081207
 Other*11991199
 Not reported2258722587
  • *Other=bronchioalveolar lavage, feces, urine, neonatal, amniotic fluid and breast milk.

  • E, envelope; N, nucleocapsid; N pop, patient population; ORF1ab, open reading frame1ab; RdRp, RNA-dependent RNA polymerase; S, spike.