Table 1

Characteristics of included studies

StudyStudy typeWHO regionGeographical settingRegion protected by travel-related measureRegion restricted by travel-related measureDiseaseIntervention categoryOutcome type
Adekunle 202014 (preprint)InferentialWPRIsland stateAustraliaChina, Iran, South Korea and ItalyCOVID-19Travel banNumber or proportion of cases
Aleta 202015 (preprint)InferentialWPRNon-island stateRegions within ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Anonymous 200316DescriptiveAMRNon-island stateVancouver, Toronto, other parts of CanadaAll other countriesSARSEntry/exit screeningDetection of high risk persons or cases
Anzai 202017InferentialWPRNon-island stateMultiple countriesChinaCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Arima 202018DescriptiveWPRIsland stateJapanChinaCOVID-19Entry/exit screening;
travel-related quarantine
Detection of high risk persons or cases
Arino 200719Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalHypothetical infectious diseaseTravel restrictionNumber or proportion of cases
Bajardi 201120InferentialAllNon-island stateAll countriesMexicoInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Travel ban;
travel restriction: land
Temporal development of epidemic
Banholzer 202021 (preprint)InferentialEUR, WPR and AMRNon-island stateAustria, Australia, Belgium, Canada Denmark, France, Finland, Italy, Norway, Switzerland, Sweden, Spain and USAAll other countriesCOVID-19Border closureNumber or proportion of cases
Bolton 201222InferentialWPRNon-island stateMongoliaNeighbouring countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Travel restrictionNumber or proportion of cases
Boyd 201723InferentialWPRIsland stateNew ZealandAll other countriesHypothetical infectious diseaseBorder closureCosts
Boyd 201824InferentialWPRIsland stateNew ZealandAll other countriesHypothetical infectious diseaseBorder closureCosts
Caley 200725Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenzaEntry/exit screening;
travel restriction: air
Detection of high risk persons or cases; temporal development of epidemic
Chang 202026 (preprint)InferentialWPRIsland stateTaiwanDifferent cities in TaiwanCOVID-19Travel restrictionNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Cheng 202027DescriptiveWPRIsland stateTaiwanChinaCOVID-19Exit/entry screening;
travel-related quarantine
Number or proportion of cases
Chinazzi 202028InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of China, all other countriesWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Chiyomaru 202029 (preprint)InferentialNon-island stateMultiple countriesMultiple countriesCOVID-19Travel banNumber or proportion of cases
Chong 201230InferentialWPRQuasi-island stateHong KongAll other countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Travel restriction: land, air and maritimeNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Chung 201531InferentialNon-island stateMultiple countriesMultiple countriesSARS; 2006 Avian influenza; 2009 Swine influenza H1N1Travel restriction: airIndustry impact
Ciofi 200832InferentialEURNon-island stateItalyItaly and all other countriesInfluenzaTravel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Clifford 202033
(preprint)
Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalAll other countriesCOVID-19Entry/exit screeningDetection of high risk persons or cases; temporal development of epidemic
Colizza 200734InferentialAllNon-island stateAll countriesAll countriesInfluenzaTravel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Cooper 200635InferentialAllNon-island stateAll countriesAll countriesInfluenzaTravel restriction: airTemporal development of epidemic
Costantino 202036 (preprint)InferentialWPRIsland stateAustraliaAll other countriesCOVID-19Travel banNumber or proportion of cases; number or proportion of deaths; temporal development of epidemic
Cowling 202037InferentialWPRQuasi-island stateHong KongChina, South Korea, Iran, Italy and affected regions in France, Germany, Japan, and Spain, Schengen Area, Macau and Taiwan.COVID-19Travel restriction: air and land;
travel ban;
travel-related quarantine;
border closure
Reproduction number; number or proportion of cases; acceptability
Dandekar 202038 (preprint)InferentialWPR, EUR and AMRIsland state;
quasi-island state
China, Italy, South Korea and USAAll other countriesCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresReproduction number
de Vlas 200939DescriptiveWPRNon-island stateRegions of ChinaRegions of ChinaSARSTravel-related quarantineReproduction number
Ediriweera 202040 (preprint)InferentialSEARIsland stateSri LankaAll other countriesCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measures;
travel-related quarantine
Number or proportion of cases; healthcare resources
Eichner 200941InferentialWPRHypotheticalHypotheticalAll other countriesInfluenza (pandemic)Travel restriction: airProbability of epidemic
Epstein 200742InferentialAllNon-island stateAll countries (focus on USA)All countriesInfluenzaTravel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Fang 202043
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Ferguson 200644InferentialAMRIsland state;
quasi-island state
USA and UKCountries connected by air trafficInfluenza (pandemic)Border controls; travel restrictiosNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Flahault 200645Inferentialn.a.Quasi-island state52 international cities and surrounding regionsCities connected via air trafficInfluenza (pandemic)Travel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases
Fujita 201146InferentialWPRIsland stateRegions in JapanUSA, Canada and MexicoInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high risk persons or cases
Germann 200647InferentialAMRNon-island stateUSA
Influenza (pandemic)Travel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases
Glass 200648Inferentialn.a.Non-island stateNon-infected regionNon-infected regionSARSEntry/exit screeningProbability of epidemic
Gostic 202049InferentialAllIsland stateAll countriesAll countriesCOVID-19Entry/exit screeningDetection of high risk persons or cases
Gostic 201550Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalSARS; MERS; influenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Goubar 200951InferentialEURIsland state;
quasi-island state
Germany and UKChina and Hong KongSARSEntry/exit screeningNumber or proportion of cases
Gunaratnam 201452DescriptiveWPRIsland stateAustraliaAll other countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Hale 201253DescriptiveWPRIsland stateNew ZealandInitially USA, Canada, Mexico, then all other countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Hamidouche 202054
(preprint)
InferentialAFRNon-island stateAlgeriaAll neighbouring and connected (via air) countriesCOVID-19Border closure; travel ban;
travel-related quarantine
Number or proportion of cases; reproduction number
He 202055
(preprint)
InferentialWPRIsland state;
quasi-island state
China, South Korea, Italy and IranItaly (Lombardy, Veneto, Emilia-Romagna, Piedmont and Marche) and China (Zhejiang).COVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Hien 201056InferentialWPRNon-island stateVietnamCountries with confirmed cases of 2009 H1N1Influenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Hollingsworth 200657Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalCountries connected via air trafficSARS and influenzaTravel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Hossain 202058 (preprint)InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresTemporal development of epidemic
Hou 202059
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; reproduction number
Hsieh 200760Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenza (endemic)Travel banReproduction number
Hsieh 200661InferentialWPRIsland stateTaiwanCountries with SARS casesSARSTravel-related quarantineNumber or proportion of cases
Jia 202062InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; other
Jiang 202063
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateRegions of ChinaRegions of ChinaCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresOther
Kerneis 200864Inferentialn.a.Non-island state52 international cities and surrounding regions52 international cities and surrounding regionsInfluenza (pandemic)Travel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Khan 201365InferentialAMRNon-island stateOther countriesMexicoInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases; other
Kim 201766Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalHypothetical infectious diseaseEntry/exit screeningReproduction number
Kong 202067
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19 and influenzaMultiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Kraemer 202068InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Kuo 200969DescriptiveWPRIsland stateTaiwanAll affected countries (eg, Mexico, USA and Canada)Influenza (H1N2 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Lai 202070
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Lam 201171InferentialWPRQuasi-island stateHong KongAll other countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Travel restrictionProbability of epidemic; temporal development of epidemic
Lau 202072
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Lee 201273Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Travel restrictionTemporal development of epidemic
Li 202074
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Lin 202075
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresReproduction number; other
Linka 202076
(preprint)
InferentialEURNon-island stateAll European countriesAll European countriesCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Liu 200677Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalHypothetical infectious diseaseEntry/exit screeningReproduction number
Liu 202078InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Liu 2020a79
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaCities outside of HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Malmberg 202080 (preprint)Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalHypothetical infectious diseaseTravel restriction; travel-related quarantineProbability of epidemic
Malone 200981InferentialAMRNon-island stateUSAAsiaInfluenza (pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases; number or proportion of cases; number of deaths
Mandal 202082InferentialSEARNon-island stateIndiaChina, Hong Kong, Singapore, Thailand, Japan, South Korea, Iran and ItalyCOVID-19Entry/exit screeningTemporal development of epidemic; number or proportion of cases
Marcelino 201283InferentialAllNon-island stateAll countriesMexico cityInfluenza (pandemic)Travel restriction: airNumber or proportion of cases
Mbuvha 202084 (preprint)InferentialAFRNon-island stateSouth AfricaSouth Africa and the all other countriesCOVID-19Travel banNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Mondal 202085
(preprint)
InferentialSEARNon-island stateIndiaIndiaCOVID-19Travel banNumber or proportion of cases
Moriarty 202086InferentialWPR and AMRNon-island stateJapan, USA, home countries of cruise ship passengersHome countries of cruise shipsCOVID-19Travel-related quarantineDetection of high risk persons or cases
Mummert 201387InferentialAMRNon-island stateUSAMexicoInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningNumber or proportion of cases
Muraduzzaman 201888
DescriptiveSEARNon-island stateBangladeshSaudi ArabiaMERSEntry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Nakata 201589Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalHypothetical infectious diseaseTravel restrictionReproduction number
Nigmatulina 200990Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenzaTravel restrictionNumber or proportion of cases
Nishiura 200991Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenza (pandemic)Travel-related quarantineDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Odendaal 202092
(preprint)
InferentialAMRNon-island stateUSAChina and other affected countriesCOVID-19Travel restrictionNumber or proportion of cases
Pan 202093 (preprint)InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Pan 2020a94InferentialWPRNon-island stateChinaChinaCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; reproduction number
Pang 200395DescriptiveWPRNon-island stateBeijingAll other countriesSARSEntry/exit screeningNumber or proportion of cases
Pinkas 200396DescriptiveEURNon-island statePolandAll other countriesCOVID-19Entry/exit screening;
border closure; travel ban;
travel-related quarantine
Number or proportion of cases
Pitman 200597DescriptiveEURQuasi-island stateUKAny of the top 100 sources of international airline passengersSARS and influenzaEntry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Priest 201398DescriptiveWPRIsland stateNew ZealandAustraliaInfluenza (type A and B)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Pullano 202099InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of China and European countriesWuhanCOVID-19Travel banProbability of epidemic
Qiu 2020100
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Quilty 2020101
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateBeijing, Chongqing, Hangzhou and ShenzhenWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; probability of epidemic
Ray 2020102

InferentialSEARNon-island stateIndiaAll other countriesCOVID-19Travel banNumber or proportion of cases
Sakaguchi 2012103DescriptiveWPRIsland stateJapanMexico, USA and CanadaInfluenza (A H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Samaan 2004104DescriptiveWPRIsland stateAustraliaAll countries affected by SARSSARSEntry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Sang 2012105Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalSARSEntry/exit screeningReproduction number; temporal development of epidemic; number or proportion of cases; number or proportion of deaths
Scala 2020106
(preprint)
InferentialEURNon-island stateIndividual regions of ItalyIndividual regions of ItalyCOVID-19Travel restrictionTemporal development of epidemic
Scalia Tomba 2008107Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenza (pandemic)Travel restriction/border controlTemporal development of epidemic
Shi 2020108
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Song 2020109Wang 2020110InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; reproduction number
St. John 2005111DescriptiveAMRNon-island stateCanadaAll other countriesSARSEntry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Su 2020112
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateBeijng, Shanghai, Guangzhou and ShenzhenBeijng, Shanghai, Guangzhou and ShenzhenCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Tang 2020113TInferentialWPRNon-island stateBeijingWuhan and other cities in ChinaCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Tian 2020114
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in ChinaCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Tsuboi 2020115DescriptiveWPRIsland stateJapanDiamond PrincessCOVID-19Travel-related quarantineNumber or proportion of quarantined diagnosed
Wang 2015116Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypothetical (low-risk patches)Hypothetical (high-risk patch)Influenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningReproduction number
Wang 2020110InferentialWPRNon-island stateChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; number or proportion of deaths
Wang 2007117DescriptiveWPRIsland stateTaiwanAll SARS-affected regionsSARSTravel-related quarantineDetection of high-risk persons or cases diagnosed
Wang 2012118InferentialWPRNon-island stateDifferent regions in ChinaDifferent regions in ChinaInfluenza (pandemic)Travel restrictionTemporal development of epidemic
Wells 2020119InferentialWPRNon-island stateAll other countriesChinaCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; probability of epidemic
Weng 2015120InferentialWPRHypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Travel restrictionNumber or proportion of cases
Wilder-Smith 2003121DescriptiveWPRNon-island stateSingaporeAll SARS-affected regionsSARSEntry/exit screeningDetection of high-risk persons or cases
Wood 2007122InferentialWPRNon-island stateMelbourne and SydneySydney and DarwinInfluenzaTravel restriction: airTemporal development of epidemic
Yang 2020123InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of China, particularly Guangdong and Zhjiang provincesHubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Ying 2020124
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaHubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Yu 2012125InferentialWPRNon-island stateChinaAll other countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningNumber or proportion of cases
Yuan 2020126
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of China and countriesWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresTemporal development of epidemic
Yuan 2020a127
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateChinaWuhanCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Zhang 2012128
DescriptiveWPRNon-island stateBeijingAll other countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningNumber or proportion of screened identified as cases
Zhang 2014129Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenza (pandemic)Entry/exit screeningNumber or proportion of cases; temporal development of epidemic
Zhang 2019130Inferentialn.a.HypotheticalHypotheticalHypotheticalInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screening;
reductions in human mobility
Temporal development of epidemic
Zhang 2020131

InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases
Zhang 2020a132
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; reproduction number
Zhao 2020133InferentialWPRNon-island stateRegions of ChinaRegions of ChinaCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; reproduction number; temporal development of epidemic
Zhou 2020134
(preprint)
InferentialWPRNon-island stateOther regions of ChinaWuhan and other cities in HubeiCOVID-19Multiple travel-related control measuresNumber or proportion of cases; number or proportion of deaths
Zlojutro 2019135InferentialAMRNon-island stateUSAAll other countriesInfluenza (H1N1 2009 pandemic)Entry/exit screeningNumber or proportion of cases; cost; other
  • AFR, African region; AMR, region of the Americas; EUR, European region; MERS, Middle East respiratory syndrome; SARS, severe acute respiratory syndrome; SEAR, Southeast Asia region; WPR, Western Pacific Region.