Table 4

Reported adherence within fidelity domains across studies (score awarded/applicable score) and final score (percentage of score awarded/applicable score)

ArticleStudy designTraining of providersTreatment deliveryTreatment
receipt
Treatment enactmentOverall score
Bennell et al3578% (25/32)21% (3/14)78% (14/18)20% (2/10)0% (0/4)56% (44/78)
Cloke et al3640% (19/48)0% (0/14)0% (0/18)0% (0/10)0% (0/4)20% (19/94)
Dickens et al3721% (5/24)0% (0/12)0% (0/18)50% (5/10)25% (1/4)9% (6/68)
Ginn and Cohen3843% (18/42)7% (1/14)0% (0/18)50% (5/10)0% (0/4)32% (24/74)
Haahr et al3935% (12/34)0% (0/14)11% (2/18)10% (1/10)0% (0/4)19% (15/80)
Hay et al4050% (17/34)0% (0/14)11% (2/18)10% (1/10)0% (0/4)25% (20/80)
Kachingwe et al4148% (24/50)10% (1/10)11% (2/18)0% (0/10)0% (0/4)29% (27/92)
Rhon et al4268% (23/34)21% (3/14)0% (0/18)0% (0/10)0% (0/4)32% (26/80)
Szczurko et al4370% (24/34)10% (0/14)28% (5/18)0% (0/10)0% (0/4)36% (29/80)
Winters et al4457% (24/42)7% (1/14)10% (0/18)0% (0/10)0% (0/4)28% (25/88)
Average score51%8%15%14%2.5%29%