Author (year) | Country | Objective | Method Study design | Participants | Sample size | Key conclusions |
Database searches | ||||||
Adlington (2018)40 | UK | Reduce length of stay, bed occupancy and delays in discharge and promote care in the appropriate setting among functional older adults on a psychiatric ward | Quantitative Quality Improvement | Older adults (65+) on psychiatric ward | NR |
|
Ardagh (2011)63 | New Zealand | Identify 10 common challenges and promising initiatives relating to patient flow and emergency department overcrowding | Qualitative NR | NR | NR |
|
Arendts (2013)68 | Australia | Determine if hospital length of stay for older patients is reduced when an allied health intervention is introduced in the emergency department (ED) | Quantitative Non-randomised prospective pragmatic study | ED patients (65+) diagnosed with one or more of six conditions (cerebrovascular insufficiency; fractured neck of femur; cardiac failure; myocardial ischaemia; exacerbation of chronic airways disease; respiratory tract infection) | 3572 |
|
Baumann (2007)55 | UK | Identify the factors causing good discharge practice performance and organisation of services | Qualitative Descriptive | Health/social services staff with managerial involvement in discharges | 42 |
|
Behan (2005)93 | UK | Explore the experience of service users across the UK during the first 6 months of the implementation of the Community Care (Delayed Discharges) Act | Qualitative Explorative | NR | NR |
|
Béland (2006)69 | Canada | Assess the transformation of the organisation and delivery of health and social services with additional interventions for frail elderly people | Quantitative Randomised controlled trial | Frail elderly | 1309 |
|
Blecker (2015)70 | USA | Evaluate the impact of a weekend hospital intervention on care processes, clinical outcomes and length of stay | Quantitative Interrupted time series observational study | Non-obstetric patients hospitalised | 57 163 |
|
Boutette (2018)71 | Canada | Serve frail elderly patients at risk of deconditioning and/or disability, caused by prolonged hospitalisation | NR Review/ description of programme | Frail older patients who are at risk of deconditioning and/or disability | NR |
|
Bowen (2014)72 | UK | Demonstrate that nurse-led discharges can improve efficiency on a short stay surgical ward, without impacting patients safety | Quantitative Case study | Adult ear, nose, throat patients having routine, elective, short stay surgery | 265 |
|
Boyd (2017)41 | USA | Explore the leadership strategies used by hospital business administrators to reduce delayed discharges and improve profitability | Qualitative Multiple case study | Hospital administrators | 3 |
|
Brankline (2009)47 | USA | Provide the appropriate level of care and patient choice when the patient is medically ready for transfer | Quantitative Pilot study | Medical floors with primarily elderly patients who require nursing home placement after discharge | 25 |
|
Brown (2008)64 | USA | Determine if the length of patient stay is reduced in the postanaesthesia care unit when nurses use discharge criteria | Quantitative Prospective clinical study | Adult, ASA physical status I, II, and III patients (18+) requiring general anaesthesia | 1198 |
|
Burr (2017)56 | Canada | Develop a framework that would support ALC avoidance strategies across the Toronto Central Local Health Integration Network | Case study Case study | ALC patients | 3 hospitals |
|
Caminiti (2013)42 | Italy | Evaluate the effectiveness of a strategy aimed to reduce delayed hospital discharge | Quantitative Cluster, parallel group, randomised trial/quality improvement | Hospital units: geriatric, medicine, long-term care | 3498 |
|
Chidwick (2017)54 | Canada | Discuss concepts and ideas that led to lowest ALC days in the province | Mixed methods Quality improvement | ALC patients | NR |
|
El-Eid (2015)73 | Lebanon | Assess the effectiveness of the Six Sigma method in improving discharge processes | Quantitative Pre and post-intervention study | NR | 17 054 |
|
Gaughan (2015)101 | England | Investigate the reduction in hospital bed-blocking due to a greater supply of nursing home beds or reduced costs | Quantitative Statistical modelling - Empirical analysis | Patients waiting for hospital discharge | NR |
|
Graham (2012)74 | UK | Evaluate the effect of the laparoscopic nurse specialist on patient discharge | Quantitative Retrospective comparison | Laparoscopic cholecystectomy and laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair patients | 128 |
|
Gutmanis (2016)65 | Canada | Outline change strategies and their impact health system transformation and those living with responsive behaviours and their family members | Mixed methods Quality improvement | Individuals with responsive behaviours | NR |
|
Henwood (2006)48 | UK | Examine the partnership between health and social care by exploring issues with hospital discharges | Case study Case study | Inpatients | NR |
|
Holland (2016)57 | USA | Report the development and evaluation of a discharge delay tracking and reporting mechanism | Quantitative Practice improvement project | Inpatients | NR |
|
Katsaliaki (2005)102 | UK | Describe a project investigating potential care pathways for elderly people after discharge from hospital | Quantitative Discrete-event simulation, simulation model | Inpatients | NR |
|
Lees-Deutsch (2019)66 | UK | Identify core characteristics of patient discharge criteria, recorded in clinical management plans or case notes | Quantitative Systematic observational retrospective review | Patients discharged from the acute medicine unit and short-stay units | 50 |
|
Levin (2019)94 | Scotland | Examine the impact of Intermediate Care and the 72-hour target on delayed hospital discharge | Quantitative Controlled interrupted time series design | Patients aged 75+ | 107 022 |
|
Lian (2008)58 | Singapore | Develop methods to reduce the hospital length of stay for premature infants by 30%, within 6 months | Quantitative Retrospective review | Premature infants | 78 |
|
Maessen (2008)75 | Netherlands | Assess the effect of enhanced recovery after surgery programme on discharge delays | Quantitative Retrospective/ prospective study | Patients undergoing elective colorectal resection | 173 |
|
Mahant (2008)59 | Canada | Determine if an audit-and-feedback intervention reduces delayed discharge in a general paediatric inpatient unit | Quantitative Prospective observational study | Paediatric inpatient | 3194 |
|
Mahto (2009)76 | UK | Determine the effect of a diabetes outreach service on delayed discharges and avoidable admissions | Quantitative Cross-sectional audit | Acutely admitted patients with diabetes | 137 |
|
Maloney (2007)49 | USA | Develop a web-based software application used to facilitate timely patient discharge | Quantitative Quality improvement pilot project | Inpatients | NR |
|
Manville (2014)95 | Canada | Determine if providing interdisciplinary care on a transitional care unit will result in improved clinical outcomes and lower costs | Quantitative Before-and-after structured retrospective chart audit | Elderly ALC patients (70+) | 135 |
|
Meehan (2018)77 | UK | Explore patients’ experiences of hospital discharge with the discharge to assess scheme | Qualitative Descriptive | Patients discharged through discharge to assess | 30 |
|
Moeller (2006)60 | Canada | Assess patient and physician-related barriers to discharging patients who have met objective criteria | Mixed methods Retrospective assessment | Patients with community-acquired pneumonia | 31 |
|
Mur-Veeman (2011)61 | The Netherlands | Explain the theory of buffer management and discuss related previous assumptions | NR Review/ theoretical paper | Bed blockers | NR |
|
Niemeijer (2010)62 | Netherlands | Reduce the average length of stay to create more admission capacity and reduce costs | Mixed methods Efficiency improvement project (retrospective and prospective data collection) | Trauma patients | 2006:1114 2007:1124 |
|
Panis (2004)78 | Netherlands | Reduce inappropriate hospital stay by adjusting patient logistics, increasing efficiency and providing comfortable surroundings | Quantitative Retrospective cohort study | Mothers of newborn patients | 2889 days of hospital stay of gynaecology and obstetrics patients |
|
Patel (2019)43 | USA | Evaluate the impact of team-based multidisciplinary rounds on discharge planning and care efficiency | Mixed methods Quality improvement initiative | Dissatisfied patients with delayed discharge | 1584 |
|
Ali Pirani (2010)44 | Pakistan | Emphasise the role of nurses to determine factors leading to a lack of discharge planning | NR Review/ summary | Those experiencing delayed discharge | NR |
|
Qin (2017)103 | Australia | Identify which barriers to discharge influence hospital occupancy when targeted by a hospital-wide policy | Quantitative Simulation modelling | NR | NR |
|
Rae (2007)96 | New Zealand | Illustrate how the Delayed Discharge Project solved a bed crisis and controlled expenditure | Quantitative Continuous quality improvement project | Acute general medical | 20 034 |
|
Roberts (2013)50 | Australia | Undertake a preliminary trial of the Goal Length of Stay tool at a rehabilitation centre | Quantitative Prospective study | Inpatients in two units: SRU or BIRU | 202 |
|
Sampson (2006)79 | UK | Describe bed occupancy data in people with diabetes before and after the introduction of a diabetes inpatient specialist nurse service | Quantitative Retrospective study | Diabetes inpatients | 152 080 |
|
Shah (2007)97 | England | Examine the impact of the Community Care (Delayed Discharge) Act on bed occupancy and length of stay in Geriatric Medicine (GM) and Old Age Psychiatry (OAP) services | Quantitative Retrospective study | Inpatient - specialties of GM and OAP services | NR |
|
Sobotka (2017)51 | USA | Describe a hospital-to-home transitional care model | Case study Illustrative case design/ review | Paediatric inpatient | 1 |
|
Starr-Hemburrow (2011)80 | Canada | Minimise the number of post-acute patients transitioning from hospital to long-term care and develop an integrated plan for appropriate care and placement | Quantitative Quality improvement | ALC patients | NR |
|
Sutherland (2013)45 | Canada | Describe structural challenges to reduce the impact of ALC patients and to propose policy alternatives that could reduce occupancy | NR Discussion and debate article | ALC patients | NR |
|
Taber (2013)81 | USA | Test a programme to improve length of stay, delayed discharges and early readmissions for kidney transplant recipients | Quantitative Observational study | Adult kidney transplant recipients | 476 |
|
Udayai (2012)82 | India | Reduce patient discharge time through a Six Sigma project | Quantitative Time motion study | Cash patients | NR |
|
Williams (2010)52 | Australia | Examine the impact of a critical care outreach service on frequency of discharge delay from the intensive care unit | Quantitative Prospective cohort study | Patients discharged from the ICU | 1123 |
|
Younis (2011)53 | UK | Compare the effect of an enhanced recovery programme with preoperative stoma education on the number of patients with prolonged hospital stay | Quantitative Prospective study | Patients undergoing anterior resection with the formation of a loop ileostomy | 120 |
|
Grey literature | ||||||
Anonymous (2008)99 | USA | Create an expedited discharge fund to pay for goods and services inhibiting a patient’s discharge (medical equipment, medication and transportation) | N/A News article | Uninsured patients | NR |
|
Anonymous (2010)46 | USA | Improve patient flow through initiatives that decrease length of stay and increase capacity | N/A News article | NR | NR |
|
Calveley (2007)83 | UK | Create a tier of support to reduce the unnecessary and costly occupation of hospital beds | N/A Review | NR | NR |
|
Manzano-Santaella (2009)100 | UK | Analyse the relationship between Payment by Results and the Delayed Discharges Act | N/A Policy analysis | NR | NR |
|
Krystal (2019)86 | Canada | NR | Mixed methods Continuous quality improvement and evaluation | Medically and socially complex and frail elderly | 100+ |
|
Walker (2011)2 | Canada | Develop recommendations of care for frail Canadians | N/A N/A | NR | NR |
|
North West Community Care Access Centre (2011)88 | Canada | Create a fact sheet of the benefits of staying at home and using Wait at Home (enhanced home care services while people wait for long-term care) | N/A N/A | Seniors waiting for LTC placement | NR |
|
Toronto Central Community Care Access Centre (2015)67 | Canada | NR | N/A N/A | NR | NR |
|
Province of New Brunswick (2017)92 | Canada | Identify priority strategic initiatives and implement community support orders across the province | N/A Annual report | NR | NR |
|
NHS Improvement (2018)104 | UK | Create a how-to guide explaining implementation approaches to reduce length of stay | N/A Guide | NR | NR |
|
Starr-Hemburrow (2010)91 | Canada | Improve patient flow through the implementation of change management initiatives | Quantitative Quality improvement | NR | NR |
|
LHIN Collaborative (2011)87 | Canada | Help support patients in their homes for as long as possible by providing them with community supports | N/A Implementation guide and toolkit | Patients (specifically high needs seniors) | NR |
|
Shah (2011)90 | Canada | Ensure the appropriate community resources are in place to support the patient on discharge | N/A Implementation guide and toolkit | High need seniors (75+) | NR |
|
Central East LHIN ALC Task Group (2008)84 | Canada | Understand the impact of delayed discharges in the Central East regions of Ontario (reviewing data, reading reports, initiating a pilot study, developing a patient flow map) | N/A Report | ALC patients | NR |
|
Adams, Care & Repair England (2017)98 | UK | Assist older patients in returning home from hospital quickly and safely | Case study Case study | Older patients | 1 |
|
Shah (2010)89 | Canada | Describe the Home First approach, a philosophy for reducing ALC | Quantitative Quality improvement | Elderly patients | NR |
|
Joint Improvement Team (2013)85 | Scotland | Identify 10 action items to transform discharge processes | N/A Quality improvement/ stakeholder engagement | N/A | NR |
|
ALC, alternate level of care; BIRU, brain injury rehabilitation unit; GM, geriatric medicine; ICU, intensive care unit; N/A, not applicable; NR, not reported; OAP, old age psychiatry; SRU, stroke rehabilitation unit.