Synopsis of 24 identified studies
Author | Country | RCT | Intervention | Type of safety metric | Unit of measurement | Impact |
Abramson | USA | No | Transition between EHRs | Medication safety | Clinicians | n.s. |
Adelman | USA | Yes | Change in version of EHR | System safety: wrong patient orders | Clinicians | Identification-re-entry function resulted in lower error rate (p<0.001). |
Awdishu | USA | Yes | Notification: AKI | Medication safety: AKI | Clinicians | Adjusted prescriptions increased (p<0.001). |
Barnett | USA | No | Transition between EHRs | Adverse event reporting: PSI-90, death and readmissions | Patients | n.s. |
Boockvar | USA | Yes | Link to community EHR | Medication safety: Reconciliation | Patients | n.s. |
Cardozo | USA | No | Notification: Trauma | Clinical pathway: cervical-spine clearance protocol | Patients | Improved compliance rate with pathway. |
Cho | USA | No | EHR generated lists | Alerts | Clinical unit | Reduction in catheter related infections (p<0.05). |
Cho | Korea | No | Notification: Falls risk assessment | Falls | Patients | Unchanged rate of falls. |
Colpaert | Belgium | No | Transition to electronic system | Medication safety | Patients | Reduction in prescription errors (p<0.001). |
Cook | USA | No | Transition to electronic system | Medication safety: antibiotic prescribing | Patients | Reduction in nosocomial infections (p<0.07). |
Dowding | USA | No | Transition to electronic system | Hospital acquired pressure ulcers and falls | Patients | Increased documentation rates for hospital acquired pressure ulcers. |
Fahey | USA | No | Change in version of EHR | Medication safety: wrong dosage of chemotherapy | Clinicians | Decrease in dosage error (n=0) compared with manual rounding (n=4). |
Hess | USA | No | Transition from paper to electronic system | Medication safety: wrong dosage in chemotherapy | Clinicians | n.s. |
Mishra | USA | No | Notification: Medication dosage | Medication safety: monitoring of Vancomycin dosage | Patients | Increase in frequency of trough levels (p<0.01). |
Mohsen | USA | No | Change in version of EHR | Venous thrombembolism Reduction in inappropriate alerts | Patients | Alert reduction (p<0.001), increase in alert effectiveness (p<0.001), but decrease in alert efficiency (p=0.007). |
Muhlenkamp | USA | Yes | Notification: Dosage alerts | Medication safety: removal of inappropriate or unnecessary alerts | Patients | Decrease in dosage alerts by 3.6%. |
Nanchal | USA | Yes | Change in version of EHR | ICU handover: occurrence of non-routine events | Clinicians | Structured sign-out process reduced the occurrence of non-routine events reported by residents (p=0.005). |
Nendaz | Switzerland | Yes | Notification: VTE risk assessment | Medication safety: decision support for VTE prophylaxis | Patients | Less overprescribing with e-alerts (p<0.01). |
Schnipper | USA | Yes | Medication Reconciliation | Medication safety: adverse drug events | Patients | Changes significant at discharge but not admission. |
Silbernagel | Switzerland | Yes | Notification: Complications of Atrial fibrillation | Medication safety: anticoagulation | Patients | Adequate prescription increased from 16% to 22% (p=0.021). |
Spirk | Switzerland | Yes | Notification: VTE prophylaxis | Medication safety: VTE prophylaxis | Patients | n.s. |
Weiss | USA | Yes | Checklist in EHR | Medication Safety: Antibiotic prescribing | Patients | Increase in number of days with empirical antibiotics (p<0.002). |
Westbrook | Australia | No | Implementation of two EHRs | Medication Safety | Patients | 44% reduction in serious errors, increase in system errors. |
Wilson | USA | Yes | Notification: AKI | Medication Safety: AKI | Patients | Increase in creatinine checks (p<0.05) and reduction in deaths and dialysis (p<0.01) only in surgical stratum. |
AKI, acute kidney injury; EHR, electronic health record; ICU, intensive care unit; n.s., not significant; PSI, Patient Safety Indicator (PSI-90); PSI-90, Patient Safety and Adverse Events Composite for the International Classification of Diseases; RCT, randomised controlled trial; VTE, venous thromboembolism.