Table 1

Description and intended use of tools to support delayed prescribing of musculoskeletal imaging

Overdiagnosis LeafletDialogue SheetWait-and-see Note
Why: rationaleGoalGoalGoal
Promote watchful waiting for people with low back pain.Promote watchful waiting for people with musculoskeletal pain (including low back pain).Promote watchful waiting for people with musculoskeletal pain (including low back pain).
Raise awareness of non-essential or ‘low-value’ lumbar imaging tests.Support doctor–patient communication and joint decision-making.Support doctor–patient communication and joint decision-making.
Provide actions for patients to take to address their pain, as alternatives to imaging.
What: materials and content6-panel A4 folded leaflet1-page A5 sheet2-sided A6 note
Designed by advertising company and researchers.Designed by the Department of Health and researchers.Designed by the Department of Health and researchers.
Key messagesKey messagesKey message
Unnecessary lumbar scans can cause harm.In your case I think imaging is unnecessary.The referral is a backup; only to be used under specific circumstances (tailored to the patient).
There are alternatives to imaging.I recommend we delay decision to have a scan.
Speak to your doctor.There are other actions you can take to address your pain.
Behavioural promptsBehavioural promptsBehavioural prompts
Framing of harms from overdiagnosis.Present no imaging as the default.Present no imaging as the default.
Appeal to authority (quote from orthopaedic surgeon)Co-signature (patient and doctor) commitment to delay.Co-signature (patient and doctor) commitment to delay.
Tailoring: to the individualNone.Space to describe symptoms, things to look out for, name and date, customisable reasons to delay, and recommended actions to manage pain and assist recovery.Review date and things to look out for.