Table 2

Main characteristics of included studies interventions

Author(s) and yearIntervention groupControl groupLasers characteristics
Brugnera et al 1997201. Nd:YAG laser
2. Sealant
3. Nd:YAG laser+sealant
No treatmentCO2
Pulsed emission; rate repetition: 7 Hz; pulse duration: 20 ms
Durmus et al 201721Er:YAG laser+orthophosphoric acidOrthophosphoric acidEr:YAG laser
Wavelength: 2.94 µm; non-contact mode; pulse energy: 120 mJ; repetition rate: 10 Hz; spot size: 0.6 mm
Goodis et al 2004221. High energy CO2 (4.8 J)
2. Low energy CO2 (2.4 J)
Sham procedureCO2 laser
Wavelength: 9.6 mm; pulse duration: 5–8 µs; rate repetition: 10 Hz; energy density: 1.5 J/cm2; pulse energy: 12 mJ
Karaman et al 201323Er,Cr:YSGG laserOrthophosphoric acidEr,Cr:YSGG laser
Wavelength: 2.78 µm; pulsed emission; no contact mode; spot size: 600 µm; repetition rate: 10 Hz; power: 125 W
Kumar et al 201624Er,Cr:YSGG laserOrthophosphoric acidEr,Cr:YSGG laser
Wavelength: 2.78 µm; pulsed emission; no contact mode; spot size: 600 µm; repetition rate: 20 Hz; power: 1.5 W
Nammour et al 2003 and 200525 261. Fluoride gel
2. Argon laser+fluoride gel
No treatmentArgon laser
Continuous emission; energy density: 10.74 J/cm2; spot size: 11 mm; irradiation duration: 30 s; pulse power: 340 mW
Raucci-Neto et al 2015271. Nd:YAG laser
2. Nd:YAG laser+fluoride gel
3. Nd:YAG laser+fluoride variant
4. Sealant
  1. Fluoride varnish

  2. Fluoride gel

  3. No treatment

Nd:YAG laser
Wavelength: 1.064 νm; pulsed emission; spot size: 300 µm; pulse duration: 100 µs; rate repetition: 10–100 Hz; irradiation duration: 30 s; energy density: 73.9 J/cm2; power: 50 W
Walsh 199628CO2 laserOrthophosphoric acidCO2 laser
Pulsed emission; spot size: 800 µm; rate repetition: 20 Hz; pulse duration: 20 ms; power: 5 W; irradiation duration: 7 s
Zezell et al 2009291. Nd:YAG laser
2. Sealant
3. Nd:YAG laser+sealant
No treatmentCO2 laser
Pulsed emission; rate repetition: 7 Hz; pulse duration 20 ms
  • Er,Cr:YSGG, erbium, chromium: yttrium scandium gallium garnet; Er:YAG, erbium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet; Nd:YAG, neodymium-doped yttrium aluminium garnet.