Table 1

Characteristics of included studies and summary of outcomes from individual studies

CitationPeriod of studyLocation(s) (setting)Environmental samplePositive samples, %Mean concentration or range (GC/L)Genotypes
South Africa
 Rachida et al252013Cato Ridge, KZN (Kwa Zulu-Natal (urban)Surface water72.7 (8/11)NRV
 Osuolale and Okoh262012–2013Eastern Cape (urban)Treated sewage8.6 (6/70)NRNR
 Adefisoye et al272012–2013Stutterheim (urban)Raw and treated sewage6.3 (3/48)NRNR
 Saïd et al192012Gauteng (urban)Surface water and treated sewage48.6 (35/70)NRIB
 Chigor and Okoh202010–2011Buffalo River (rural)Surface water41.3 (31/72)1.5E+01 to 1.9E+05NR
 Venter et al211997–2000Gauteng (urban)Surface water16.2 (50/308)NRNR
Mozambique
 Nenonen et al282004Maputo Bay (Urban)Shellfish33.3 (23/69)NRIB
Uganda
 O’Brien et al292016Kampala/Nakivubo (urban)Raw and treated sewage, surface water (swamp)46.7 (28/60)5.88E+03 to 1.0E+04 (RS)NR
1.41E+03 to 1.11+04 (TS)
2.73E+03 (SW)
 Katukiza et al302011Kampala (urban)Treated sewage17.1 (7/41)NRNR
Kenya
 Kiulia et al312007–2008Nairobi (urban)Surface water (river), raw sewage21.95 (9/41)NRNR
Tunisia
 Jebri et al322012North Tunis (urban)Raw and treated sewage0.0 (0/48)NR
 Ouardani et al332009–2010Kairouan (urban)Raw and treated sewage53.9 (146/271)6.7E+01 to 5.6E+07 (RS)IA, IB
7.2E+01 to 1.4E+08 (TS)
 Ouardani et al342009–2010Parkside (rural)Raw and treated sewage39.7 (129/325)4.29E+03 (RS)NR
1.56E+03 (TS)
 Gharbi-Khelifi et al352009El-Mahres (urban)Groundwater (well)50 (5/10)NRIA
 Béji-Hamza et al362007–2008Mahdia (urban)Raw and treated sewage66.7 (100/150)7.3E+01 to 4.33E+06 (RS)IA, IB
2.56E+03 to 2.32E+06 (TS)
 Amri et al372007–2008Lake Tunis (urban)Shellfish31.48 (17/54)NRNR
 Hassine et al382005–2006Monastir (urban)Raw sewage11.82 (11/93)NRNR
 Gharbi-Khelifi et al392000–2001Goz Amir (urban)Raw and treated sewage35.41 (17/48)NRNR
 Elamri et al402000–2001Northern Tunisia (urban)Shellfish26.1 (6/23)NRNR
Morocco
 Amdiouni et al412009Casablanca (urban)Raw sewage8.0 (4/50)NRNR
 Benabbes et al422006–2010Atlantic Coast (urban)Shellfish2.6 (2/77)1.0E+02NR
Chad
 Guerrero-Latorre et al432009Dogdore (urban)Ground and surface water0.0 (0/16)NRNR
Pakistan
 Ahmad et al442016–2017Lahore (urban)Surface water8.6 (6/70)NRIA
 Ahmad et al452014Peshawar (rural)Raw sewage12.63 (12/95)NRNR
 Ahmad et al462013Faisalabad (urban)Raw sewage and surface water4.0 (3/75)NRNR
 Khan et al472011Mardan (urban)Raw and treated sewage and vegetables10.3 (3/29)NRNR
India
 Chobe and Arankalle482007Shimla (urban)Raw and treated sewage, surface water80 (4/5)NRIIIA
 Arankalle et al492005Kottayam-Kerala (urban)Raw sewage and surface water17.64 (3/17)1.0E+02 to 2.6E+03 (RS)NR
 Umesha et al502003–2005Sasthan, Mulki (urban)Shellfish0.0 (0/194)NRIIIA
 Phanuwan et al512005Kampung Melayu (urban)Surface water70.58 (12/17)NRNR
 Chadha et al522004Daund, Pune (rural)Raw sewage and groundwater33.3 (1/3)NRIIIA
 Chitambar et al532002Pune (urban)Raw sewage90 (9/10)NRIB, IIIA
Philippines
 Bai et al542012–2013Metro Manila (urban)Surface water58.3 (7/12)NRIA, IIIA
  • GC/L, genome copies per litre; NR, not reported; RS, raw sewage; SW, surface water; TS, treated sewage.