Table 1

Nominal group meeting structure

PhaseActivity
Informed consentFacilitator (BC) talks through participant information sheets and consent forms and answers any questions. Participants sign consent forms.
1: IntroductionFacilitator introduces the topic, explains our interest in it and asks participants to introduce themselves.
2: Silent reflectionParticipants read the scenario and write comments.
3: Round robinFacilitator elicits one comment from each participant and writes this on a flip chart. Discussion not allowed. Continues until comments exhausted.
4: DiscussionFacilitator guides discussion of comments on each scenario in turn, using open-ended questions and ensuring all participants had the opportunity to contribute their perspective.
5: VotingParticipants vote whether the scenario is acceptable or not. (undecided was also permitted)
6: RepeatProcesses 2 to 5 are repeated in turn for each scenario.
7: BreakFacilitator counts votes.
8: DiscussionResults of votes presented and discussed. Each scenario without clear majority is discussed in turn.
9: VotingSecond round of voting if no clear majority in first round of voting.
10: ConclusionResults of vote. Facilitator explains future plans and thanks participants.