Sample characteristics | N (%) |
Research experience | |
PhD student | 43 (80) |
Post-doctoral student | 11 (20) |
Affiliation regarding the current paper | |
First author | 50 (93) |
Coauthor | 4 (7) |
Study design | |
Systematic review | 10 (19) |
Randomised controlled study | 11 (20) |
Observational study (cross-sectional, cohort, case-control) | 33 (61) |
Previous reporting guidelines use* | |
No, it will be my first time to use reporting guidelines | 27 (50) |
Yes, to write or co-write a paper | 13 (22) |
Yes, to write this paper | 11 (17) |
Yes, to review a paper | 2 (2) |
Frequency of reporting guidelines use | |
Never | 19 (35) |
Rarely | 12 (22) |
Sometimes | 9 (17) |
Usually | 12 (22) |
Every time | 2 (4) |
Motivation of guideline use*† | |
Self-motivation or motivation from colleagues or coauthors | 12 (22) |
Journal suggestions to use checklists within the writing process | 1 (2) |
Journal requirements to fill the checklist at the end | 5 (9) |
Subjective knowledge | |
How do you rank your knowledge with respect to the content of the reporting guideline?‡ | |
Very knowledgeable | 3 (6) |
Somewhat knowledgeable | 17 (31) |
Neither knowledgeable nor unknowledgeable | 8 (15) |
Somewhat unknowledgeable | 10 (19) |
Very unknowledgeable | 15 (28) |
How do you rank your knowledge with respect to the utilisation of the reporting guideline? | |
Very knowledgeable | 2 (4) |
Somewhat knowledgeable | 17 (31) |
Neither knowledgeable nor unknowledgeable | 9 (17) |
Somewhat knowledgeable | 11 (20) |
Very unknowledgeable | 15 (28) |
Objective Knowledge | |
Answer the following statement with true or false (frequency of the correct answer) | |
The checklist should be used to evaluate the quality of papers* ( FALSE) | 9 (17) |
The reporting checklists must be completely filled, or my paper will be rejected† ( FALSE) | 37 (69) |
It is acceptable to report that some items on the checklist are not applicable to my study* ( TRUE) | 49 (91) |
Reporting on items that are not carried out will add more clarity to my paper and will not lead to rejection* ( TRUE) | 36 (69) |
The checklists aim to make reporting more clear, complete and transparent*(TRUE) | 51 (94) |
The checklist aim to improve communication between coauthor* ( FALSE) | 34 (63) |
*Indicate a multiple-response question.
†n = 27
‡n=53