Table 2

Data extraction framework

Main categorySubcategoryDescription
1. Author
2. Title
3. Journal
4. Year of publication
5. Aim/objectivesDescribe the stated aim and objectives
6. Year of research-
7. LocationIndicate the country(ies) where the study was conducted
8. Study settingSpecify the location of the study sites (eg, district(s) in which study was conducted)
9. Policy change
Content of policy changeDescribe the maternal health policy being evaluated
Date of policy changeNote the month/year in which the policy change was implemented
10. Approach to health policy analysis
Framework and theoriesIndicate analytical framework used (if any) to evaluate maternal health policies
Scope of analysisIndicate stages of policy process included (eg, agenda setting, policy development, policy implementation, policy outcomes)
11. Methodology to evaluate health outcomes
Study designSpecify study design adopted (eg, case study, cross-sectional design, pre–post study design)
PopulationDescribe specific characteristics of target population
Data sourceSpecify data sources (eg, primary, secondary)
Sampling strategyDescribe how sampling (if any) was done
Data collectionDescribe the methods of data collection (none if secondary)
Data analysisSpecify how data were analysed
No of years of dataSpecify period of time of data analysis (prepolicy and postpolicy implementation)
Outcome measuresIndicate outcome measures adopted (eg, use of maternal health services, proportion of deliveries attended by skilled health personnel)
12. ResultsPolicy processDescribe findings of analysis of policy process relating to introduction of maternal health policy
Reported outcomesDiscuss change in selected outcome measures of maternal health
Patient and public perspectiveDiscuss any reporting of perspectives of patients or the public with regard to the policy, its implementation or its impact
13. ConclusionImpactIndicate conclusion of study regarding overall impact of maternal health policy
FacilitatorsDescribe factors that support implementation of the maternal health policy
BarriersDescribe factors that inhibit implementation of the maternal health policy
14. LimitationsDescribe shortcomings of the study