Characteristics of included studies (n=35)
Study | Year | Setting | N of part | Age | Study type | Follow-up (months) | Trial reg | No. of arms | P cal |
Molars | |||||||||
Koch and Garcia-Godoy 44 | 2000 | Uni. H | 12 | 6–8 | Pro Co | 24–60 | n | 3 | n |
Lygidakis et al 45 | 2003 | Uni. H | 46 | 8–10 | Pro Co | 48 | n | 1 | n |
Zagdwon et al 46 | 2003 | Uni. H | 17 | 6–16 | RCT | 12–24 | n | 2 | y |
Kotsanos et al 32 | 2005 | Uni. H | 72 | 8 | Retro Co | 52 | n | 4 | n |
Mejàre et al 33 | 2005 | Uni. H | 76 | 6–17 | Retro Co | 62 | n | 7 | n |
Jälevik and,Möller47 | 2007 | Uni. H | 27 | 6–13 | Retro Co | 44–99 | n | 1 | n |
Lygidakis et al 48 | 2009 | Uni. H | 47 | 6–7 | RCT | 48 | n | 2 | n |
Baroni and Marchionni 49 | 2011 | Uni. H | 30 | 6–9 | Pro Co | 36 | n | 1 | n |
Gaardmand et al 50 | 2013 | Uni. H | 33 | 8–18 | Retro Co | 39 | n | 1 | n |
Cabasse et al 51 | 2015 | Uni. H | 39 | 9 | Pro Co | n | n | 1 | n |
Fragelli et al 52 | 2015 | Uni. H | 21 | 6–9 | Pro Co | 12 | n | 1 | n |
Bekes et al 53 | 2016 | Uni. H | 16 | 8 | Pro Co | 2 | n | 2 | y |
Bakkal et al 54 | 2017 | Uni. H | 38 | 7–12 | RCT | 1 | n | 2 | n |
de Souza et al 55 | 2017 | Uni. H | 18 | 6–8 | RCT | 18 | y | 2 | n |
Fragelli et al 56 | 2017 | Uni. H | 21 | 6–8 | RCT | 18 | n | 2 | y |
Sönmez and Saat 57 | 2017 | Uni. H | 42 | 8–12 | RCT | 24 | n | 4 | n |
Dixit and Joshi 58 | 2018 | Uni. H | 32 | 8–14 | RCT | n/a | n | 2 | y |
Folayan et al 59 | 2018 | Uni. H | 73 | 8–16 | Pro Co | n/a | n | 2 | n |
Grossi et al 60 | 2018 | Uni. H | 40 | 7–13 | Pro Co | 12 | y | 1 | n |
Koleventi et al 61 | 2018 | Uni. H | 14 | 11 | Pro Co | 6 | n | 2 | n |
Pasini et al 62 | 2018 | Uni. H | 40 | 8–13 | Pro Co | 4 | n | 2 | n/a |
Dhareula et al 63 | 2019 | Uni. H | 30 | 8–13 | RCT | 36 | y | 2 | y |
Incisors | |||||||||
Wong and Winter 64 | 2002 | Uni. H | 15 | n/a | RCT | 6 | n | 1 | n |
Özgül et al 65 | 2013 | Uni. H | 33 | 7–12 | RCT | 1 | n | 6 | n |
Sheoran et al 66 | 2014 | Uni. H | 25 | 11–13 | RCT | 1 | n | 2 | n |
Restrepo et al 67 | 2016 | Uni. H | 51 | 9–12 | Pro Co | 1 | n | 2 | y |
Bhandari et al 68 | 2018 | Uni. H | n/a | 7–16 | Pro Co | 6 | n | 1 | n |
Hasmun et al 69 | 2018 | Uni. H | 111 | 7–16 | Pro Co | n/a | n | 1 | y |
Only registered | |||||||||
DRKS00009760 | 2016 | Uni. H | 40 | 6–70 | RCT | 6 | y | 2 | n |
DRKS00011882 | 2017 | Uni. H | 300 | 7–14 | Pro Co | 0,5 | y | 3 | n/a |
NCT03614819 | 2018 | Uni. H | 122 | 6–10 | RCT | 24 | y | 2 | n/a |
NCT03760497 | 2018 | Uni. H | 300 | 6–10 | RCT | 24 | y | 3 | n/a |
NCT03826810 | 2019 | Uni. H | 48 | n/a | RCT | 12 | y | 2 | n/a |
NCT03870958 | 2019 | Uni. H | 195 | 6–9 | RCT | 36 | y | 2 | n/a |
NCT03862014 | 2019 | Uni. H | 100 | 6–10 | RCT | 24 | y | 2 | n/a |
Studies were separated according to target condition (MIH in molars or incisors), and ordered chronologically.
N of part, number of participants; P cal, power calculation; Pro Co, prospective cohort; RCT, randomised controlled trial; Retro Co, retrospective cohort; Trial reg, trial registration; Uni. H, University hospital; n, no;n/a, not available; y, yes.