Study | Year Country | Type of neurodisability | Intervention | Study design | Child outcomes Sleep Other | Parent outcomes | Adverse events | |
Melatonin | ||||||||
Appleton et al 13 | 2012 UK | DD alone or with other condition | Melatonin | Parallel RCT | X | X | X | X |
Camfield et al 20 | 1996 Canada | Mixed | Melatonin | N of 1 crossover RCT | X | |||
Cortesi et al 17 | 2012 Italy | ASD | Melatonin | Parallel RCT | X | X | X | |
Van der Heijden et al 18 | 2007 Netherlands | ADHD | Melatonin | Parallel RCT | X | X | X | |
Dodge and Wilson23 | 2001 USA | Mixed | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | X | ||
Garstang and Wallis21 | 2006 UK | ASD with or without LD | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | |||
Hancock et al 25 | 2005 UK | Tuberous sclerosis | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | X | ||
Jain et al 16 | 2015 USA | Epilepsy | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | X | X | |
Jan et al 24 | 2000 Canada | Mixed | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | X | ||
Wasdell et al 14 | 2008 Canada | Mixed | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | X | ||
Weiss et al 15 | 2006 Canada | ADHD | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | x | X | X | |
Wirojanan et al 19 | 2009 USA | Mixed | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | X | ||
Wright et al 22 | 2011 UK | Mixed | Melatonin | Crossover RCT | X | X | ||
Non-pharmacological | ||||||||
Adkins et al 28 | 2012 USA | Mixed | Parent-directed, non-tailored | Parallel RCT | X | |||
Austin et al 36 | 2013 Australia | Mixed | Parent-directed, tailored | Before-after | X | X | ||
Beresford3 | 2012 UK | Mixed | Parent-directed, tailored | Parallel RCT | X | X | ||
Beresford3 Intervention 2 | 2012 UK | Mixed | Parent-directed, tailored | Before-after | X | X | ||
Beresford3
Intervention 3 | 2012 UK | Mixed | Parent-directed non-tailored | Before-after | X | X | ||
Beresford3
Intervention 4 | 2012 UK | Mixed | Parent-directed non-tailored | Before-after | X | X | ||
Bramble60 | 1997 UK | Mixed | Parent-directed non-tailored | Before-after | X | X | X | |
Francis and Dempster31 | 2002 Australia | Mixed | Valerian | Crossover RCT | X | X | ||
Gringras et al 34 | 2014 UK | Mixed | Weighted blanket | Crossover RCT | X | X | X | |
Guilleminault et al 32 | 1993 USA | LD | Light therapy+behavioural programme | Before-after | X | |||
Hiscock et al 27 | 2015 Australia | ADHD plus LD or ASD | Parent-directed, tailored | Parallel RCT | X | X | X | |
Johnson et al 26 | 2013 USA | Autism and ASD | Parent-directed, tailored | Parallel RCT | X | |||
Malow et al 39 | 2014 USA | Mixed | Parent-directed non-tailored | Parallel RCT | X | X | ||
Montgomery et al 61 | 2004 UK | Mixed | Parent-directed non-tailored | Parallel RCT | X | |||
Moss et al 62 | 2014 Australia | Mixed | Parent-directed, tailored | Parallel RCT | X | X | X | |
Oriel et al 35 | 2016 USA | ASD | Aquatic exercise programme | A-B-A | X | |||
Peppers et al 63 | 2016 USA | NR | Non-comprehensive, parent-directed | Before-after | X | X | X | |
Piazza et al 64 | 1997 USA | Mixed | Behavioural | Parallel RCT | X | |||
Quine and Wade65 | 1991 UK | LD | Parent-directed, tailored | Before-after | X | X | X | |
Reed et al 29 | 2009 Canada | ASD | Parent-directed non-tailored | Before-after | X | X | X | |
Sciberras et al 41 | 2011 Australia | ADHD | Parent-directed, tailored | Parallel RCT | X | X | X | |
Weiskop et al 33 | 2005 Australia | Mixed | Parent-directed, tailored | Before-after | X | |||
Wiggs and Stores30 | 1998 UK | Mixed | Non-comprehensive, parent-directed | RCT | X | X | X | |
Yehuda et al 66 | 2011 Israel | ADHD | Essential fatty acids | Controlled before-after | X | X | X | |
Yu et al 42 | 2015 Hong Kong | ASD and Asperger syndrome | Parent-directed non-tailored | Before-after | X | X | X | |
Yu and Hong67 | 2012 China | LD | Acupuncture and earpoint taping | Before-after | X |
10Definitions for how studies were classified as parent-directed and tailored/non-tailored are available in the effectiveness review report (www.journalslibrary.nihr.ac.uk/programmes/hta/1421202/#/).
ADHD, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; ASD, autism spectrum disorder; DD, developmental delay; LD, learning disability; NR, not reported; RCT, randomised controlled trial.