Table 4

Risk of bias assessment

Author, yearWas the randomisation sequence adequately generated?Was allocation adequately concealed?Was there blinding of participants?Was there blinding of caregivers?Was there blinding of data collectors?Was there blinding of data analyst?Was there blinding of outcome assessors?Was loss to follow-up (missing outcome data) infrequent?Are reports of the study free of suggestion of selective outcome reporting?Was the study apparently free of other problems that could put it at a risk of bias?
Apariman,
200644
Definitely yesProbably noDefinitely yesProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably noDefinitely yesProbably yesProbably yes
Deng, 200645; Deng, 201046 Definitely yesProbably yesProbably yesProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably noDefinitely yesProbably yesProbably yes
Gharabaghi, 201147 Probably noProbably noDefinitely yesDefinitely yesProbably yesProbably noProbably yesDefinitely yesProbably noDefinitely yes
Huang, 199648 Probably yesProbably yesProbably yesProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably noDefinitely yesProbably yesDefinitely no
Nanthakomon, 200649 Probably yesProbably yesDefinitely yesDefinitely yesProbably yesProbably noProbably yesDefinitely yesProbably noProbably yes
Pietri, 199750 Probably yesProbably noProbably yesProbably yesProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably no
Safaei, 201751 Definitely yesDefinitely yesDefinitely yesProbably yesDefinitely yesProbably noDefinitely yesDefinitely yesProbably yesDefinitely yes
Wang, 200852 Definitely yesProbably yesProbably yesProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably noDefinitely yesProbably yesProbably no
Xie, 200353 Definitely yesProbably yesDefinitely yesDefinitely noDefinitely noDefinitely noDefinitely noDefinitely yesProbably yesDefinitely no
Zeraati, 201654 Definitely yesProbably yesDefinitely yesProbably yesProbably yesProbably noProbably noDefinitely yesProbably yesDefinitely yes
Zhou, 200055 Probably yesProbably yesProbably yesProbably noProbably noProbably noProbably noDefinitely yesProbably yesDefinitely no
  • All answers as: definitely yes (low risk of bias), probably yes, probably no, definitely no (high risk of bias).