Table 1

Baseline characteristics of included studies

StudyCountryDesignDevice (manufacturer)Patient characteristicsTotal sample size
(C reactive protein (CRP)/no CRP)
1. Randomised controlled trials
(a) Patients presenting with signs of respiratory tract infection
 Andreeva and Melbye42 RussiaClusterAfinion
(Axis Shield)
Adults with lower respiratory tract infection (LRTI)/acute cough for less than 28 days.179
(101/78)
 Cals et al 19 The NetherlandsClusterNycoCard II (Axis Shield)Adults with suspected LRTI (cough <4 weeks, +1 focal and +1 systemic symptom or sign).431
(227/204)
 Cals et al 20 The NetherlandsIndividualNycoCard II (Axis Shield)Adult with LRTI (cough <4 weeks, +1 focal and +1 systemic symptom or sign) or rhinosinusitis <4 weeks, +2 symptoms or signs.258
(129/129)
 Cals et al 43 The NetherlandsClusterNycoCard II (Axis Shield)Adults with suspected LRTI (cough <4 weeks, +1 focal and +1 systemic symptom or sign).379
(203/176)
 Diederichsen et al 53 DenmarkIndividualNycoCard II (Axis Shield)Children and adults with respiratory tract infection.812
(414/398)
 Do et al 54 VietnamIndividualNycoCard II (Axis Shield)Children and adults with at least one focal and one systemic symptom of acute respiratory tract infection.2037
(1017/1019)
 Little et al 21 Spain, England, Wales (UK), Poland, Belgium, the NetherlandsClusterQuikRead
(Orion Diagnostica)
Adults with upper or LRTI less than 28 days.4264
(2224/2040)
 Melbye et al 44 NorwayIndividualNycoCard II (Axis Shield)Adults with subjective complaint of pneumonia, bronchitis or asthma or 1 of: cough, shortness of breath, chest pain on deep inspiration or cough.239
(108/131)
(b) Patients presenting with signs of any acute illness
 Lemiengre et al 57 (also Verbakel et al 9)BelgiumClusterAfinion
(Alere)
Children with an acute illness less than 5 days.3147
(1730/1417)
 Rebnord et al 51 NorwayIndividualQuikRead Go (Orion Diagnostica)Children with fever and/or respiratory symptoms.397
(138/259)
 Van den Bruel et al 52 UKIndividualAfinion (Alere)Children with an acute illness less than  5  days.54
(26/28)
2. Non-randomised trials
(a) Patients presenting with signs of respiratory tract infection
 Bjerrum55 DenmarkCohortNot specifiedChildren and adults with acute sinusitis, acute tonsillitis, and acute otitis.367
(281/86)
 Fagan45 NorwayCohortNot specifiedAdults treated for acute bronchitis.324
(122/202)
 Hughes46 Wales (UK)Before–afterAfinion
(Alere)
Adults with symptoms of respiratory tract infection and other.94
(not specified)
 Kavanagh et al 47 IrelandBefore–afterQuikRead (Orion Diagnostica)Adults with acute cough and/or sore throat less than 1 month.120
(60/60)
 Llor et al 48 SpainBefore–afterNycoCard II
(Axis Shield)
Adults with acute sinusitis, acute tonsillitis, and acute otitis.161
(43/118)
 Llor et al 49
 (also Llor et al 67)
SpainBefore–afterNycoCard II
(Axis Shield)
Adults with uncomplicated acute illness (<7 days) with cough as the main symptom and 2+ signs or symptoms of LRTI (increase in sputum volume or purulence, chest pain and/or worsening of dyspnoea).836
(208/628)
 Peters et al 56 The NetherlandsCase–controlNycoCard II
(Axis Shield)
Children and adults with an intellectual disability suspected of LRTI.1472
(882/590)
(b) Patients presenting with signs of any acute illness
 Jakobsen et al 50 Norway, Sweden, Wales (UK)CohortNycoCard II
(Axis Shield) and QuikRead (Orion Diagnostica)
Adults with an acute illness episode less than 28 days.503
(372/131)