Table 2

Dose constraints for all trial arms

VolumeArm A: StandardArm B:
CHART-ED
Arm C: IDEAL-CRTArm D: I-STARTArm E: Isotoxic IMRT
CTVV95%>99%V95%>99%V95%>99%V95%>99%Optimal: CTV D(total Vol −1 cc) ≥95%
Mandatory: CTVMeanDose±1% of prescribed dose
PTVV95%>90%
V90%>98%
V95%>90%
V90%>98%
V95%>90%
V90%>98%
V95%>90%
V90%>98%
Optimal: PTV D(total vol −1 cc) ≥90%
PTV D95%≥95%
Mandatory: PTV D(total vol − 1 cc)≥85%
PTV D95%≥90%
PTV D1 cc≤107%
Spinal canalD0.1 cc<47 GyD0.1 cc<46 GyD0.1 cc<48 GyD0.1 cc<47 GyD1.0 cc ≤ EQD2 50 Gy
Lung GTVV20 Gy<35%V20 Gy<35%V20 Gy<35%Mean dose≤20 Gy (physical dose)
Brachial plexusD0.1 cc<55 GyD0.1 cc<64.3 GyD0.1 cc<65 Gy
D30%<60 Gy (ipsilateral branchial plexus)
D0.1 cc<55 GyD1.0 cc ≤ EQD2 66 Gy
HeartD100%<36 Gy
D67%<44 Gy
D33%<57 Gy
D100%<48 Gy
D67%<57 Gy
D100%<44 Gy
D67%<52 Gy
D33%<59 Gy
D100%<36 Gy
D67%<44 Gy
D33%<57Gy
D1.0 cc ≤ EQD2 76 Gy
Mean dose≤46 Gy (physical dose)
OesophagusD0.1 cc<105%D0.1 cc<105%D1.0 cc<65 Gy
Lung contraV5 Gy<60%*V5 Gy<60%*V5 Gy<60%*
Mediastinal
envelope
D1.0 cc ≤ EQD2 76 Gy
  • *Optimal constraint (ie, not mandatory limit).

  • CTV, clinical target volume; EQD2, equivalent dose for 2 Gray fractions; GTV, gross tumour volume; IMRT, intensity-modulated radiotherapy; PTV, planning target volume.