Table 4

Comparison of PC access and initiation across geographic areas

OntarioUKUSAWestern Australia
Criteria to access PC
  • 94 000 deaths in Ontario 2014/2015

  • Universal insured hospital and physician system

  • No restrictions on curative along with PC

  • No written document required to initiate PC, though often the ‘surprise question’ of expected death of 1 year to 6 months is used to initiate care47

  • Provided by general practitioners, specialists and home-care providers

  • 548 000 deaths 2015

  • Primary care delivered heavily by general practitioners and primary care trusts

  • Universal health insurance

  • Patients may be terminal (expected to die within 12 months, have a life-limiting illness or chronic condition with a trajectory that has a sharp functional decline or extensive acute episodes, or require extended care)

  • Can mix palliative and curative care34

  • 2.6 M deaths in 2015

  • Hospice benefit includes visiting interprofessional providers in home, residential hospices, hospitals, long-term care, etc

  • Available to Medicare patients

  • Must have signed physician note stating expected death within 6 months

  • Must waive access to curative treatments to access hospice benefit32

  • 23 852 deaths in Western Australia in 2009/2010

  • Mix of private and government service providers

  • Use ‘normative need’ to assess access to PC specialists33

Physician ratio
  • 2.2 physicians/1000 ppl (2015)

  • 47%/53%: generalists/specialists37

  • 2.8 physicians/1000 ppl (2015)

  • 29%/71%: generalists/specialists37

  • 2.5 physicians/1000 ppl (2011)

  • 12%/88%: generalists/specialists37

  • 3.5 physicians/1000 ppl (2015)

  • 45%/47%: generalists/specialists (8%: medical doctors not further defined)37

Per cent that get any service
  • 54% of decedents between 2010 and 2012 received at least PC services (from billing claims) in any setting.(table 2)

  • 74% of people who are in need of PC receive either specialist or generalist services

  • 18% of non-malignant access to PC was for chronic respiratory illness, 11% for heart failure34

  • 46% of Medicare (>65 years old) decedents received ≥1 day of hospice care (via the Medicare hospice benefit) in 201532

  • 46% of decedents received any PC33

Cancer and non-cancer access
  • 88% of terminal illness, 44% of organ failure and 32% of frailty decedents (or 39% non-cancer) received any PC services (table 2)

  • Among those receiving any PC services, 55% died from terminal illness, 27% from organ failure and 18% from frailty illness trajectories

  • 88% of PC inpatients have cancer diagnosis

  • 20% of inpatient referrals are for non-cancer34

  • Among those who received the hospice benefit, the principal diagnoses were: 27% cancer, 19% cardiac, 17% dementia and 11% respiratory32

  • 69% of patients with cancer had access to specialist care

  • 14% of patients without cancer had access to specialists33

Average Length of stay in PCMedian days of initiation of service to death:
  • Terminal illness 107 days

  • Organ failure 22 days

  • Frailty 24 days (table 2)

Median days on service in one large study in one region (Leeds, UK):
  • 37 days for cancer

  • 16 days for non-cancer48

Mean/(median) days on service
  • Cancer: 47/(19) days

  • cardiac: 76/(28) days

  • dementia: 105/(56) days

  • respiratory 69/(19) days

  • stroke 77/(20) days32

  • Median number of days receiving specialist PC was 30 (cancer), 8 (COPD) and 5 (Alzheimers and heart failure)33

  • Median days PC initiated before death: 62 (cancer), 6 (Alzheimers) and 43 (COPD)33

Location of service (community, home, hospital)
  • 68% of cancer decedents have PC in a community setting

  • 76% in an acute care setting

  • <1% of PC for any trajectory was received in an LTC facility (table 2)

  • ~20% of LTC residents were seen by a PC specialist nurse, 96% were seen by a GP

  • Poor access to hospitals. Only 21% of hospitals provide face-to-face PC 24/7

  • 27% of hospital outpatient PC and 17% of community PC provided to non-malignant disease34

  • Home 56.0%

  • Nursing facility 41.3%

  • Hospice inpatient facility 1.3%

  • Acute care hospital 0.5%

  • Other 0.9%32

  • Organ failure patients (eg, liver failure) tended to receive care in hospital over community settings

  • Motor neuron and cancer decedents had increased access to community services33

  • COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; GP, general practitioner; LTC, long-term care; PC, palliative care; ppl, people.