Table 2

Registration characteristics of included trials

Study characteristicN (%)
All trials
n=192
Financial ties present
n=130
Financial ties absent
n=62
Registered at any time186 (97)130 (100)56 (90)*
Registered prospectively131 (68)101 (78)30 (48)*
Prospectively registered with clearly defined primary outcome103 (54)81 (62)22 (35)*
Prospectively registered and published primary outcomes are consistent76 (40)62 (48)14 (23)*
Prospectively registered primary outcome inconsistent with published primary outcome27 (14)19 (15)8 (13)
 Registered primary outcome reported as secondary outcome in published manuscript11 (6)7 (5)4 (6)
 Registered primary outcome not reported in published manuscript5 (3)5 (4)0 (0)
 Published manuscript includes new primary outcome12 (6)10 (8)2 (3)
 Published primary outcome described as secondary in registry4 (2)3 (2)1 (2)
 Timing of assessment of primary outcome variable differs between registry and manuscript7 (4)6 (5)1 (2)
Does registration discrepancy favour statistically significant published results?n=27n=19n=8
 Yes14 (52)12 (63)2 (25)
 No8 (30)3 (16)5 (63)
 Unknown5 (19)4 (21)1 (13)
  • *P≤0.001.