Table 4

Newcastle-Ottawa Scale risk of bias scores

ReferenceSelectionComparabilityOutcomeTotal
Markou et al 12 3238
Nery et al 13 3025
Markou et al 14 3227
Martini and Barbisan15 3025
Nery and Barbisan16 3227
Rengo et al 17 4239
Giaccardi et al 18 3227
Cacciatore et al 19 3227
Noyez et al 20 3238
Min et al 21 4217
van Laar et al 22 3036
Average scores±SD3.18±0.401.45±0.932.27±0.656.91±1.22
  • Maximum scores are 4, 2 and 3 for selection, comparability and outcome, respectively. Maximum total score is 9. A lower score within each category and for a total score indicates a higher risk of bias.