Table 1

Results of the first ranking exercise

MorbiditiesRank before tie-breaksRank after tie-breaks
New global permanent neurological impairment11
New impaired cognitive function more than a month after surgery22
Unplanned reoperation/reintervention23
Developmental delay24
Major adverse event25
Problems feeding (graded)26
Mental health consequences27
Length of ICU stay28
New focal permanent neurological impairment29
Low cardiac output (categorised)210
Poor communication between clinical team and family211
ECMO/mechanical support212
Acute kidney injury (graded)213
Prolonged pleural effusion214
Complications during surgery215
Hospital acquired infection (graded/categorised)215
Prolonged hospital length of stay217
Complete heart block (categorised)218
Surgical bleeding (graded)219
Questionable clinical team decision & diagnosis220
Level of support from hospital available at home221
Recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy221
Phrenic nerve injury223
Necrotising enterocolitis2424
Vascular thrombosis (graded)2525
JET2626
Elevated pulmonary vascular resistance2727
Liver injury (graded)2727
Sensory neural deafness2727
  • Note that for some suggested morbidities, the panel indicated that a grading or categorisation scheme would be required if that morbidity were to be used. The definition of an appropriate grading or categorisation scheme was left to the separate definitions panel, with only those morbidities selected subject to the full definition process.

  • ICU, intensive care unit. ECMO, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, JET,  junctional ectopic tachycardia.