Table 3

Mean subscale results according to status of participation in five groups

First survey % positive; mean (SD)Second survey % positive; mean (SD)
DimensionLeavers*Dropouts†Stable‡Stable‡Laggards§Newcomers¶
Teamwork climate59.6%; 71.8 (20.8)63.0%; 75.8 (15.5)60.3%; 74.9 (18.0)**65.1%; 77.9 (17.0)64.5%; 76.6 (19.1)58.9%; 76.6 (15.6)
Safety climate36.2%; 64.3 (20.3)38.4%; 70.3 (15.7)40.9%††; 68.0 (18.6)**55.0%; 72.8 (18.0)48.4%; 69.6 (21.0)48.2%; 70.3 (19.4)
Job satisfaction51.1%††; 67.3 (24.8)**63.0%; 76.8 (17.0)68.5%††; 77.0 (18.4)**78.2%; 82.4 (17.4)74.2%; 77.4 (22.4)76.8%; 83.9 (17.3)
Stress recognition51.1%; 67.9 (25.4)56.2%; 68.9 (20.0)58.8%; 70.6 (23.2)61.2%; 71.1 (23.4)45.2%††; 69.3 (23.7)46.4%; 67.4 (20.1)
Perceptions of unit management55.3%; 68.5 (25.1)58.3%; 70.9 (22.7)55.3%; 70.6 (21.7)**62.2%; 75.8 (18.9)58.1%; 73.2 (20.6)74.5%; 81.3 (11.4)**
Perceptions of department management21.3%; 58.7 (18.9)30.1%; 63.5 (19.3)33.2%; 62.6 (20.0)**34.5%; 65.4 (18.2)22.6%; 58.7 (18.9)50.5%; 69.4 (18.4)
Working conditions46.8%; 68.5 (25.1)58.9%; 70.9 (22.7)53.6%; 69.6 (24.3)**60.2%; 73.0 (23.3)64.5%††; 77.2 (21.7)57.1%; 69.7 (25.9)
  • *Leavers: participating in the first survey, then leaving the department, N=47.

  • †Dropouts: invitees in both surveys, but only participating in the first survey, N=73.

  • ‡Stable: participants in both surveys, N=238.

  • §Laggards: invitees in both surveys, but only participating in the second survey, N=31.

  • ¶Newcomers: staff joining the department after the first survey, and participating in the second survey only, N=56.

  • **Indicates a statistically significant difference in means when comparing with the stable participants (p<0.05).

  • ††Indicates a statistically significant difference in % positive when comparing with the stable participants (p<0.05).