1448 e-Letters

  • Re:Qualitative cross-sectional study of the perceived causes of depression in South Asian origin women in Toronto
    kwame mckenzie

    Thank you for commenting on our article and pointing out the short hand statement "consented"

    Thank you for your comments and with your permission I will use them as a teaching peice for my students.


    Kwame McKenzie

    Conflict of Interest:

    author of the article

  • Peter G Sainsbury

    I enjoyed reading about this well conducted study that produced interesting results. I do, however, wish to comment on one sentence:

    [The participants] were then approached face to face by the researchers and consented.

    While I realise that word limits encourage authors to be parsimonious and make stylistic compromises, to state that research participants are 'consented' is to imply that they are passiv...

    Show More
  • Re:There is no need for further placebo-controlled trials
    Ane B. Fisker

    We thank Mayo-Wilson and colleagues for their comments(1). They have used our paper on the effect of vitamin A campaigns on mortality(2) not to question the paper itself, but to repeat a previous discussion(3, 4) about whether new trials of vitamin A supplementation (VAS) are needed to optimise the vitamin A policy. This is clearly a very important discussion.

    We think that new trials are needed. We have found i...

    Show More
  • Correction to author affiliations
    Editorial Office BMJ Open

    Author affiliation 3 should read NWORTH, Bangor University, Bangor, UK

  • Re:No evidence that oral contraceptive use is associated with prostate cancer mortality: further observations
    David Margel

    We thank Drs Cherrie and MacCalman for their thoughtful comments. However the first step in any analysis is exploring the variables. When examining the distribution of women use of vaginal barriers world- wide, one notices that no country reports more than 5% of woman using this mode of contraception, and only 9 countries have over 1% use of vaginal barriers. Clearly this variable cannot be entered at face value. When w...

    Show More
  • There is no need for further placebo-controlled trials
    Evan Mayo-Wilson

    To the Editor:

    We concur with Fisker et al. that factors moderating and mediating the effect of vitamin A supplementation on mortality are not fully understood.[1] Further observational studies could elucidate this relationship. New trials might examine the impact of delivering vitamin A at different times of year or with different doses and frequencies; however, we disagree with Fisker et al. that further tri...

    Show More
  • Misleading conclusion with serious negative health outcome
    Chew Boon How

    Dear BMJ Open Editorial,

    we appreciate the effort of the authors in looking into the 30-year mortality outcomes of their initial cohorts, who were stratified into different occupational work demands, adjusted for some co-morbidities, risk factors and social classes. It was reassuring that the established cardiovascular risk factors of smoking and hypertension were indeed true much earlier than we aware. However...

    Show More
  • No evidence that oral contraceptive use is associated with prostate cancer mortality: further observations
    John W. Cherrie

    We are pleased that Margel and Fleshner recognize the data errors in their original manuscript [1], which have a dramatic impact on the outcome of the ecological analysis [2]. Using the correct dataset and extending the analysis to include all countries, which we agree is appropriate, the authors report that the correlation between oral contraceptive use and prostate cancer mortality was much reduced (Pearson correlation...

    Show More
  • Is there substance behind the headline?
    Luke D Sayers

    'Chronic Fatigue syndrome affects 1 in 100 pupils'

    This statement featured prominently on the BBC website and drew me first to press article and then the study. It seemed like reasonable research on first glance, it involved 2855 pupils and was published in a BMJ journal. However on closer inspection, the study is flawed.

    The authors present a clear agenda that they feel CFS/ME remains undiagnosed an...

    Show More
  • Uncontrolled study proves little about value of therapy received
    Tom P. Kindlon

    This paper (1) includes data on two separate (but related) issues: (i) the prevalence of diagnosed and undiagnosed Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Myalgic Encephalomyelitis ("CFS/ME") (NICE criteria (2)) in children aged 11-16 and (ii) information on how they fared when they received therapy at the CFS clinic. The relative rigour that is brought to the first set of data may mean some may miss that many questions remain about th...

    Show More