Introduction Difficult airway management is closely related to the safety and quality of medical care. However, the low incidence of correct prediction of difficult airway in clinical screening tests presents physicians with a dilemma. Depressed airway neuromuscular tension during sleep and anaesthesia tends to cause collapse of fragile parts of the upper airway. Although previous studies have confirmed that anterior cervical tissue thickness is associated with difficult airways, there is no evidence to support a correlation between a difficult airway and specific patterns or findings of anaesthesia-induced airway collapse. Thus, this study aims to examine changes in airway dimensions before and after induction of general anaesthesia to explore whether it could provide useful information regarding the specific anatomic changes occurring which may cause difficult airways.
Methods and analysis This will be a single-centre prospective observational single-blinded study, conducted in a tertiary teaching hospital in Guangzhou, China. Subjects will be recruited from patients (aged 18–65 years) scheduled for elective surgery under general anaesthesia. Sonographic measurement will be performed to detect changes in the thickness of the anterior cervical soft tissue before and after anaesthetic induction. Based on the resulting data distribution, analyses will initially compare these changes using a paired t-test or the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. The correlation of sonographic changes and Cormack–Lehane grade will be evaluated by using receiver-operating characteristic curves to detect the sensitivity and specificity of a measurement for detecting difficulties. Linear stepwise regression analysis will be used to assess the correlation between airway changes and demographic variables as well as clinical tests.
Ethics and dissemination Ethical approval has been obtained from the Ethics Committee of the First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine (ZYYECK (2018) 041). The results will be disseminated through conference presentations, professional journals and peer-reviewed publications.
Trial registration number ChiCTR1900021123; Pre-results.
- airway changes
- anaesthetic induction
- difficult airway
- prospective study protocol
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study
No previous study has used ultrasound to investigate upper airway changes following anaesthetic induction.
The study will explore new indicators that can provide insight into the theoretical basis for dynamic risk assessment of difficult airways.
The trial will recruit both easy and difficult laryngoscopy subjects, which can provide information useful for evaluating the difference between difficult and normal airways.
Patients with indications for awake and/or spontaneous breathing airway management technique will be excluded, and patients with unexpected and complicated difficult airway management will be withdrawn from the study; although this might create a potential selection bias, this will ensure patient safety and compliance with the American Society of Anesthesiologists’ principle of difficult airway management.
The repeated measurement design uses each individual as its own control, which overcomes the bias caused by individual variation; however, the influence of measurement time on observation results is not considered.
Airway management is critical in medical intervention and is a prerequisite for successful treatment and rescue. However, in some cases, repeated attempts to perform laryngoscopy or intubation lead to lack of adequate oxygen delivery to the brain and other vital organs, which can threaten patient safety.1 In 2016, we conducted a large-scale survey of airway management in China, which showed that 73% of anaesthesiologists were concerned about difficult airways, 36% experienced emergency airway rescue, and in 14% of hospitals, death or brain injury were caused by difficult airways. Although airway management-related severe complications in anaesthesia are rare, they can result in serious patient harm.2 3 According to the survey data obtained in the fourth National Audit Project of the Royal College of Anaesthetists and Difficult Airway Society project (NAP4), the incidence of ‘cannot intubate, cannot oxygenate’ is less than 1 in 5000 in general anaesthesia; however, the combined rate of death and brain damage in such cases constitutes up to 25% of all major complications. Among these adverse events, hypoxia is the most common cause of airway-related deaths.3 4
Obstruction of the upper airway is a relatively common complication during sleep and anaesthesia.5 Even topical anaesthesia of the oropharynx tends to increase the frequency of obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA).6 The mutual narcotic mechanism of sleep and anaesthesia is thought to trigger the bistable thalamocortical switch that controls consciousness.7 At or approaching the moment of loss of consciousness, local electromyographic activity abruptly decreases to a nadir, accompanied by an increase in mask pressure.8 Such problems often occur because the tendency for a loss of pharyngeal patency is related to anatomical factors,8 which also make intubation difficult.5
The framework of bone and cartilage on the upper airway ensures respiratory tract patency. However, the pharynx, a soft tube composed mainly of muscles and lacking in bony or cartilaginous scaffolds, provides the anatomical basis for collapse during inhalation. Due to the role of the thoracic and abdominal muscles during inhalation, the pleural cavity is enlarged, the pressure of the pleural and pharyngeal cavity is reduced, and the whole respiratory tract is in a negative pressure state. When the negative pressure exceeds the critical pressure that can be withstood by the pharyngeal airway wall, the airway may collapse, especially in individuals in whom the tract is already narrow due to compression of tissue around the pharynx.9 10
Accurate prediction of a difficult airway is the first step towards avoiding potential complications. Preoperative unspecified airway assessment is recommended by the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) and NAP4, as well as by many international airway management guidelines.11 Whenever feasible, airway history and physical examination should be conducted in all patients; based on the anticipated likelihood of airway difficulty, such as that in patients with OSA, the ASA strongly suggests conducting additional evaluations.12
The observed incidence of unexpected difficult airways depends on the tests performed. Unfortunately, low sensitivity and high variability significantly decrease the value of the commonly used clinical screening test as a reliable clinical diagnostic approach.13 A Danish retrospective study revealed that 93% of difficult intubation and 94% of difficult mask ventilation cases were unanticipated; at the same time, only 25% and 22%, respectively, of the anticipated cases actually occurred.14 A meta-analysis15 and systematic review16 have found that both single predictors and combined tests are characterised by limited discriminative capability, sensitivity and positive likelihood ratio.
The invisible anatomic lesions (eg, vocal fold cysts) that may lead to difficult airways could be challenging to identify in standard preoperative examinations; additionally, quantitative analysis of the obstacles cannot be implemented based on clinical signs and symptoms.17 Various assistive techniques such as endoscopy,18 X-ray imaging,19CT20 21 and MRI22 23 have been used to image both intrinsic and extrinsic pathological changes in the trachea.24 In addition, combining the advantages of endoscopy and CT, the novel application of virtual endoscopy in anaesthesia provides a three-dimensional (3D) ‘fly-through’ video of intratracheal anatomy through reconstructed CT images.25 Compared with other supplementary measurements, ultrasound is an effective, non-invasive, widely available evaluation modality, which requires no radiation and which can be performed with little or no patient preparation. Furthermore, it would be a relatively objective technique and familiar to anaesthesiologists who often conduct ultrasound-guided nerve block and vascular access, as well as airway management-related operations (eg, confirmation of endotracheal tube placement and localisation of cricothyroid membrane).26 This measurement allows evaluation of adjacent soft tissue structures around the collapsible segment, such that narrowing and flaccidity can be delineated. A strong correlation has been found between the Cormack–Lehane score and ultrasound-determined depth from the skin to the trachea at the level of the thyrohyoid membrane.27 The use of ultrasound is similar to that of the upper lip bite test, which is the optimal bedside test for predicting difficult intubation.13 26 28
However, not all difficult tracheal intubations are related to obvious lesions; they can also be derived from more subtle anatomical tendencies controlled by muscular tone.5 29 Depression of the electromyographic activity of pharyngeal dilator muscles, as well as reduction of longitudinal tension due to reduced lung volume during anaesthesia and sleep, cannot offset the intraluminal negative pressure during inspiration and the extraluminal negative pressure from soft tissue and bone, thus leading to the occurrence of airway collapse.30 The vulnerable compliant segments are predisposed to partial or complete obstruction only when neuromuscular activation is depressed by a pharmaceutical agent8 or when sleep occurs.29 For this reason, obstruction during sleep and anaesthesia can be identified in only few patients when they are awake.9 Therefore, preoperative ultrasound examination may not be able to reveal the impact of dynamic changes on airflow in the upper airway, thus limiting its ability to identify potential risks.
There is limited high-level scientific evidence of the potential role of ultrasound in dynamic detection of upper airway changes during induction of anaesthesia. Furthermore, the data obtained do not indicate sufficiently whether these changes are associated with difficult airway. It is consequently critical that methodologically rigorous trials are performed to establish the use of ultrasound in assessment of difficult airway during anaesthetic induction and to provide new ideas and a theoretical basis for determining the correlation between dynamic airway changes and difficult airways.
We aim to address this issue in the study proposed here. Subjects will be recruited from the First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine, a tertiary teaching hospital in China. In this institute, nearly 20 000 cases undergo operating room anaesthesia annually, 60% of which involve general anaesthesia; this can provide sufficient cases for addressing the critical clinical issues discussed above.
Methods and analysis
Aim of the current study
To evaluate changes in anterior cervical soft tissue thickness at five anatomical levels (hyoid bone, epiglottis, cricothyroid membrane, thyroid isthmus and suprasternal notch) in the upper airway, before and after induction of general anaesthesia.
To detect whether correlations exist between changes in ultrasound measurements and mask ventilation pressure, Cormack–Lehane score, demographic variables and clinical screening tests and to identify the usefulness of these measurements for assessment of a difficult airway.
Design and setting
The study is designed as a prospective observational single-blinded study, conducted in a single centre. The flowchart of this trial is provided in figure 1. The study will observe patients scheduled for elective surgery under general anaesthesia in the operating theatre of the First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine from February 2019 to January 2020.
Sample size and study power
Sample size is estimated based on a pilot study of 18 subjects. The change in the depth from the skin to the epiglottis before and after induction of anaesthesia in the pilot study was 0.22 cm±0.55 (mean±SD). Assuming type I and type II errors of 0.05 and 0.10, respectively, at least 66 subjects should be enrolled in this study. To adjust for attrition by dropout, 75 subjects will be recruited into the study.
Patients aged from 18 to 65 years, ASA physical status I–II and scheduled for elective surgery under general anaesthesia in operating room will be screened for eligibility. We will use no sex restriction. The inclusion and exclusion criteria are provided in table 1. If any subject is thought to have allergic symptoms or haemodynamic changes, the corresponding treatment and tracheal intubation will be given immediately, and the participant will be withdrawn from the study. If face mask ventilation is inadequate, the Intubating laryngeal mask airway (ILMA) will be used to maintain ventilation. After sufficient oxygenation, fibreoptic-guided intubation through ILMA will be performed. If the Supraglottic airways (SGA) cannot maintain ventilation and oxygenation, cricothyroid membrane puncture will be performed immediately. In addition, patients with unanticipated difficult ventilation or intubation will be withdrawn from the study.
Before (T1) and after anaesthetic induction with loss of consciousness (T2), airway sonographic measurements (Navi series, Shenzhen Wisonic Medical Technologies, Shenzhen, China) will be performed by an attending anaesthesiologist, using a linear ultrasound transducer. Participants will be kept supine, in the sniffing position throughout the measurement procedure.31 32 The probe will be placed in the submental region of the neck, in the midline, to measure the thickness of the anterior cervical soft tissues at five levels (hyoid bone (figure 2A), epiglottis (figure 2B), cricothyroid membrane (figure 2C), thyroid isthmus (figure 2D) and suprasternal notch (figure 2E)) in the axial plane. Measurement sites used during the first measurement will be marked to allow easier positioning of the probe at the same site in subsequent measurements. The images will be stored on the hard drive of the ultrasound machine.
Airway pressure measurement
After induction of anaesthesia, routine pressure-controlled face mask ventilation will be administered to the patient. Concomitantly, the mean airway pressure will be measured with a variable reluctance diaphragm pressure transducer (Datex-Ohmeda Aestiva 7100, GE Healthcare, Chicago, Illinois). Difficult mask ventilation will be recorded.
When the muscle relaxes completely (train-of-four, TOF ¼ 0), laryngoscopy will be performed by another attending anaesthetist who is blinded to the results of the ultrasound assessments. In accordance with a modified version of the Cormack–Lehane classification system,33 34 the Cormack–Lehane grades 1 or 2a, grades 2b or 3a, and grades 3b or 4 will be designated as easy, restricted and difficult laryngoscopies, respectively.
Anaesthetic induction procedure
Standard monitoring will be performed throughout anaesthesia to detect clinical vital signs and indicators related to the depth of anaesthesia (table 2). When the Narcotrend (MonitorTechnik, Bad Bramstedt, Germany) reaches stage D2, the second ultrasound measurement will be made. The induction will be performed as per standard practice of rapid sequence anaesthesia induction (see box 1).35
Anaesthetic induction procedure
Preoxygenation treatment through a face mask for 3 min.
Induction with intravenous propofol 1.5 mg/kg.
Surgical analgesia with intravenous sufentanil; infusion at 0.5–1 µg/kg/min, adjusted according to the Narcotrend (stage D2).
Neuromuscular blockade with intravenous rocuronium 0.6 mg/kg.
Pressure-controlled facemask ventilation with a tidal volume of 8 mL/kg.
Endotracheal intubation with a direct laryngoscope.
The primary outcome is the changes in the thickness of the anterior cervical soft tissue between baseline and after anaesthetic induction. The ultrasound measurement will be used to evaluate thicknesses at five anatomical levels: hyoid bone, epiglottis, cricothyroid membrane, thyroid isthmus and suprasternal notch.
The secondary outcomes include the demographic variables, clinical screening tests, laryngoscopy results and anaesthesia-related indicators (table 3). Arterial blood gas measurements will be examined before and after anaesthetic induction.
Recruitment and single blinding
The subjects will be recruited from the surgical ward, and written informed consent will be obtained during the preoperative visit. The three attending anaesthesiologists will be blinded to each other’s preoperative evaluation, ultrasound and laryngoscopy findings.
Patient and public involvement
The protocol of this study was developed and implemented through discussion with a patient and public involvement (PPI) group in face-to-face conversations and via messages, emails and phone calls. LS was a patient scheduled for orthopaedic surgery who served as a patient adviser. He was consulted on key aspects of the study design, including the recruitment and dissemination methods, consent form, image data acquisition and selection of the outcomes. The PPI representatives read the final protocol prior to the manuscript submission. In addition to the dissemination to clinicians and researchers through publication of professional clinical papers and delivery of academic speeches, key results of the trial will be disseminated via email to the participants to encourage further publicity with respect to the results.
Data will be analysed using the IBM Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) V.20.0. The Shapiro–Wilks test will be used to first verify the normality of the sonographic data before and after anaesthetic induction. According to distribution sets, these changes will be analysed using a paired t-test or the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Comparison of the area under the receiver-operating characteristic curves will determine the correlation between sonographic airway changes and the Cormack–Lehane grade, and will be used to assess optimal cut-off scores. The independent contribution of demographic variables, clinical screening tests and anaesthesia-related indicators (table 3) to airway changes will be assessed in a multivariate analysis using forward stepwise multiple linear regression. For all analyses, a p value <0.05 will be considered statistically significant.
Ethics and dissemination
Written informed consent in both Chinese and English will be obtained from every participant prior to enrolment. The subjects can voluntarily withdraw from the trial at any time. Such withdrawal will not affect the medical intervention provided by the institution. Participants will be anonymised in the study by a medical identification code.
The First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine is one of the four national airway management training bases of the Chinese Association of Anaesthesiologists. As an academic and training centre, the department of anaesthesiology provides comprehensive operative services to a large population. It also serves as the primary teaching site to provide systematic, standardised and normalised training for medical staff. Many international conferences and training courses have been held in our hospital in conjunction with well-known universities worldwide. Since 2008, more than 1600 anaesthesiologists, emergency doctors, intensive care unit doctors and respiratory physicians from 29 provinces and municipalities in China have participated in an airway management training programme. In 2018, the director of the department delivered a speech regarding the status quo of airway management in China at the conference of the American Association of Airway Management. These all provided sufficient preconditions and conditions for validation and promotion of new technologies.
To date, there has been no previous ultrasonographic study that has observed the morphological changes in the upper airway before and after induction of general anaesthesia. Our study will involve monitoring these changes and analysing the correlation between changes in the upper airway and difficult airway by regression analysis, to provide a new basis for evaluation of difficult airways and to explore new and more effective methods to address this problem. It will provide novel indicators that can form a basis for new clinical guidelines in airway assessment. The findings will be published in professional journals and in peer-reviewed journals. They will be presented at seminars and scientific conferences. The key audience for dissemination will be anaesthesiologists, emergency physicians, intensive care unit doctors and sleep medicine physicians in China as well as internationally.
We wish to acknowledge Lei Su and the patient and public involvement group who made public suggestions for the study design and dissemination.
Contributors WM conceptualised and designed the study, wrote funding applications and provides professional consultation, assists with methodology and administers the project. FD drafted, reviewed and edited this manuscript, and will help to collect and analyse the data. YW performed the pilot study and collected data for estimating the sample size and reviewed and edited this manuscript. XW and HZ performed the pilot study and collected data for estimating the sample size and will assist in further data collection.
Funding The trial was supported by the Guangzhou Science and Technology Bureau (Grant number: 201707010297) and National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant numbers: 81503663 and 81673922).
Competing interests None declared.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Patient consent for publication Not required.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.