Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Role of iodine-containing multivitamins during pregnancy for children’s brain function: protocol of an ongoing randomised controlled trial: the SWIDDICH study
  1. Sofia Manousou1,2,
  2. Birgitta Johansson3,
  3. Anna Chmielewska4,5,
  4. Janna Eriksson1,
  5. Kerstin Gutefeldt6,
  6. Carl-Johan Tornhage7,8,
  7. Robert Eggertsen1,9,
  8. Helge Malmgren1,
  9. Lena Hulthen1,10,
  10. Magnus Domellöf4,
  11. Helena Nystrom Filipsson1,11
  1. 1 Institute of Medicine, Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg, Göteborg, Sweden
  2. 2 Department of Medicine, Kungälv’s Hospital, Kungälv, Sweden
  3. 3 Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg, Göteborg, Sweden
  4. 4 Pediatrics Unit, Department of Clinical Sciences, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden
  5. 5 Department of Pediatrics, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
  6. 6 Department of Endocrinology, University Hospital of Linköping, Linköping, Sweden
  7. 7 Department of Pediatrics, Skaraborg Hospital, Skövde, Sweden
  8. 8 Department of Pediatrics, Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden
  9. 9 Mölnlycke Health Care Center, Mölnlycke, Sweden
  10. 10 Department of Internal Medicine and Clinical Nutrition, Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg, Göteborg, Sweden
  11. 11 Department of Endocrinology, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Göteborg, Sweden
  1. Correspondence to Dr Sofia Manousou; sofia.manousou{at}vgregion.se

Abstract

Introduction Iodine is essential for normal brain development. Moderate and severe fetal iodine deficiency results in substantial to serious developmental delay in children. Mild iodine deficiency in pregnancy is associated with neurodevelopmental deficits in the offspring, but evidence from randomised trials is lacking. The aim of the Swedish Iodine in Pregnancy and Development in Children study is to determine the effect of daily supplementation with 150 µg iodine during pregnancy on the offspring’s neuropsychological development up to 14 years of age.

Methods and analysis Thyroid healthy pregnant women (n=1275: age range 18–40 years) at ≤12 weeks gestation will be randomly assigned to receive multivitamin supplements containing 150 µg iodine or non-iodine-containing multivitamin daily throughout pregnancy. As a primary outcome, IQ will be measured in the offspring at 7 years (Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-V). As secondary outcomes, IQ will be measured at 3.5 and 14 years, psychomotor development at 18 months and 7 years, and behaviour at 3.5, 7 and 14 years. Iodine status (urinary iodine concentration) will be measured during pregnancy and in the offspring at 3.5, 7 and 14 years. Thyroid function (thyroid hormones, thyroglobulin), and deiodinase type 2 polymorphisms will be measured during pregnancy and in the offspring at 7 and 14 years. Structural MRI or other relevant structural or functional brain imaging procedures will be performed in a subgroup of children at 7 and 14 years. Background and socioeconomic information will be collected at all follow-up times.

Ethics and dissemination This study is approved by the Ethics Committee in Göteborg, Sweden (Diary numbers: 431-12 approved 18 June 2012 (pregnancy part) and 1089-16 approved 8 February 2017 (children follow-up)). According to Swedish regulations, dietary supplements are governed by the National Food Agency and not by the Medical Product Agency. Therefore, there is no requirement for a monitoring committee and the National Food Agency does not perform any audits of trial conduct. The trial will be conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki. The participating sites will be contacted regarding important protocol changes, both orally and in writing, and the trial registry database will be updated accordingly. Study results will be presented at relevant conferences, and submitted to peer-reviewed journals with open access in the fields of endocrinology, paediatrics and nutrition. After the appropriate embargo period, the results will be communicated to participants, healthcare professionals at the maternal healthcare centres, the public and other relevant groups, such as the national guideline group for thyroid and pregnancy and the National Food Agency.

Trial registration number NCT02378246; Pre-results.

  • iodine
  • pregnancy
  • child development
  • cognition
  • thyroid hormones

This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

View Full Text

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Strengths and limitations of this study

  • Large interventional controlled trial on iodine supplementation during pregnancy, powered to detect a difference of three IQ points in children.

  • Long observational follow-up of the children, up to 14 years, with complex assessment of neurocognitive development.

  • Future implementation of the study is feasible, as the intervention tablet exists on the market.

  • Lack of pure iodine and pure placebo tablets implies careful interpretation of results.

  • Dropout rate may be high.

Background

Iodine deficiency as an international issue

Iodine is essential for the production of thyroid hormones and important for growth and brain development during fetal and early postnatal life1; a knowledge obtained after a long history of iodine deficiency (ID) associated disorders. For centuries, goitre with hypothyroidism, mental retardation and cretinism have been an entity. During the 1920s in the USA, Marine and Kimball performed the classic experiment of treating schoolgirls with iodine, leading to a dramatic reduction in the prevalence of goitre. Iodine prophylaxis was established in the USA in 1921. After some debate, iodine prophylaxis was introduced in Switzerland in 1922, and then worldwide over the subsequent decades. The combat against severe and moderate ID has been successful in reducing the number of children with ID-caused mental retardation. However, mild ID is widely apparent, especially during pregnancy,2 when dietary iodine demand increases from 150 to 250 µg/day.3

Iodine status in Sweden as the country for this study

Before iodination of table salt in 1936, ID was common in Sweden.4 Current iodine intake is sufficient in the general population5 6 and was considered adequate during pregnancy during the 1990s7 8; there is no recommendation on iodine supplementation during pregnancy. However, since the 1990s, the situation may have changed due to dairy product consumption in adults being lower; milk iodine levels are lower than before9 10; a reduction in salt intake is recommended for reducing the risk of hypertension; new salt forms (flake salt, gourmet salt) without iodine are popular; there is a reluctance to consume ‘food additives’; awareness of ID among the younger population is generally low; and the main proportion of total salt intake (≈80%), that is, from ready-made foods and dishes, does not provide iodine. Unless iodine is added to all salts used, the risk of decreased iodine intake is apparent, and arouses concerns, especially for pregnant women. Retrospective, local data on pregnancy highlight this assumption is realistic.11

ID during pregnancy: effects on the child’s development

Severe and moderate ID leads to lower serum thyroid hormone levels and thereby to lower availability of thyroid hormones in the brain. During fetal life and early years, the growing brain is vulnerable12 13 and severe ID results in mental retardation in the newborn, unless the thyroid hormone is replaced.14 In addition, an increased incidence of attention deficit hyperactivity disorders (ADHD) has been associated with mild to moderate ID.15

In mild ID, thyroid hormone levels are maintained, whereas thyroglobulin (TG) levels are increased as a biomarker of goitre. The brain’s use of thyroid hormones depends on the local conversion of inactive hormone thyroxine (T4) to active hormone triiodothyronine (T3), a process mediated by deiodinase type 2 (D2).16 D2 is found in the hippocampi and the cerebral cortex and its activity is increased by ID to maintain sufficient T3 levels.16 17 In the presence of normal thyroid hormone in blood, it is unclear how mild ID affects brain development. One theory is that this depends on deiodinases, which can change thyroid hormone signalling locally in different tissues, without affecting serum hormone concentration.16 18

Mild ID during pregnancy might have an impact on brain development, despite maintained normal thyroid hormone levels.19–22 In the UK, a longitudinal study19 found 8-year-old children have an increased risk of being in the lowest quartile of verbal IQ, if their mothers had mild ID in early pregnancy, than children of mothers with normal iodine nutrition. In a similar association study from Australia,20 mild ID was linked with lower cognitive performance in 9-year-old children. Results from an observational pilot study from Italy21 indicate mild to moderate ID during fetal life affects cognitive development, especially verbal abilities, even in absence of maternal thyroid insufficiency. In Norway, a large observational study22 found maternal iodine intake below the estimated average requirement during pregnancy was associated with reduced fine motor skills and verbal abilities and with more behaviour problems at the age of 3 years.

As the randomised controlled trial23 evaluating 150 µg iodine/placebo in pregnant women in an iodine sufficient country was small (n=86) and lacked cognitive assessment in children, there were many expectations about the MITCH study.24 In this trial, 832 women from Thailand and India were randomised to 200 µg iodine/placebo, and there was no difference in cognitive outcome in 5–6 year-old children. However, these results were ambiguous for several reasons. First, the women had entered Maternal Iodine Supplementation and Effects on Thyroid Function and Child Development (MITCH) study with urinary iodine concentration (UIC) as in mild ID, but they did have a normal TG, which indicated the iodine stores in prepregnancy may have been sufficiently filled, thus minimising any mental effects on the children. Second, some women were already iodine sufficient at baseline.25 Third, both intervention and placebo groups were iodine sufficient in the second and third trimesters. To prevent subnormal fetal brain development, many international authorities recommend 150 µg extra iodine/day during pregnancy, despite the lack of studies proving causality.26 27

Knowledge gaps and background to the Swedish Iodine in Pregnancy and Development in Children study

There is a substantial gap in knowledge about mild ID during pregnancy and its potential negative consequences on neuropsychological development. Therefore, there is a need for a placebo controlled trial that compares neuropsychological outcome in children exposed to mild ID during fetal life and children with normal iodine nutrition during pregnancy.

From 29 November 2012 to 1 June 2015, a pilot randomised placebo controlled trial involving 200 pregnant women receiving a daily supplementation with either a multivitamin containing 150 µg iodine/day or a multivitamin without iodine (placebo) was conducted by our group. This study (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02378246) aimed to evaluate the effects of iodine supplementation on UIC and thyroid function. As the MITCH study had ambiguous results, the question if mild ID during pregnancy affects fetal brain development remains unanswered, and it was evident to us that our trial needed to be expanded to include a sufficient number of pregnant women, to enable a satisfactorily powered child follow-up regarding neuropsychological development.

There are indications28 that UIC level during pregnancy in Sweden is lower than detected in the MITCH study, and an elevated TG is detected in early pregnancy, implying a lower iodine status at start of study. Moreover, iodine status in the third trimester is clearly lower in a local Swedish study11 than in the placebo group in the MITCH study, indicating a different iodine situation in Sweden than in Thailand and India. Therefore, the Swedish Iodine in Pregnancy and Development in Children (SWIDDICH) study is conducted. The hypothesis is that the use of an iodine-containing multivitamin during pregnancy results in better cognitive development in the child than with a multivitamin without minerals (superiority trial) and this effect is stronger on verbal competence, which is in agreement with previous findings.19 21 22

Objectives

The primary aim is to assess whether cognition (especially verbal competence) in children whose mothers received 150 µg iodine daily in a multivitamin during pregnancy is higher than children whose mothers received placebo (a multivitamin without iodine) and probably remained in mild ID. The purpose is to determine whether all pregnant women who live in a country where the general population is iodine sufficient, but live in conditions that can result in mild ID during pregnancy, should be recommended extra iodine during pregnancy.

Methods

Design of the SWIDDICH study

This is a randomised placebo controlled study in which children are followed up as an observational cohort, separated into two groups by fetal iodine exposure.

Setting and participants

Pregnant women will be recruited from more than 10 maternal healthcare centres in Sweden with the aim of forming several clusters to facilitate child follow-up. The main study site will be in Gothenburg, with secondary sites in Umeå and Linköping, and other areas where maternal healthcare centres are recruited. At the first scheduled pregnancy visit, information about the study will be provided and written informed consent collected by the midwife. All procedures during pregnancy will be combined with routine pregnancy visits.

All informed consents and blood and urine for future analyses will be sent to the main study site in Gothenburg. To promote participant retention and a complete follow-up, a contact from the study coordinator will be taken after childbirth. In addition, information will be shared with participants on the homepage https://www.gu.se/swiddich.

Inclusion

The following inclusion criteria will apply: women aged 18–40 years, pregnant at 7–12 weeks, willing to refrain from iodine supplementation and take a multivitamin supplement instead, without current thyroid disease, not in another pregnancy or lactating less than 6 months before inclusion, and non-vegan.

Randomisation, allocation, concealment and blinding

Randomisation numbers with an allocation ratio 1:1 are prepared centrally and sent to each participating centre. Consecutive numbers are used and the information regarding the study group allocation of each number stored securely at the premises of the University of Gothenburg, Sweden. Mothers are provided with a random container of pills by either drawing a lot or blindly drawing a container. All containers are identical, with tasteless pills of the same size for both groups. Recruiting staff, study participants and those involved in laboratory work and developmental assessment are blinded to the group allocation. The code will only be broken by the central study team for data analyses before publications, but will still be blinded to all groups working with the follow-up. The code has been broken for the 200 women of the pilot study, but all (ie, study participants, psychologists and lab engineers) except the central study team are still blinded. No other interim analyses are planned.

Intervention

Women in the experimental group receive a daily multivitamin supplement containing 150 µg iodine and those in the control group receive a daily multivitamin supplement containing no iodine (the contents of the two supplements are presented in table 1). The intervention lasts throughout pregnancy until the day of delivery. Women in both groups are recommended, as are all pregnant women in Sweden, to take extra folic acid 400 µg/day during the first trimester,29 and even extra iron, when the haemoglobin status indicates it. Therefore, women in the placebo group will be on maximum 600 µg daily folic acid supplementation, which is safely below the tolerable upper level of 1000 µg/day.30 The folic acid and iron administrations do not interfere with the study tablet. However, the women are not permitted to take any other multivitamins besides the study supplement.

Table 1

Multivitamin with iodine (intervention) and multivitamin without iodine (‘placebo’): table of contents

Compliance: discontinuation

Participants are asked to bring the container with the remaining pills to the visit in the third trimester. The container is weighted and the percentage of intended doses used is calculated. Mothers who no longer want to participate in the study during pregnancy will be regarded as dropouts and no further data will be collected. If there is discontinuation in the children follow-up, children can come to the next visit. If the discontinuation is permanent, a registry search will still be done.

Outcomes

Outcomes in mothers

Outcomes in mothers will be assessed in the first, second and third trimesters of pregnancy. UIC and thyroid hormones will be measured in all three trimesters, and thyroperoxidase (TPO) antibodies and TG in the first and third trimesters.

Primary outcome in children

Cognition measured by IQ (total IQ) with focus on the verbal compound (verbal IQ) at 7 years is the primary outcome (Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, WISC-V31).

Secondary outcomes in children

Cognition measured by IQ at 3.5 years (Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence-IV32) and at 14 years (WISC-V31 or an equivalent adequate version at the time) are secondary outcomes, together with outcomes related to psychomotor development, behaviour and ADHD. Psychomotor assessment will be done by the parents at 18 months (The Ages and Stages Questionnaire-3)33 and by a physiotherapist at 7 years (Movement Assessment Battery for Children test).34 Behaviour will be assessed through parental questionnaires, the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL); first at 3.5 years (CBCL 1–5),35 then at 7 and 14 years (CBCL 6–18).36 At 7 and 14 years, the Nordic questionnaire 5–1537 will be used to assess ADHD-related symptoms.

Parents also give their consent to a registry search at 3.5, 7 and 14 years regarding the inpatient and outpatient registries for collecting information on medical diagnoses,  the drug registry, the medical birth registry, quality registries, maternal, child and school healthcare for medical and growth data, and educational registries.

In a subgroup of children (n=200), structural brain changes will be evaluated by MRI of the brain (with a 3T Philips MR scanner) at 7 and 14 years. Automatic segmentation of the whole brain will be with Freesurfer38 and Maper, multiatlas propagation with enhanced registration.39 Mediotemporal lobe (MTL) structures will be analysed through manual segmentation with custom software developed in previous projects.40 41 Subregional analyses directed at regions of neurogenesis will be included. Intracranial volume measured manually will enable reliable normalisation of MTL volumes. Other structural and/or functional brain imaging methods may supplement, or even replace, the described protocol, depending on the state of knowledge at the time of study.

Possible confounding variables and background information

In children, UIC will be measured from the 3.5-year visit and forward and dry blood spots will be collected for thyroid hormones, TG and deiodinases at 7 and 14 years. Background and confounding variables will be assessed at 18 months, and 3.5, 7 and 14 years.

Time frame for the study actions

Recruitment to the SWIDDICH study began in March 2017 and is planned to be completed in 2019. Currently, 75 of 1075 pregnant women have been included. Several strategies are used to reach target sample size: a study coordinator is employed to contact maternal healthcare centres, and a stepwise reimbursement model is applied to the maternal healthcare centres in case of high recruitment rates; the National Food Agency promotes study participation in their communication with maternal healthcare centres; and local paediatricians are involved to facilitate the children follow-up. The follow-up of children was also offered to the families participating in the pilot study (2012–2015), before the study extension was decided. The time points for all study actions are presented in table 2.

Table 2

Summary of SWIDDICH study actions

Patient and public involvement statement

Pregnant women were not involved in the planning of the study.

Considerations

Considerations on the content of the intervention and the ‘Placebo’ tablets

The reason for choosing iodine-containing multivitamins instead of pure iodine tablets as the intervention is to ensure future implementation of the study is feasible. There are currently no pure iodine tablets available on the market. In the planning state of the study, discussions were initiated with pharmaceutical companies to provide pure iodine tablets and placebo, but interest was low. In the future, iodine in multivitamins will be the only available supplement source in most countries. Therefore, a multivitamin containing 150 µg iodine was chosen for the intervention and a multivitamin without minerals as the comparator.

Other components in the multivitamin products, besides iodine, may intervene with outcomes. It is proposed that vitamin B12 42 43 and iron44 can have positive effects on the brain, and iron and selenium influence thyroid hormone levels.45 46 Iron is found in TPO enzyme that couples iodine to TG. Selenium is found in deiodinases, such as D2, which converts T4 to T3, and is also an antioxidant of the thyroid gland. Sweden is a selenium-deficient country,47 but it is unclear whether selenium deficiency affects cognitive outcome in humans.48 B12 is higher in iodine-containing multivitamins where iron and selenium also are included. However, B12 content in both placebo and intervention tablets is, at least, equal to the recommended daily intake for B12; thus B12 deficiency is not anticipated in any of the groups. In addition, the iron content is low and many pregnant Swedish women take a separate 100 mg iron supplement, which makes the 12 mg iron in the intervention tablet negligible. Iron, B12 and selenium will be measured in a subpopulation to evaluate possible group differences and contributions to thyroid metabolism.

Considerations in choosing a realistic starting point for intervention

Fetal brain development during the first 12 weeks is dependent on maternal T4 levels. By initiating the intervention at pregnancy weeks 7–12, a substantial part of the first trimester is missed. Ideally, iodine supplements may be initiated before conception. Practically, the recruitment of women who plan a pregnancy is difficult, as these women are not known by healthcare providers before pregnancy. One way would be through advertising in the newspaper to recruit women who are planning pregnancy. However, this would be ineffective and create selection bias, as only 50% of those who fall pregnant have planned the pregnancy, and not every woman responds to an advertisement. Women are included at the earliest possible stage and this is still far earlier than in a recent publication by Casey et al 45 that included pregnant women in mean gestational weeks 16.6–18.0 and found negative results. The inclusion in the proposed study is similar to that in the MITCH study, where women were included in gestational weeks 10 and 11.24

Power calculation, data management, statistical considerations and authorship

The sample size needed, excluding dropouts, is calculated to 788 children (394 in each group) for an effect size of 3 IQ points with SD 15 and power 0.80. Currently, there are no similar randomised studies for power calculation. The smallest significant effect of 3 IQ points is in accordance with an observational study,19 where children of mothers with UIC<150 µg/L during pregnancy had a 3-point lower IQ at school age than children of mothers with normal UIC during pregnancy. This expected effect from iodine supplementation in mild ID is also suggested by Troendle,49 where statistical considerations are discussed for the possibility that the needed placebo controlled study is conducted. Assuming a dropout frequency of 22% during pregnancy (which is in accordance with preliminary data from the pilot study with 200 pregnant women28) and 20% during the children follow-up, 1263 pregnant women need to be recruited to the study. This sample size is in general agreement with Troendle,49 thus the decision was made to try and recruit 1275 pregnant women. The dropout frequency for the children follow-up could be lower than estimated, as there are two occasions for dropout and mothers who remain in the study after the first follow-up can be assumed willing to continue the study. The power calculation assumes the use of an unpaired t-test between groups; however, more advanced analyses could decrease variance, thus requiring a lower sample size.

The sample size will be reassessed by calculating the dropout frequency when 750 women are included and when half of the children from the first 200 included women have been invited to the 3.5-year neuropsychological evaluation. Sample size reassessment will be conducted without unblinding the study groups.

A 100% compliance to the study medication is assumed, as the results will be based on an intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis. Compliance is monitored to enable a per-protocol analysis (only the compliant participants included) to be added. However, the ITT approach reflects the real-life clinical situation, in which a certain number of patients are not compliant with the recommended treatment, and this will be the foundation for future recommendations on iodine supplementation to all pregnant women.

A separate power calculation for the MRI investigation has been done. This assumes the described protocol will be followed, and a previous study of 11-year-old children has been used for guidance.50 To detect a 5% difference with power 0.80, each group requires 60 children. As the variation in the hippocampal volumes in 7-year-old children could be slightly larger than in the previous study,50 and as dropout from the MRI at 14 years needs to be considered, 100 children will be included in each group.

Coded collected data will be entered into a database, with appropriate backup from the university servers. Key lists will be kept safe and transfer of data to the databases will be validated by random cross-checks with the original data set. UIC analyses will be duplicated to promote validity. For further details, see ethical applications (Diary numbers: 431-12 approved 18 June 2012 (pregnancy part) and 1089-16 approved 8 February 2017 (children follow-up)) and https://clinicaltrials.gov/. All authors will have access to all data and the statisticians will have access to the data needed.

The choice of methods for comparing the main outcome between the experimental and control groups will be guided by the data distributions. In case of deviation from normality assumptions, transformations of data may be done. Non-parametric tests will be used for non-normal and ordinal data. Possible confounders, such as socioeconomic factors, other background information, gestational age, thyroid hormones, TG, deiodinase polymorphisms and UIC, will be considered in the data analyses. Repeated measurements in a mixed model (where groups are compared repeatedly at 3.5, 7 and 14 years) and within-group analyses are planned. The models will also consider dropout frequency and recruitment from different maternal healthcare centres, which will be used as a factor in the analysis. For all dropouts, relevant background variables will be studied. Adjustments for bias may be performed. For non-informative dropouts, methods for multiple imputations will be considered. A multivariate analysis with total grey, total brain volume, intracranial volume, MTL volumes and possibly other measures of brain structure and function as independent variables will be conducted. The data analyses will be undertaken by an experienced statistician. Authorship will be decided according to the Declaration of Vancouver.

MRI considerations: where are changes from ID located?

T3 receptors are distributed among all brain areas with high levels in the hippocampi and the cerebellar cortex. Rodent data indicate T3 receptors are involved in the regulation of hippocampal structure and function.51 In the human cerebral cortex, thyroid receptors are already present in week 9 and concentrations increase up to 18 weeks of gestation.52 Considerable amounts of D2 are also found in the cerebral cortex.53 In the first half of pregnancy, the fetus is dependent on the mother’s supply of thyroid hormones. In mild ID, the mother maintains serum thyroid hormone levels through unknown compensatory mechanisms. In the second half of a mild ID pregnancy, when the fetus partly relies on its own thyroid hormone production, the fetus will be hypothyroid, as it has not developed compensatory mechanisms and there is a lack of sufficient iodine levels transferred by the mother.53

The description of neuropathology caused by ID is limited to few observations from adult cretins, ranging from severe cortical atrophy to almost normal appearance. In areas with endemic goitre, fetuses aborted in the second half of the pregnancy have a less differentiated cerebral cortex.53 In rats, transient periods of thyroid hormone insufficiency during periods of cortical development affect cortical and hippocampal cytoarchitecture.53

Human data from maternal hypothyroidism support an effect on the brain, specifically on the hippocampus.54 These data are in line with the recent publication by Korevaar et al,55 who conclude the relationship of IQ with FT4 (in peripheral blood) exhibits a U-shaped configuration with lower IQ levels in both ends of the normal range. FT4 in this study55 is also associated with total grey matter volume.

Considerations on the neuropsychological evaluation

Neuropsychological development can be divided into three domains: psychomotor, cognitive (IQ) and socioemotional development (figure 1). There are five landmark studies in the iodine field evaluating neuropsychological development in the offspring that use neuropsychological tests: the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (UK),19 Iodine Supplementation During Pregnancy and Infant Neuropsychological Development (INMA, Spain),56 Generation R (Netherlands),55 MITCH (India and Thailand)57 and Hynes et al (Australia).20 Verbal cognitive function appears to be the most susceptible subdomain for ID. In SWIDDICH, verbal cognitive function and total IQ were chosen (as the latter is the best understood and requested) as primary outcome measurements. As cognitive testing is less valid at younger ages, verbal IQ at 7 years was chosen as the primary evaluation time point, and all three domains of neuropsychological development will be evaluated at several follow-up times.

Figure 1

Neuropsychological domains. Verbal cognitive function, as a subdomain of cognition, appears the most susceptible subdomain for iodine deficiency and is the primary outcome of the Swedish Iodine in Pregnancy and Development in Children (SWIDDICH) study at the age of 7 years.

Implications for society and the individual

Impaired child development increases economic burdens for society. Lowered IQ is associated with worse economic outcomes and lower lifetime earnings. Small decrements in IQ around the mean are linked to lower incomes.58 59 IQ may be the easiest factor to quantify, but may not be the factor with the most serious consequence for a ‘good life’. Environmental factors, including ID, that place the nervous system at risk may affect executive functions, such as planning and initiating ideas, and result in attention problems, impulsive behaviour and inability to handle stress and disappointment, and can impede success in school and in life and possibly lead to antisocial behaviour.60

If the average IQ of a population drops, the IQ distribution shifts and the number of individuals with low IQ (eg, below 75 or 85, classified as intellectually disabled) increases. In turn, this will also decrease the number of gifted and exceptionally gifted people with high IQ (eg, above 130), who may have major positive impacts on the immediate future for a company or a country. A cost-benefit analysis of iodine supplementation in mild to moderate ID has recently proved positive.61

Based on the dollar value in 1987 in the USA, the cost in terms of reduced income for a 1 point IQ reduction has been calculated to nearly US$20.7 billion per year.62 A 3-point decline in IQ also impacts social costs in the USA60 and increases the risk of: poverty by 20% during the first 3 years; low birth weight by 12%; being a recipient of welfare by 18%; and high school dropout by 28%. Even though a decline of a few IQ points may be small for the individual, the societal effects are considerable. As a small general risk reduction entails a large social benefit, iodine supplementation could be a cost-effective action if the main hypothesis of this study holds true.

Considerations on possible adverse effects of iodine or placebo

Iodine supplementation may increase the frequency of postpartum thyroiditis (PPT), as iodine affects autoimmunity63: 10%–15% of women already have PPT and this number may increase slightly with iodine supplementation. As PPT is not a dangerous condition and most cases resolve spontaneously, we consider the reduced risk for subnormal brain development in a child motivates accepting the risk for PPT. In Denmark, PPT was evaluated in a placebo controlled trial in mild to moderate ID, and treatment did not increase or worsen PPT.63

Excess iodine intake in the mother may block thyroid function in the fetus, leading to hypothyroidism and goitre, and is associated with poorer mental and psychomotor development or behaviour problems in children.22 56 64 However, the risk for adverse effects of iodine supplementation is higher in cases of preconception ID due to sudden increase of iodine intake, and should therefore not be the case in Sweden where the normal population is iodine sufficient.65

The placebo group is at risk of ID during pregnancy. However, as there are no current recommendations for iodine supplementation during pregnancy in Sweden, this group follows normal management.

The intervention and the comparator are dietary supplements, and the total intake of nutrients depends on the diet. Information on adverse reactions is not collected.

Conclusion

The aim of this paper is to describe the study protocol for the SWIDDICH research project and the considerations that led to its design. The study attempts to further understand the consequences of mild ID during pregnancy and to test whether treatment of the mothers with iodine-containing multivitamins improves outcome in the children. As the study is the largest of its kind, it offers the potential for influencing future recommendations on iodine supplementation with multivitamins to pregnant women living in conditions of mild ID.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Elisabeth Gramatkovski,

Michael Hoppe and Therese Karlsson for their invaluable help as coordinators of the study.

References

  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7.
  8. 8.
  9. 9.
  10. 10.
  11. 11.
  12. 12.
  13. 13.
  14. 14.
  15. 15.
  16. 16.
  17. 17.
  18. 18.
  19. 19.
  20. 20.
  21. 21.
  22. 22.
  23. 23.
  24. 24.
  25. 25.
  26. 26.
  27. 27.
  28. 28.
  29. 29.
  30. 30.
  31. 31.
  32. 32.
  33. 33.
  34. 34.
  35. 35.
  36. 36.
  37. 37.
  38. 38.
  39. 39.
  40. 40.
  41. 41.
  42. 42.
  43. 43.
  44. 44.
  45. 45.
  46. 46.
  47. 47.
  48. 48.
  49. 49.
  50. 50.
  51. 51.
  52. 52.
  53. 53.
  54. 54.
  55. 55.
  56. 56.
  57. 57.
  58. 58.
  59. 59.
  60. 60.
  61. 61.
  62. 62.
  63. 63.
  64. 64.
  65. 65.
View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Contributors SM, BJ, AC, JE, KG, CJT, RE, HM, LH, MD and HNF contributed to the design of the SWIDDICH study. HNF wrote the first version of the manuscript and SM was responsible for pushing the work forward together with the other coworkers. All coauthors critically reviewed and approved the final version of the manuscript. SM is the guarantor. The primary sponsor is HNF (principal investigator), Sahlgrenska Academy and University of Göteborg and Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Göteborg, Sweden. The main study site is in Göteborg with additional sites in Umeå and Linköping.

  • Funding This work was supported by the ALF agreement (grant numbers ALFGBG 58777, ALFGBG 717311); Regional FOU (grant number VGFOUREG 664301); Lilla barnets fond (grant number 20160917); Svenska Läkarsällskapet (grant number SLS 688891); Lars Hiertas Minne Foundation (grant number FO2016 0016); Formas grant (grant number 2017 0095); and a grant from the General Maternity Hospital Foundation 2017. Multivitamins for the first 200 women were provided by Recip Medical, Solna, Sweden, but they are not involved in the study design and they do not contribute in any other way. The National Food Agency is a stakeholder in this trial. The authors of this manuscript solely contributed to the design, management, future analyses with the support of unbound statisticians, interpretation of data, writing the manuscript and decisions on where to submit. The maternal healthcare centres are reimbursed for the collection of patients by the principal investigator (HNF).

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Patient consent Not required.

  • Ethics approval Bioethics Committee of Gothenburg.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.