Objective To examine the associations between CD4 recovery, dyslipidaemia and apolipoprotein (APO) gene single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) following highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART).
Design Retrospective observational cohort study.
Setting A major HIV care clinic in Hong Kong.
Participants 197 Chinese treatment-naïve HIV patients.
Outcome measures Maximum CD4 count and its rise 2–3 years after HAART initiation and their association with abnormal total cholesterol (TC), triglyceride (TG) and 8 selected APO SNP at multiple time points.
Results Before HAART, abnormal levels of TC, TG, high-density lipoprotein cholesterol and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol were detected in 13%, 26%, 59% and 19% of the recruited patients, respectively. APOA5 −1131T>C and c.553G>T were significantly associated with high pre-HAART TG while APOE 2198C>T was correlated with high TG at baseline and/or a rise 2–3 years following HAART initiation. Poor CD4 achievement, defined as the highest CD4 count <350/μL and a net gain of <100/μL, was associated with a low CD4 count ≤200/μL at baseline and a rise of TC beyond 5.17 mmol/L following HAART with or without the use of antilipid agents. Conversely, satisfactory CD4 achievement was associated with APOC3 3238GG genotype. Applying a linear generalised estimating equation, APOA5 −1131T>C was shown to be a predictor of a weaker temporal trend for CD4 response in the presence of a low baseline CD4≤200/μL.
Conclusions Dyslipidaemia plays a predictive role in impacting immunological recovery following HAART, which could be partly explained by the APO gene SNP.
- GENITOURINARY MEDICINE
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study
Analyses of longitudinal data collected from a cohort of Chinese patients receiving treatment in accordance with standard protocol.
Both lipid levels and information on the selected apolipoprotein (APO) gene single nucleotide polymorphism were available to examine their impacts on immunological recovery following highly active antiretroviral therapy.
Only eight APO genes were selected for analysis in the study.
CD4 count alone was used for assessing immunological recovery.
The complex inter-relationships between hyperlipidaemia and HIV infection have continued to be unravelled, paralleling the progress of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART). In treatment-naïve patients, advanced HIV diseases have been reported to be associated with high plasma triglyceride (TG), low high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) and variable levels of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) and very-LDL-C,1–4 the relative importance of which depends also on the patients' nutritional status.5 With HAART, hyperlipidaemia has become increasingly reported, notably in association with regimens composed of ritonavir-boosted protease inhibitors (PIs).6 Lipid profile may also improve with the use of antilipid agents and the strategic selection of antiretrovirals (ARVs).7 Overall, the characteristics of HIV-related cardiovascular and metabolic complications have been extensively researched.5 ,8 As an important outcome of HAART, immunological recovery and the potential influences of hyperlipidaemia are becoming an emerging concern. Retrospective cohort studies suggested a positive correlation between HDL-C and nadir CD4 cell count.1 ,4 Similar patterns were reported in Asian communities,3 children9 and women.10 In the latter study, a higher CD4 count was associated with higher apolipoprotein (APO) B. Separately, an African cohort study reported that the LDL/HDL-C ratio and anthropometric markers contributed to the variability of CD4 reconstitution after 6 months of HAART.11
From the genetic perspective, HAART-associated hyperlipidaemia was under the influence of various forms of genetic polymorphisms, similar to the situation in non-HIV adults.12 ,13 The prevalence of such polymorphisms did vary from one population to another. A study in the Chinese population reported that APOA5 gene −1131T>C and c.553G>T were associated with high TG and could predict coronary artery disease.14 A cross-sectional study demonstrated that the same polymorphisms at APOA5 could affect circulating CD4 cell levels in chronically HIV-infected patients,15 inferring the effects of lipid metabolism on HAART-associated immune recovery. These results echoed the analyses conducted on a South African cohort, suggesting that metabolic parameters might account for as much as 44% of CD4 recovery following HAART.13 While these studies provided insights into the relationships between dyslipidaemia, host genetic polymorphism and CD4 recovery, a definitive conclusion is difficult partly because of the limitations inherent in the studies, many of which were cross-sectional in design. There was also scarcity of data on the temporal changes of lipid/immune markers, superimposed on the coexistence of confounders. These backgrounds have prompted us to conduct a retrospective cohort study on HIV-positive treatment-naïve patients of the same ethnicity with data from multiple time points to test the relationships between lipid/genetic polymorphism and CD4 recovery pattern.
Patients and methods
The study was conducted at the HIV specialist service of Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Hong Kong, an institution that looks after about a quarter of all reported HIV/AIDS cases in the territory. Following written informed consent, HIV-positive patients were recruited if they were Chinese and had been put on HAART, in accordance with local clinical guidelines founded on a CD4-guided approach to treatment initiation. In brief, treatment was recommended when the CD4 count fell below 350/μL. The following data were retrieved from clinical records anonymously: demographics; dates of HIV diagnosis and HAART initiation; HAART regimens—divided into either PI-based or non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NNRTI)-based; CD4 and viral load measurements every 3–4 months; lipid profiles—TG, total cholesterol (TC), HDL-C, LDL-C; and the use of lipid-lowering treatment at baseline and/or following HAART.
During a 9-month study period, all eligible cases were selected for analysis if they were ARV naïve at baseline, had been on their first HAART regimen ≥2 years without interruptions, had lipid measurements, a viral load and CD4 records made at baseline and during treatment, and had achieved viral suppression (defined as ≤500/mL) as a result of HAART. Patients with missing data on CD4 changes and lipid profiles were excluded. Blood samples were collected from eligible patients followed by the extraction of genomic DNA using QIAmp DNA kit (Qiagen) according to the manufacturer's protocol. The following candidate single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of APO genes were tested: APOA5 −1131T>C (rs662799), c.56C>G (S19W) (rs3135506) and c.553G>T (rs2075291); APOC3 −482C>T (rs2854117), -455T>C (rs2854116) and 3238C>G (rs5128); and APOE 2060T>C (rs429358) and 2198C>T (rs7412) by allelic discrimination using the custom TaqMan SNP Genotyping Assay (Applied Biosystems).16 ,17 Selection of these SNPs was based on results published in the literature as regards their association with dyslipidaemia following HAART.12 ,15 ,18
Lipid abnormalities were diagnosed according to the cut-off values defined by the US National Cholesterol Education Program Adult Treatment Panel III (NCEP-ATPIII) guidelines: TG ≥1.7 mmol/L; TC ≥5.17 mmol/L; HDL-C <1.03 mmol/L; LDL-C ≥3.36 mmol/L.19 Allele frequencies of SNPs were calculated by direct counting. The Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) for each SNP was tested using a χ2 HWE test calculator, considering equilibrium for p>0.05. Linear generalised estimating equations (GEEs) with an unstructured working correlation matrix were performed to examine the variation of selected SNP, hyperlipidaemia (TC and TG abnormality) and baseline CD4≤200/μL (independent variables) with a CD4 count across time (outcome variable). Sequential Bonferroni was used to adjust for multiple comparisons in GEE. Separately, univariate analysis (OR) was used to compare between patients with suboptimal and satisfactory CD4 recovery, followed by multivariate analyses. In this study, satisfactory CD4 recovery was defined as the attainment of the highest CD4 count above 350/μL at years 2–3 and a net gain of >100/μL above baseline, following criteria adopted in a previous study.20 All statistical analyses were performed in SPSS V.22 (IBM Corp) and R V.3.2.1.
General characteristics of recruited patients
Between August 2011 and March 2012, a total of 327 ARV-naïve patients attending the clinic were approached. Of these, 197 (60%) eligible patients were recruited after exclusion of cases with missing data. The general characteristics of recruited patients are displayed in table 1. Overall, their male-to-female ratio was 6.9:1, with a median age of 37 (IQR 31–44). The median pretreatment CD4 count and viral load were 103/μL (IQR 29–212) and 97 000/mL (IQR 34 000–279 000), respectively. The median duration of observation was 27 months (IQR 23–60). One hundred and forty-eight patients (75%) have been put on NNRTI-based ARV therapy, and 49 (25%) on PI-based therapy regimens. At study entry, patients in the NNRTI-treated and PI-treated groups were similar with regard to age, gender, nadir CD4 count and HIV viral load. All patients had demonstrable virus suppression with a viral load ≤500/mL after the initiation of HAART.
Lipid profile and APO gene polymorphisms
At baseline, a quarter (26%) of the patients had a high TG ≥1.7 mmol/L. The proportions with abnormal TC, HDL-C and LDL-C were 13%, 59% and 19% respectively, while 18 (9%) had already been receiving antilipid treatment before HAART. The genotype distributions of the SNPs in the tested APO genes were in HWE (p>0.05), except for APOA5 c.56C>G (S19W), in which case only one patient was tested positive for the SNP (see online supplementary table S1). Two mutated alleles, APOA5 −1131T>C and c.553G>T, were significantly associated with a high pre-HAART TG (ie, ≥1.7 mmol/L; 81% vs 55%, OR=3.43, 95% CI 1.38 to 8.51; 28% vs 10%, OR 3.32, 95% CI 1.27 to 8.68, respectively). There was otherwise no association between baseline lipids and the other APO gene SNPs (see online supplementary table S2(A)). Likewise, no difference was seen between homozygous and heterozygous SNP-containing genotypes as regards their association with dyslipidaemia (results not shown). Concerning the impacts of ARV therapy, patients on NNRTI were more likely to have abnormal HDL-C <1.03 mmol/L at baseline compared with those on PI (39% vs 67%, OR=3.11, 95% CI 1.15 to 8.41).
Following the initiation of HAART, 44/94 (47%) of the recruited participants with a normal lipid profile at baseline had developed dyslipidaemia at years 2–3—elevated TG 27/72 (38%), TC 26/85 (31%), LDL-C 6/24 (25%) and reduced HDL-C 2/14 (14%)—while 3/93 (3%) had started on antilipid agents. There was no difference between PI-based and NNRTI-based regimens in their development of dyslipidaemia (results not shown). Expanding the definition of dyslipidaemia to include abnormal lipid levels after HAART as well as the use of antilipid agents, the mutated APOA5 allele −1131T>C remained significantly associated with abnormal TG (see online supplementary table S2(B)) Separately, the mutated APOE allele 2198C>T was associated with a rise in TG at baseline and/or years 2–3 following HAART initiation, with the inclusion of patients on antilipid treatment. There was, however, no association between abnormal TG at years 2–3 following HAART and any one of the eight APO SNPs for patients with normal lipid levels at baseline (see online supplementary table S2(C)). As for abnormal TC and LDL-C, there was again no genetic association with any of the tested SNPs at any specific time point following HAART.
Immune recovery and its correlates
In the subsequent analyses, satisfactory CD4 achievement was defined as the attainment of the highest CD4 count above 350/μL at years 2–3 and a net gain of >100/μL above baseline.20 Results of 140 patients were available for the analyses, of which 75 (53.5%) could be classified as satisfactory CD4 achievers. Comparing between low and satisfactory CD4 achievers, a low baseline CD4 count ≤200/μL was a negative associating factor (86% vs 69%, OR=0.36, p=0.02; table 2). The extent of CD4 recovery was not related to baseline dyslipidaemia, but was associated with a rise of TC beyond 5.17 mmol/L with or without the use of antilipid agents following HAART. Age, baseline viral load and gender did not show any relationship with CD4 achievement. The allelic frequency of APO SNPs tested did not show any significant difference between low and satisfactory CD4 achievers. Patients homozygous for the mutated APOC3 allele 3238C>G were more likely to give a satisfactory CD4 achievement compared with heterozygous patients (OR 3.74, 95% CI 1.07 to 13.13; see online supplementary table S3). The temporal difference in the maximum yearly CD4 between patients with normal TC and abnormal TC (at baseline and/or a rise above normal range following HAART) is shown in online supplementary figure. Multivariable analysis confirmed that both a low CD4 baseline count and increased TC following HAART were associated with poorer immune recovery.
The possible influence of dyslipidaemia and APO SNP on longitudinal CD4 trend over an extended period of up to 3 years was examined using GEE. Three APO gene mutations were included in the analyses: APOA5 −1131T>C allele, APOA5 c.553G>T allele and APOC3 genotype 3238GG. The other input variables were: yearly time points, baseline CD4 (count ≤200/μL or >200/μL), abnormal TC (≥5.17 mmol/L at baseline or 2–3 years after initiation of HAART, and/or the use of antilipid treatment), abnormal TG (≥1.7 mmol/L at baseline or 2–3 years after initiation of HAART, and/or the use of antilipid treatment). Two sets of models were constructed for the exploration, one focusing on abnormal lipids and the other on the selected APO mutated alleles/genotype which have been shown to be associated either with hypertriglyceridaemia or with the ultimate CD4 recovery. The main results of GEE are displayed in table 3, using yearly maximum CD4 as the dependent variable. Abnormal TC but not TG was consistently associated with a poorer CD4 recovery, in conjunction with or without a low baseline CD4. On the other hand, the APOA5 mutated allele −1131T>C was also a predictor of a weaker CD4 recovery over time. The impact was, however modest, as the association could not be demonstrated in the absence of a low baseline CD4 count ≤200/μL. No statistically significant correlation can be found between the APOA5 mutated allele c.553G>T or the APOC3 mutated genotype 3238GG and the temporal trend of CD4 recovery.
In this study, we set out to examine the inter-relationships between dyslipidaemia and immune recovery following the initiation of HAART in chronic HIV infection. Since hyperlipidaemia can be a result of a multitude of factors, we attempted to minimise, as far as possible, the effects of confounders by focusing on a cohort composed of patients with the same ethnic background (ie, Chinese), and limiting the analyses to the situation in the first 2–3 years following the initiation of HAART. The temporal trend of dyslipidaemia was assessed, alongside the evaluation of the effects of selected APO SNPs. Our results confirmed that satisfactory CD4 achievement was negatively associated with a low baseline CD4 count, as has been reported by us and reviewed elsewhere.20 ,21 It is interesting to note, however, that dyslipidaemia did play an important role in the temporal pattern of immune recovery. Specifically, an elevation of plasma TC above 5.17 mmol/L, rather than the absolute values at specific time point(s), in the 2–3 year period following initiation of HAART, was associated with poorer CD4 recovery. The latter's associations with TG, LDL-C and HDL-C could not be demonstrated. The effect of the boosted PI-based regimen on dyslipidaemia reported in other studies was also not seen in our cohort.22 Our results could be related to the clinical decision of attending physicians on restricting the use of PI to patients without baseline dyslipidaemia, such that the lipid profile of PI-treated patients was different from those on NNRTI. It is therefore difficult to compare between the two treatment groups in terms of temporal changes of plasma lipids. The relatively small proportion (<5%) of patients requiring antilipid agents following HAART could be partly explained by the short observation period during which dyslipidaemia tended to be moderate.
From the perspective of host genetics, our results did not support a strong influence of the selected APO SNPs on immune recovery. At baseline, the associations between mutated APOA5 alleles −1131T>C and c.553G>T with high baseline TG were seen, confirming results of similar population studies on HIV12 and non-HIV patients.23 Our results on the associations between specific APO SNP and lipid profiles were not entirely the same as observations made in other reported studies.12 ,13 ,18 ,22 ,24 The discrepancies might have arisen from the differences in study design and/or the recruitment criteria applied in enrolling HIV patients. As regards immune recovery, the APOC3 3238GG genotype was shown to be associated with a better CD4 recovery 2–3 years after HAART, an observation not seen for other SNPs or genotypes for the eight selected APO genes under investigation; neither has this been reported in the literature. In assessing the temporal trend of CD4 increase using a GEE model, no correlation could be demonstrated with APOC3 3238GG. The same GEE model, however, showed that the APOA5 allele −1131T>C was associated with a smaller CD4 increase over time, an observation similar to that reported by Echeverria et al.15 Other SNPs did not show any significant association with dyslipidaemia or CD4 achievement at any time points during the study, and which therefore have not been included in the GEE for further analysis. Though the selected APO SNP may predispose individuals to dyslipidaemia, there could also be strong influences of one's stage of HIV illness, nutritional status, diet, ethnicity, as well as the HAART regimens prescribed. The immunological impacts of SNP may therefore be hard to elicit if it is moderate, and especially so in the presence of the interplay between multiple factors in our cohort study. Since a CD4-guided approach was adopted as a standard practice for the initiation of HAART during the study period, the baseline pretreatment lipid profile is also likely to vary in accordance with the CD4 threshold adopted in different clinical cohorts.
The association between dyslipidaemia and immune recovery could be explained by the phenomenon of systemic inflammation, the latter long known to be a hallmark of both chronic HIV infection25 ,26 as well as hyperlipidaemia.27 In chronically infected HIV patients, the inflammation burden was reported to be associated with elevated TC and TG, in the background of virological suppression following HAART.28 In the presence of ongoing activation of the innate and adaptive immune system, fuelled by the presence of proinflammatory cytokines, there is progressive destruction of CD4 cells.25 Early initiation of HAART with a PI-based regimen has been reported to promote rapid CD4 recovery.29 The impact of dyslipidaemia either at baseline or following treatment was, however, not examined in the latter study. Another small-scale study that involved the addition of an integrase inhibitor, a lipid-neutral ARV, was shown to decrease the level of the inflammatory marker but failed to demonstrate any increase in CD4 counts.30 The use of an antilipid agent has in fact been examined as a means of reducing T-cell activation. There appeared to be a greater reduction of CD4 and CD8 cell activation, respectively, following statin, but improvement of the CD4 trend was not consistently demonstrated.31–33 In our cohort, abnormal levels of TC, TG, HDL-C and LDL-C were prevalent before HAART initiation. The results in our study confirmed the association between hyperlipidaemia, notably a rise from normal to high level following HAART, and a poorer CD4 recovery in the first 2–3 years after treatment initiation, with the APO gene polymorphism (notably APOA5 −1131T>C and APOC3 3238GG) playing a moderate role in parallel. The impacts of dyslipidaemia on immune activation might have counterbalanced the effects of HAART on CD4 recovery. Since the testing of inflammatory markers was not included in the original study design, the negative association between inflammation and CD4 recovery remains speculative. Other studies have suggested that CD4/CD8 inversion could be a marker of immune senescence and metabolic complication of chronic HIV infection, the latter characterised again by dyslipidaemia.34
We acknowledge that our study did carry some inherent limitations. By focusing on ARV-naïve patients with the same ethnic background, we were able to minimise the influences of confounders but had restricted ourselves to the analysis of a relatively small number of patients from the cohort. Generalisability of the results should therefore be made with caution. In the host genetic studies, we have only explored the impacts of eight selected APO SNPs while other genetic factors may knowingly also have contributed to dyslipidaemia.12 ,13 ,24 In the assessment of immune recovery, CD4 counts were measured as the only marker of the body's response. The potential impacts of hyperlipidaemia on T cell activation and monocyte homoeostasis have not been evaluated.31–33 ,35 Neither have we examined the effects of treatment on the CD4/CD8 ratio, an indicator of effective immunological outcome that has recently been shown to be associated with the level of cumulative viraemia.36 The observation period was relatively short and may not allow conclusions to be drawn on the long-term impacts of dyslipidaemia, though the effects in the initial 2–3 years of HAART can be effectively elicited. Finally, the provision of antilipid in some patients may have partly complicated the clinical pictures. In our analyses, antilipid treatment at baseline and following ARV therapy were included as surrogates of dyslipidaemia, on the assumption that there could be relatively little or no impacts of such treatment on CD4 recovery in the first few years of HAART. Despite these drawbacks, this small study on a cohort of Chinese treatment-naïve patients, through genetic, statistical analyses and GEE, has enabled us to delineate the complex relationships between dyslipidaemia, APO gene polymorphisms and CD4 recovery. Further research on the biological pathways on inflammation and immune recovery would be crucial to better understand the situation so as to inform optimisation of ARV therapy.
The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of Miss Mandy Li for her data entry and database management and also thank the Li Ka Shing Institute of Health Sciences for providing laboratory support.
Contributors S-SL conceptualised the study. CMN, M-PL and DP-CC developed the study protocols. DP-CC performed experiments on the APO gene SNP. M-PL coordinated the study at the clinic and collated the data in conjunction with DP-CC. RK-KL contributed to the initial data exploration, while N-SW worked on the final analyses described in this manuscript. CMN and DP-CC prepared the preliminary draft of the manuscript, which was subsequently revised by N-SW and S-SL. The final version of the manuscript was developed and edited by S-SL. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript.
Funding This work was supported by funding from the Council for the AIDS Trust Fund (Project MSS173R), and the Health and Medical Research Fund (Project CU-15-A15), Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government.
Disclaimer The funders were neither involved in the planning and design nor analyses arising from the study.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent Obtained.
Ethics approval Research Ethics Committee of The Joint Chinese University of Hong Kong—New Territories East Cluster, and Kowloon Central/Kowloon East Cluster of the Hospital Authority.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement No additional data are available.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.