Article Text
PDF
Abstract
Objectives To study Mesoamerican nephropathy (MeN) and its risk factors in three hot occupations.
Design Cross-sectional.
Setting Chinandega and León municipalities, a MeN hotspot on the Nicaraguan Pacific coast, January–February 2013.
Participants 194 male workers aged 17–39 years: 86 sugarcane cutters, 56 construction workers, 52 small-scale farmers.
Outcome measures (1) Differences between the three occupational groups in prevalences/levels of socioeconomic, occupational, lifestyle and health risk factors for chronic kidney disease (CKD) and in biomarkers of kidney function and hydration; (2) differences in prevalences/levels of CKD risk factors between workers with reduced estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFRCKD-EPI <80 mL/min/1.73 m2) and workers with normal kidney function (eGFRCKD-EPI ≥80 mL/min/1.73 m2).
Results Sugarcane cutters were more exposed to heat and consumed more fluid on workdays and had less obesity, lower blood sugar, lower blood pressure and a better lipid profile. Reduced eGFR occurred in 16%, 9% and 2% of sugarcane cutters, construction workers and farmers, respectively (trend cane > construction > farming, p=0.003). Significant trends (cane > construction > farming) were also observed for high serum urea nitrogen (blood urea nitrogen (BUN) >20 mg/dL), high serum creatinine (SCr >1.2 mg/dL), low urinary pH (≤5.5) and high BUN/SCr ratio (>20) but not for high urinary specific gravity (≥1.030). Sugarcane cutters also more often had proteinuria and blood and leucocytes in the urine. Workers with eGFR <80 mL/min/1.73 m2 reported a higher intake of water and lower intake of sugary beverages. Serum uric acid levels related strongly and inversely to eGFR levels (adj β −10.4 mL/min/1.73 m2, 95% CI −12.2 to −8.5, p<0.001). No associations were observed for other metabolic risk factors, pesticides, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs or alcohol. Among cane cutters, consumption of electrolyte hydration solution appeared preventive (adj β 8.1 mL/min/1.73 m2, p=0.09).
Conclusions Heat stress, dehydration and kidney dysfunction were most common among sugarcane cutters. Kidney dysfunction also occurred to a lesser extent among construction workers, but hardly at all among small-scale farmers. High serum uric acid was associated with reduced kidney function.
- NEPHROLOGY
- PUBLIC HEALTH
- OCCUPATIONAL & INDUSTRIAL MEDICINE
- EPIDEMIOLOGY
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study
The study provides a detailed description of exposures to potential risk factors for Mesoamerican nephropathy (MeN) among workers in three occupations of special interest: subsistence farmers, construction workers and sugarcane cutters.
The study established the prevalence of kidney dysfunction and dehydration among workers in these three distinct occupations at risk for MeN.
The cross-sectional design limits causal interpretations about associations between the potential risk factors and the markers of kidney function, but the study provides clues for aetiology and possible pathways of kidney injury.
Most exposures to risk factors are self-reported, but much attention was paid to the quality of the questionnaires.
Introduction
Mesoamerican nephropathy (MeN), an epidemic of chronic kidney disease (CKD), is a chronic tubulointerstitial disease unrelated to traditional CKD risk factors, affecting predominantly young male workers in Pacific coastal communities of Central America and possibly southern Mexico.1–4 Several tens of thousands of people have died of this disease.3 Although MeN is often described as an epidemic of agricultural workers,1 ,5–8 in Central America sugarcane workers are clearly the most affected population.1 ,9 ,10
A consistent risk factor for MeN appears to be heavy manual labour in extreme heat.1 Manual sugarcane cutters exert substantial amounts of energy, often in environmental temperatures over 35°C and high humidity.11–13 Besides heat stress, some sugarcane workers are also exposed to pesticides, either at sugarcane plantations or while labouring in other crops.11 ,14 Consumption of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) to manage muscle pain is common.15 Exposure to heavy metals may occur through contaminated pesticide formulations and fertilisers, as has been shown in Sri Lanka,16 contaminated drinking water,17 or even during burning of the cane.18 Overall, exposure of sugarcane workers to different potential CKD risk factors has not been described in detail.
A leading hypothesis is that recurrent dehydration, possibly in combination with exposure to other agents (eg, NSAIDs, heavy metals, agrochemicals, high fructose intake) may be a driving factor.1 ,4 Animal experiments have shown that dehydration and hyperosmolarity may induce tubular injury via activation of the polyol-fructokinase pathway in the kidney.19 Recently, a mechanism of hyperuricaemia and cyclical uricosuria associated with volume loss and dehydration has also been proposed.20 ,21
Studies suggest that MeN may also occur among miners and construction workers,5 ,22 cotton workers23 and subsistence farmers.6 However, these cross-sectional data mostly consider current occupation and are therefore not conclusive. Cane cutting is seasonal and many sugarcane workers are also subsistence farmers or work in construction. Contrary to contracted workers, independent small-scale farmers have control over their work hours and are able to avoid the hottest temperatures. Prevalence studies have been recommended to assess exposure to CKD risk factors and kidney dysfunction in different occupations.1
The aim of this study was to compare the prevalence of a range of potential CKD risk factors among sugarcane cutters, construction workers and small-scale farmers labouring in the same hot environment, along with biomarkers of hydration and kidney function. We hypothesise that sugarcane cutters experience more heat stress, more dehydration and more signs of kidney dysfunction than small-scale farmers, with construction workers somewhere in between.
Methods
Study population and recruitment
This is a cross-sectional study. We recruited 194 male workers aged 17–39 years, all living in the municipalities of Chinandega and León in the Pacific region of Nicaragua, a major epicentre for the MeN epidemic. Of these, 86 were sugarcane cutters, 56 construction workers and 52 small-scale farmers. Cane cutters from several sugarcane villages were recruited with the help of community leaders; a trade union assisted in recruiting construction workers employed by private companies at three construction sites; and a rural farmer association helped to recruit associated farmers dedicated full time to the cultivation of subsistence crops. The response rate was 86% among cane cutters and there were no refusals among construction workers and farmers.
The study was approved by the Ethical Review Board of UNAN-León, Nicaragua. All participants provided written informed consent.
Data collection
Data were collected for sugarcane cutters during January 2013, 2 months after the sugarcane harvest started, and during February 2013 for construction workers and farmers under similar climatic conditions. In each of the sugarcane and farming villages a well-known public place was selected as the data collection station; construction workers were evaluated at their work site. Data collection started between 05:30 and 06:00 hours on the morning after a workday and blood and urine samples were collected after overnight fasting.
Medical measurements and biological samples
Blood pressure was measured with a calibrated digital sphygmomanometer with the participant seated after resting for 10 min. Weight was measured with a calibrated digital flat mobile scale and height with a foldable stadiometer. Certified technicians collected blood samples in vacuum tubes for centrifugation and serum separation and in a tube with anticoagulant for blood cell count. Samples without coagulant were centrifuged on the spot at 3500 rpm for 10 min at room temperature. All samples were placed on ice and transported the same day to the laboratory at the Research Center on Health, Work and Environment (CISTA) at UNAN-León where haematocrit and haemoglobin were determined with a Mindray 2300 haematology analyser and the serum samples were frozen at −80°C. After finalising all data collection, serum samples were transported to the National Diagnostic and Reference Center of the Ministry of Health (CNDR-MINSA) of Nicaragua, which takes part in an international interlaboratory quality control programme. Samples were analysed with Cobas Integra 400, an automated equipment which uses a photometric test to determine levels of serum glucose, lipid profile, serum uric acid (S-UA) and blood urea nitrogen (BUN) and a Jaffe compensated method for quantification of serum creatinine (SCr). SCr was calibrated against IDMS-traceable creatinine. Blind spiked and duplicate blood samples from each tenth participant were in 95% within 1 SD. A urinalysis dipstick was performed on a spot morning sample using a Bayer Clinitek 50 Urine Chemistry Analyser with Multistix 10SG reagent strips (Siemens Diagnostics, USA) with semi-quantitative measurements of protein (≥30–<300 mg/dL and ≥300 mg/dL, glucose (positive at ≥100 mg/dL), urinary specific gravity (USG) (1.000–1.030), pH (5.0–8.5), blood (+ to +++), nitrite (positive), leucocyte esterase (+ to +++), bilirubin (+ to +++), ketone (≥5 mg/dL) and urobilinogen (≥2 Ehrlich units).
Questionnaires
Questionnaires were applied by trained interviewers with courses on bioethics and good clinical practices. A questionnaire on work and health obtained data on demographics and employment (age, education, drinking water source, income, type of contract, sub-employment, social security), lifestyle (smoking, alcohol, drugs, fluid intake on non-working days), health (medically diagnosed diseases, nephrotoxic medications), work history (industry, job titles, job duration, crops, pesticides) and occupational heat stress determinants (shift duration, breaks, shadow, work speed, heavy loads; in addition, for sugarcane workers, incentives to cut more cane and hours between cane burning and entering the field). This questionnaire was developed based on versions used in previous studies in the region.5 ,23 ,24
A second questionnaire, developed at the National Institute of Public Health in Mexico, obtained data on the types and amounts of fluids and food items consumed during the day (always a workday) before the interview. The amount of fructose contained in the food and drinking items was estimated based on a fructose calculation list of the Mexican questionnaire25 and the USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference for items not included in the Mexican questionnaire.26
Statistical analysis
Data were analysed with SPSS Statistics 20. Glomerular filtration rate estimated by the CKD-EPI equation (eGFRCKD-EPI) was the main outcome measure, categorised into <80 mL/min/1.73 m2 and ≥80 mL/min/1.73 m2. This cut-off point was chosen instead of the traditional<60 because too few workers had estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) <60. Prevalences of high BUN (>20 mg/dL), high SCr (>1.2 mg/dL), high S-UA (>7.2 mg/dL) and protein >30 mg/dL, blood, nitrites or leucocytes in urine were secondary measures of kidney dysfunction. Prevalences of high USG (≥1.030), low urinary pH (≤5.5) and high BUN/SCr ratio (>20) were used as indicators of dehydration.
Self-reported social and work history items, diseases and medications, and heat stress exposure variables were dichotomised. A category of high tobacco consumption was created with subjects in the upper quartile of ever smokers (≥3 pack-years) and a category of high alcohol consumption composed of subjects in the upper tertiles of lifetime alcohol consumption (≥80 000 g) or average weekly consumption (≥125 g). Total fluid intake was defined as drinking water plus sugary drinks (natural fruit refreshments, sodas, coffee, tea and electrolyte solution) and reported as litres of total liquids consumed the previous (work) day and for comparison also for a typical non-work day, with subcategories into water only and sugary drinks. Total fructose intake was estimated from all food and fluids consumed including chewed cane and stratified into fructose from food sources and added sugars. Fructose variables were categorised into quartiles. The cut-off for body mass index was set at ≥25 kg/m2. Hypertension was defined as systolic blood pressure ≥140 mm Hg and/or diastolic blood pressure ≥90 mm Hg, or a self-reported medical history of hypertension. Diabetes was defined as serum glucose ≥125 mg/dL in the fasting serum sample or a self-reported medical history of diabetes. Use of nephrotoxic medications was recorded if taken at least three times per week for more than 3 months in the case of NSAIDs and other analgesics, or administered for at least a week in the case of nephrotoxic antibiotics, during the last year. Blood and urine biochemical parameters were explored as continuous variables or defined as normal versus abnormal using standard clinical cut-off values.
Differences between occupations were assessed with ANOVA and Kruskal-Wallis tests for normally and not normally distributed continuous variables, respectively, and Pearson χ2 test for categorical variables or Fisher's exact test when the χ2 test was not applicable. Post hoc tests were performed with Tukey's HSD test for continuous results and post-hoc χ2 as described by Franke et al.27 With occupation as the main proxy for heat stress, we assessed trends for sugarcane cutters > construction workers > farmers for prevalences of markers of kidney dysfunction and dehydration over the ordered occupational groups with the gamma statistic.
Differences in the distribution of risk factors between subjects with reduced and normal kidney function were explored for all occupations combined (n=194) and restricted to sugarcane cutters (n=86), with Whitney U-tests for continuous variables and χ2 tests or Fisher's exact test for categorical variables. Exact p values are reported and p values ≤0.05 were considered statistically significant. Multivariate linear regression models were constructed for all workers and restricted to sugarcane cutters, with factors that were different between subjects with reduced and normal kidney function at p<0.10. Residuals from the regressions were checked to assess the fit of the models.
Results
Potential risk factors for CKD/MeN among the three occupations
Socioeconomic and health-related CKD risk factors
Socioeconomic CKD risk indicators were unfavourable for all workers, but somewhat less for construction workers (table 1A). Farmers had the lowest income and sugarcane cutters were significantly less educated with an average of 4 years of elementary schooling. With regard to lifestyle and medical factors (table 1B), sugarcane cutters had lower prevalences of high tobacco and alcohol consumption. There were no major differences in the use of nephrotoxic drugs between the groups. None of the workers had been previously diagnosed with diabetes and only five had hyperglycaemia >125 mg/dL (2 sugarcane cutters, 2 construction workers and 1 farmer). Sugarcane cutters showed less obesity, better lipid profiles, lower heart rates and lower blood pressure but more anaemia (36% with haemoglobin <13 g/dL). There were no differences in total leucocyte count between occupations.
Socioeconomic and health indicators relevant for chronic kidney disease/Mesoamerican nephropathy risk among workers in three occupations, municipalities of Chinandega and León, Nicaragua, 2013
Occupational heat exposure, fluid and fructose intake and pesticides
On average, construction workers had an effective work time of 8 hours and farmers had the shortest with 5 hours, whereas sugarcane workers actively cut cane for 6.5 hours per day (table 2A). A higher proportion of sugarcane workers perceived a very rapid work pace and had to take rest breaks in the absence of shade; 83% received incentives for cutting more cane and almost half started harvesting within 12 hours of burning the cane. Sugarcane cutters more often reported weight loss related to the current job (over the last 2 months) and fainting on the job (6% compared with 2% of farmers and no construction workers). Dysuria (‘chistata’), a common symptom in MeN affected areas thought to be related to dehydration,15 ,24 was not different between the three groups.
Occupational heat stress, fluid and fructose intake and pesticide exposure indicators among workers in three occupations, municipalities of Chinandega and León, Nicaragua, 2013
With regard to fluid intake (table 2B), sugarcane cutters reported on average 6.2 L of total fluid intake the previous (work) day, 70% (4.4 L) as water and almost 30% (1.8 L) as sugary drinks. This was higher than for construction workers and farmers. Intake of water and sugary beverages were not correlated (rp=0.01). In contrast, there was no difference between the three groups for total fluid, water and sugary drinks intake on non-work days.
Fructose intake during the previous day was highest for sugarcane cutters and 41% of sugarcane cutters belonged to the category of highest quartile of consumption of total fructose (>107 g) (table 2B). Fructose intake from food was low among sugarcane cutters and most came from added sugars during work hours, specifically from sweetened beverages, electrolyte hydration solution (one-third of cutters) and cane chewing (about two-thirds). Fructose intake outside work hours was not different between the groups.
With regard to pesticide exposures (table 2C), farmers used pesticides most frequently (71%) compared with almost half of sugarcane cutters and only 11% of construction workers. Glyphosate and 2,4-D use was more common among sugarcane cutters whereas paraquat and the insecticides cypermethrin and chlorpyrifos were used more often by farmers. With the exception of cypermethrin, which had been used by almost half of the farmers, no specific pesticide exceeded 25% of users in any of the groups.
Status of kidney function and hydration by occupation
Kidney function biomarkers were more commonly abnormal among sugarcane cutters, with significant differences between the groups for prevalences of eGFR <80 mL/min/1.73 m2 (16%, 9% and 2% in sugarcane cutters, construction workers and small-scale farmers, respectively; p for trend=0.003), high SCr (p for trend=0.02) and high BUN (p for trend=0.003) (table 3A). Likewise, proteinuria >30 mg/dL was approximately three times more prevalent in sugarcane workers than in the other groups (15% vs 5–6%, p for trend=0.08), whereas leucocyturia was observed in 22% of sugarcane workers but in only 0–2% of the other heat-exposed groups (p<0.001). Microhaematuria was also three times more prevalent in sugarcane workers, but this difference was not statistically significant (6% vs 2%, p for trend=0.19). High S-UA was more common among sugarcane cutters (17%) and construction workers (16%) than among farmers (6%).
Biomarkers of kidney function and dehydration among workers in three occupations and trend over categories ordered by exposure to occupational heat stress (sugarcane > construction > farming), municipalities of Chinandega and León, Nicaragua, 2013
Regarding markers of dehydration, the prevalence of concentrated urine (USG ≥1.030) was not statistically different between groups (table 3B). Low urinary pH occurred in 29% of sugarcane cutters versus 12% of construction workers and farmers (p=0.01) and sugarcane cutters more commonly had an elevated BUN/SCr ratio (26% vs 0 and 4% of construction workers and farmers, p<0.001). Trends over ordered categories were significant for urinary pH and BUN/SCr ratio. Although sugarcane cutters as a group had a lower prevalence of concentrated urine, within the group low fluid intake was strongly associated with concentrated urine (OR 3.5, p=0.06) and acidic urine (OR 8.7, p<0.001), which was not the case among construction workers and farmers (table 4).
Associations between low intake of fluids and markers of dehydration among sugarcane cutters (n=86) and non-cutters (construction workers and small-scale farmers) (n=108)
Risk factors for reduced kidney function
In bivariate analyses of differences in kidney, urinary and metabolic biomarkers, work practices, hydration practices and lifestyle characteristics between subjects with reduced kidney function (eGFR <80 mL/min/1.73 m2) and subjects with normal kidney function (eGFR ≥80 mL/min/1.73 m2) (see online supplementary table S1), reduced kidney function was significantly associated with work as a sugarcane cutter, high intake of water, low intake of sugary beverages, increasing age, low haemoglobin and high tobacco consumption. In analyses restricted to sugarcane cutters the results were similar and, in addition, workers with reduced kidney function had cut cane for a considerably longer time than those with normal kidney function (cumulative time on the job: median 108 vs 60 months, p=0.06). Sugarcane cutters with reduced kidney function reported almost three times higher water intake and three times lower intake of sugary beverages than cutters with normal kidney function, with only one of the 14 reporting intake of the electrolyte solution. In addition, the cane cutters with reduced kidney function had a worse lipid profile than those with normal kidney function and more often had hypertension, but none had diabetes or hyperglycaemia and only one was overweight (see online supplementary table S1).
supplementary table
In backwards stepping multivariate linear regression analyses with inclusion of variables with p≤0.10 in the bivariate analyses (except haemoglobin due to missing data), age (β −1.3, 95% CI −1.8 to −0.8; p<0.001) and S-UA (β −10.4, 95% CI −12.2 to −8.5; p<0.001) were significantly associated with reduced kidney function among all workers, which was identical in models with total fluid intake and with intake of water and sugary beverages separately (table 5A). In the subset of sugarcane cutters, too many variables had a p value ≤0.10 in bivariate analyses (see online supplementary table S1) and therefore the regression was done in two steps. Hypertension, lipid profile tests and blood sugar were not associated with reduced kidney function in a model also including age and S-UA (data not shown) and were not further considered. In a model with water intake, intake of sugary drinks (without electrolyte solution) and intake yes/no of electrolyte solution, age, S-UA, high tobacco consumption and high alcohol consumption (table 5B), reduced kidney function was associated significantly with age and S-UA and non-significantly with the intake of electrolyte solution (β 8.1, 95% CI −1.2 to 17.5, p=0.09). Age and cumulative months on the job correlated (rp 0.68, p<0.001), and substituting age with time cutting cane yielded similar results.
Multivariate linear regression models of estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFRCKD-EPI) among all workers (sugarcane cutters, construction workers and farmers) and restricted to sugarcane cutters
Discussion
This study found evidence for more frequent heat stress, dehydration and kidney dysfunction among sugarcane cutters, as expected, and to a lesser degree also reduced kidney function among construction workers but not among small-scale farmers. Also, as expected, S-UA levels increased with decreasing eGFR.
Evidence of reduced kidney function
We used a cut-off of eGFR of 80 mL/min/1.73 m2 to evaluate differences in renal function because only 11 workers had eGFR <60 due to their young age (all under age 40) and also because sugarcane workers were screened by employers before the start of the harvest 2 months earlier and workers with SCr >1.2 mg/dL were not hired and, thus, were not part of our study population. Despite this, approximately one-quarter of sugarcane cutters had evidence for either eGFR <80 mL/min/1.73 m2, SCr >1.2 mg/dL or proteinuria ≥30 mg, and these findings were, respectively, eight-, three- and twofold more common than those observed in subsistence farmers and about twofold more common than in construction workers (table 3). However, although to a lesser degree than cane cutters, construction workers also had an unusually high prevalence of decreased kidney function, which is in accordance with a previous unpublished study in the same area.25 In contrast, the single small-scale farmer with reduced kidney function had worked previously in sugarcane. Thus, our results show that not all agricultural workers are at increased risk for CKD, as is commonly stated, but rather workers in certain types of agriculture and other jobs in the heat such as work in the construction industry. The absence of reduced kidney function among subsistence farmers is consistent with a study in a MeN epidemic area in El Salvador, where subsistence farmers without a history of plantation work had a significantly lower prevalence of abnormal SCr than men who had worked on sugar or cotton plantations (15% vs 33%).20 Reduced kidney function was accompanied by a higher frequency of anaemia among sugarcane cutters (36% vs 4–9% in the other groups). The prevalence of anaemia was higher than the prevalence of reduced kidney function and cannot be simply ascribed to the higher frequency of reduced renal function. Marked anaemia, defined as Hb <10 g/dL, was not observed in any of the groups.
Reduced kidney function was not associated with traditional risk factors for CKD. Notably, there were no cases of confirmed diabetes in the entire population. Importantly, sugarcane workers showed significantly worse renal function despite an overall lower frequency of abnormal lipid profile, hypertension and obesity compared with the other two groups (see table 1). Increasing age (>50 years) is a known risk factor for CKD, but in our study increasing age was associated with a decline in renal function despite the young age of the study participants. This is possibly related to an increased risk with continued job exposure over time, in particular among the sugarcane cutters. Thus, our study suggests that most cases of reduced kidney function are related to MeN and not classic CKD.
Evidence for heat stress
There was evidence for a greater risk of heat stress among sugarcane cutters. Sugarcane cutters laboured at a faster pace, had less exposure to shade, reported more weight loss during the ongoing harvest and had more fainting episodes. While sugarcane cutters had greater heat stress exposure, they also drank more fluids during the course of the day, amounting to an average of 6.2 L per day (although this varied considerably, with approximately 20% drinking <2.5 L/day and 40% >7 L/day). However, the type of exertion and sweating that occurs with cane harvesting11–13 could still result in a dramatic loss of fluids such that dehydration can occur despite high fluid consumption. Cade et al28 found that college football players could lose as much as 8 quarts (about 7.6 L) of water in a 2-hour period, associated with loss of salt, decrease in blood glucose and a fall in blood pressure.
Potential mechanisms involved in inducing kidney damage
Daily heat stress and dehydration may cause repeated renal hypoperfusion episodes, and intermittent subclinical rhabdomyolysis associated with excessive exertion may also induce repeated acute kidney injury through the release of inflammatory mediators including oxidants, cytokines and uric acid which, over time, leads to CKD.18 Experimental evidence has shown that repeated exposure to heat stress caused a reduction in renal function accompanied by histological evidence of tubulointerstitial damage.19 Heat stress is known to raise S-UA levels, in part from subclinical rhabdomyolysis29 but also from reduced renal blood flow.30 In turn, hyperuricaemia is a well-known risk factor for CKD31 and mediates both glomerular and tubulointerstitial disease in animals.32–34 Interestingly, S-UA levels tended to be highest in both sugarcane workers and construction workers, with 16–17% of these individuals having hyperuricaemia compared with 6% of subsistence farmers. Furthermore, we found that the presence of hyperuricaemia was independently and strongly associated with declining renal function —that is, for each increase of 1 mg/dL S-UA there was an average decline of 10 mL/min in kidney filtration (see table 5). However, since reduced renal function can also result in increased uric acid levels due to impaired excretion, the causal role of uric acid in reduced kidney function cannot be determined.
Recently we hypothesised that renal injury could be occurring in sugarcane workers due to cyclical uricosuria with crystal formation.20 ,21 According to this hypothesis, S-UA might rise as a consequence of subclinical rhabdomyolysis, followed by its crystallisation in the urine. One factor that increases the risk of urate crystal formation is acidic urine, which could result from the release of lactic acid associated with strenuous exercise and the effects of dehydration to reclaim sodium with hydrogen ion excretion. Urine pH was significantly lower in the sugarcane workers compared with the other groups (see table 3) and was strongly associated with low fluid intake on the previous (work) day in the subset of sugarcane workers (see table 4). This might reflect the effects of greater volume depletion (with aldosterone stimulation), lactic acid generation during the previous day, or other mechanisms.
Hydration and fructose
We had expected that low water intake or high sugary fluid intake would be associated with reduced renal function, based on studies in animals.19 ,35 However, workers with eGFR <80 mL/min/1.73 m2 drank more water and consumed fewer sugar-based drinks during the workday than subjects with normal kidney function (4.5 vs 2.2 L water, p=0.08; 0.6 vs 1.25 L sugary beverages, p=0.001) (see online supplementary table S1). This was particularly so among the sugarcane cutters with reduced kidney function who drank about 4 L more water and 1 L less sugary beverages. Excessive thirst from decreased concentration capacity of impaired kidneys may partially explain these counterintuitive findings, as well as the very high water requirements during the heavy labour of sugarcane cutting.12 ,13 Although low fluid intake was clearly associated with concentrated urine among sugarcane cutters (USG ≥1.030: OR 3.5, p=0.06) (see table 4), cutters in the quartile with the highest fluid intake did not have a decreased risk of concentrated urine (OR 1.3, p=0.70) while high fluid intake among non-sugarcane workers appeared to be preventive (OR 0.10, p=0.06). Salvadorian cane cutters who consumed amounts of fluid comparable to the Nicaraguan cutters were found to have insufficient fluid intake under their work conditions.11
Sugary beverages that contain fructose are known to increase the risk of albuminuria36 and can induce renal injury in laboratory animals.35 However, fructose is also a component of sports drinks and fluid resuscitation packets containing glucose and electrolytes that might be beneficial to the volume and water depleted, such as by providing glucose that may prevent or treat any associated hypoglycaemia or by helping to maintain blood pressure due to the fructose component.37 ,38 In our study, the intake of electrolyte solutions tended to be associated (p=0.09) with improved kidney function in multivariate analyses (see table 5). One study in Nicaragua found that, for each 100 mL electrolyte hydration packet consumed during the workday, the eGFR of cane cutters increased by 7 mL/min/1.73 m2 over the course of one harvest season.17 These issues need to be assessed with prospective studies that examine overall fluid balance by measuring fluid intake as well as losses during work, such as pre- and post-shift weight and serum and urine osmolarity.
Other risk factors for kidney disease
There was no association with NSAIDs or alcohol intake. A history of high tobacco consumption was more frequent among subjects with reduced kidney function (p=0.02) but lost significance in multivariate analyses. A history of pesticide exposure was more common among farmers, although exposure to herbicides was more common among sugarcane cutters, especially glyphosate and 2,4-D, both of special interest. However, analyses failed to identify pesticide exposures as an independent risk factor for reduced kidney function (see online supplementary table S1).
Study limitations
The main limitation of our study is its cross-sectional design. The kidney function parameters are based on single determinations in blood and urine without a chronicity criterion (presence during at least 3 months) for a proper clinical diagnosis of CKD.39 Recently, attention has been drawn to the fact that single biomarker determinations and consequent categorisations into CKD stages based on a cut-off value, without consideration of age- and sex-specific criteria for GFR, are inadequate as the basis for population-based CKD prevalences because these practices can lead to overdiagnosis among the elderly and underdiagnosis in younger age groups, with large unexplained differences between nations.40 ,41 However, the main purpose of our study is not a clinical diagnosis but to distinguish differences in kidney function parameters between three occupational groups of the same sex and same young age distribution, and comparisons therefore remain valid on the group level. In addition, in the same region, at the time of this study, we also followed a small group of heat-exposed sugarcane cutters and a group of control workers unexposed to heat over the harvest season. The cutters showed an important decline in kidney function,42 which provides support for the cross-sectional findings, although no cohort data exist for construction workers or farmers.
Another limitation is that our heat exposure and hydration data were self-reported, but these data were collected through carefully designed questionnaires. Workers were asked to fast and did not consume any food before providing blood and spot urine samples between 05:30 and 06:00 hours (see Methods), but they did ingest water or other fluids during the evening, night and early morning. Nonetheless, we observed a lower U-pH and more frequent high BUN/SCr ratio among cane cutters and, to a lesser extent, among construction workers compared with subsistence farmers, which is an indication of incomplete recovery of adequate hydration status after the previous work day among the more heat stress-exposed workers.
Our sample size was based on a pre-study power calculation of 80% to detect CKD among 100 sugarcane cutters and100 non-cutters at α 0.05. Post hoc, we achieved a power of 0.68 for an increased risk of reduced eGFR among cutters versus non-cutters, but the post hoc power of the comparison between cutters and farmers was 80%. Therefore, our results seem sufficiently reliable, also considering the significant trends for indicators of heat stress, dehydration and kidney dysfunction in support of our main hypothesis of cane cutting>construction>farming. Finally, we did not have resources for examining biomarkers of early damage such as neutrophil gelatinase associated lipocalin (NGAL) and N-acetyl-β-D-glucosaminidase (NAG), which are important to include in future studies.
Conclusions
Compared with construction workers and, in particular, subsistence farmers from the same MeN epidemic region of Nicaragua, sugarcane cutters have higher heat stress, more dehydration and worse renal function despite the fact that other health indicators of the cutters were significantly better. Our study supports the need for improved work practices and even more hydration with adequate access to water for sugarcane cutters, as well as for workers in other hot occupations such as construction. The associations between intake of water and sugary drinks and kidney function as well as the role of hyperuricaemia need to be assessed in carefully designed follow-up studies.
References
Footnotes
Contributors Concept and design: AA, CW, MG, RJJ, JG, RC-R. Data collection and biological analyses: AA, MG, IW, CR-J, CJR. Data analysis: CW. Data interpretation: All authors. Manuscript preparation: CW, RJJ. Critical revision and approval of manuscript: All authors.
Funding Danone Research, Palaiseau, France. The funder did not participate in study design, data collection or reporting of results.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent Obtained.
Ethics approval Ethical Review Board of the National Autonomous University of Nicaragua, León, Nicaragua.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement No additional data are available.
Linked Articles
- Correction