Objectives The role of infection in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) has not been determined. We aimed to document the infectious burden and some aspects of antibacterial immunity in a large and prospective cohort study of RA patients in the early and late stages of the disease and in their relatives predisposed to RA.
Setting Clinical and laboratory examination of all individuals enrolled in the study was performed in the Republican Clinical Hospital, Kazan, Russia.
Participants 376 patients with RA, 251 healthy first-degree relatives and 227 healthy controls without a family history of autoimmune disease (all females) were examined twice annually over more than 10 years.
Primary and secondary outcome measures The following parameters were investigated: type, duration and frequency of infections, bacterial colonisation and serum levels of IgG to bacteria, serum levels of total Ig, plasma cytokine levels, granulocyte reactive oxygen species production, lysozyme activity and phagocytosis.
Results There were no significant differences in infection rate between healthy controls (median 14 days/year) and RA patients (13). However, infection rates were higher (p<0.001) in healthy relatives (53) and early stage patients (62), which groups also showed heavy bacterial skin colonisation. In contrast, late stage patients had fewer infection days (12; p<0.001) than healthy controls, although bacterial colonisation was still heavy. Phagocyte function and antibacterial antibody generation, together with compensatory cytokine production, were observed to be subnormal in the healthy relatives as well as in RA patients.
Conclusions We observed a marked increase in overall infections at the time of RA onset, and signs of a defective antibacterial defence mechanism, contrasting with fewer infections in the late RA stage. It can be speculated that frequent early infections initiate a compensatory immune hyper-reactivity which reduces the infection load while stimulating the development of RA in predisposed individuals.
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study
Infection rate and bacterial colonisation were increased in relatives and early rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
In late RA there were fewer infection days and heavy bacterial colonisation.
There were subnormal innate immune functions and high cytokine levels in the relative and RA groups.
Frequent infections initiate proinflammatory cytokine hyper-production.
Compensatory innate immune reaction reduces infections but provokes RA.
It has long been hypothesised that infections play a role in the development of rheumatoid arthritis (RA).1–7 However, it remains to be elucidated whether infection is a cause or a consequence (or neither) of the numerous immune aberrations displayed by RA patients. Do infections play a pathogenic role by evoking immune reactions, for example resulting from molecular mimicry with a specific microbe or from repeated exposures to a multitude of foreign agents triggering a wear and tear type of immune defence?8
Intrigued by our observations that the leukocytes of RA patients show deficient phagocytosis,9 we decided to systematically document infections and some anti-bacterial immune parameters in a prospective large cohort study. Because the early stage of RA is considered to provide a window of opportunity to significantly impede disease progression,10 ,11 first-degree healthy relatives (HR) were included, some of whom developed RA during the study. If exposure to microbes was found to be a significant causative factor, this would have profound implications for our understanding of the pathophysiology of this disease, and how to best design early phase aggressive treatment.
Materials and methods
Most patients in the Tatarstan province in the European part of Russia (population 3.8 million) who have a clinical history suggesting RA are referred to our specialist hospital. More than 90% of all women diagnosed with RA at our clinic from 2002 to 2011 were included in the present study. Mean follow-up was 5.4 years. RA was diagnosed by consensus by three rheumatologists using the American Rheumatology Association criteria of 1987, and the EULAR 2010 criteria; for those patients with a diagnosis already when referred to our centre, the time of diagnosis was estimated based on physician records and patient report. Time zero during disease progression was defined as the time when the diagnostic criteria were met. A total of 257 women were studied while in early RA (eRA), defined as <6 months of RA duration and 285 women while in late stage RA (laRA), defined as >3 years of RA duration (table 1). Some subjects were studied as both HR, eRA and laRA; during the study, 26 HR subjects changed diagnostic group status to eRA, and 185 changed from eRA to laRA, while no healthy control (HC) developed RA. A total of 231 patients were enrolled as eRA and 89 after they had reached laRA status. All patients were asked to invite their first-degree female relatives to participate, and more than half of these relatives accepted, giving a total of 251 HR; they showed no symptoms or MRI signs of arthritis, no erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) or C-reactive protein (CRP) elevation (except during infection), and no reactivity of rheumatoid factor or antibody to citrullinated peptides. The HC group comprised 227 women with no chronic disease and no RA among close relatives; these women were identified by a rheumatologist as having no signs of arthritis and negative results in the same laboratory tests as were performed for the HR. Exclusion criteria were some risk factors for infection.7 Some 3.6% were excluded due to strong immunosuppressive therapy, and another 1.3% because of smoking or habitual alcoholism (by tradition it is uncommon in this geographical area for a woman to smoke). In addition, 15–20% of the patients were excluded from participation because of a concomitant chronic disease (mainly diabetes mellitus). All patients were receiving disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs); 35 patients were on infliximab, one on abatacept, two on tocilizumab, and seven on rituximab, and 7% were on oral prednisolone averaging 10 mg daily.
Anamnestic information on infections was collected by a specialist in rheumatology trained in Russia at semi-annual in-hospital 2-day visits for most of the HR and the RA patients; for the HC group infection information was from the year preceding enrolment. The study participants were asked about symptoms suggesting infections experienced during the preceding half or whole year. Information from out-clinic documents was sought whenever a general practitioner had been visited. Only those episodes judged by the rheumatologist to truly indicate an infection were scored (there were no formal criteria). In the case of exacerbation of a chronic infection, the diagnosis was established by a specialist in the corresponding medical area. Infections over a 1-year period (the year immediately before assignment as HC, HR or eRA, and the last year as laRA) for each study subject are shown in figure 1. Infection data were collected from all study subjects, but the described tests were performed only for a limited time during the study, with no selection bias other than study time, and thus on only some of the subjects; for bacterial cultures n=16–139, anti-bacterial IgG n=16–31, lysozyme and phagocytosis n=31–46, reactive oxygen species (ROS) production n=11–19, cytokines n=14–58, total Ig levels n=56–224, and IgE n=16–40. Written informed consent was obtained from all subjects. The study was approved by the ethics committee of the Kazan State Medical Academy, Kazan, Russia (Permit no. 1/2002).
Bacterial cultures were established from skin (lower volar arm) cotton swabs and from urine and faeces samples, in the Bacteriology Laboratory, Republic Hospital Number 3, Kazan, following routine procedures established by Russian federal authorities. For quantitation, the skin swab material or 1 g faeces was suspended in 1 or 10 mL, respectively, phosphate-buffered neutral pH saline; then 10 μL of this suspension or of urine was streaked onto a Petri dish. Samples were obtained on several occasions, but only one result for each sample type (with the most complete sample set and from the most recent date) per individual is presented in this manuscript. Bacterial samples and blood for immunological investigation were taken only in the absence of clinical signs of infection.
Phagocytosis of 14C-labelled Staphylococcus aureus and lysozyme activity were measured as described earlier.12 ROS were analysed by luminol-dependent chemiluminescence real time registration using a chemiluminometer designed by Dr Santalov, Pushchino, Russia, with opsonised zymosan (Sigma, USA; final concentration 0.25 mg/mL) as stimulant. Serum IgG to S. aureus,13 Staphylococcus epidermidis and Escherichia coli was determined with ELISA (Navina, Russia). Plasma levels of tumour necrosis factor α (TNF-α), interleukin-1β (IL-1β) and interleukin-6 (IL-6) were measured by ELISA (Vector-Best Test Systems, Russia), and interferon γ (IFN-γ) by ELISA (BioLegend, USA). Serum IgG, IgM and IgA total levels were studied using a turbidometric method (Human Diagnostics, Germany), and IgE by ELISA (R&D, USA).
The sign criterion, Student t test for independent samples, the Mann–Whitney test, Wilcoxon test, χ2 criterion and regression analysis were used. The Pearson criterion was used if case normal distribution was evident. The Spearman rank order correlation test and multiple regression analysis were used for analysis of association between infections and age.
Number of days with an infection experienced during a 1-year period
The infection results for the 1-year period preceding either the first examination (HC and HR), arthritis onset (eRA) or the last examination (laRA) are presented in figure 1A. There was no significant difference in the median number of infection days between HC (14) and all RA patients together (13). Higher figures were noted for HR (53, p<0.001) and eRA (62, p<0.001). The laRA patients had fewer infection days (12, p<0.01) than HC (14).
Infection results recorded at different time points for those HR subjects (n=26) who developed RA during the study, and for a subset of RA patients (n=185) followed for a relatively long period starting at the time of diagnosis, are presented in figure 1B. Among this HR subgroup, infection duration was lower at the first examination (4 years before being diagnosed with RA) (60 days, left in figure 1B) as compared with the year preceding diagnosis (70, middle in figure 1B; p<0.001). At the last follow-up of 11 of these 26 individuals, at 2.8 years after diagnosis, there was a decrease to 28 days (right in figure 1B; p<0.01, as compared with the two earlier time points). Among the 185 RA patients followed from time of diagnosis, a decrease from 56 to 5 days was noted at 8.4 years after diagnosis (p<0.01) (figure 1B). There was no significant correlation between the age of the studied subjects and infection duration (results not shown).
We also scored infection types (table 2). There was no infection in 12.4% of HC, 4.0% of HR (p<0.05), 2.0% of eRA (p<0.01) or 28.3% of laRA (p<0.01). The most frequent type of infection in all groups was influenza-like symptoms, with no differences between HC, HR and eRA; however the laRA group showed lower values. Symptoms typical for herpes simplex were more frequent, and each episode was longer, for HR and eRA; for laRA the result was similar to HC, but laRA had fewer episodes than eRA. Higher percentages of HR and eRA than HC had upper respiratory and urinary tract infections; again, laRA displayed lower rates. For many of the types of infection with a probable bacterial origin, HR and eRA showed increase rates, while laRA had a tendency to lower rates (as compared with HR, eRA as well as HC). This can be exemplified by significant differences for acute sinusitis episodes (forming part of the upper respiratory tract data), with this type of infection affecting 2.7% of all HC, 4.8% of HR, 6.0% of eRA and 0.8% of laRA.
Samples for bacterial culture were taken from faeces, urine and skin at a time when the subjects showed no signs of infection (figure 2A). A high bacterial count was defined arbitrarily as >105 colony-forming units (CFU) per mL of a suspended skin swab, as >105 CFU per mL urine and as >4×108 CFU per g of suspended faeces. For all three bacterial species and three sample types, high CFU values were more frequent among HR, eRA and laRA as compared with HC. As an example, a high count of S. aureus was found in 1 of 23 (4%) HC skin samples, in 13 of 38 (34%) HR samples, in 16 of 45 (36%) eRA samples and in 17 of 75 (23%) laRA samples (p<0.001 for HR and eRA, and p<0.01 for laRA, as compared with HC). For laRA, the E. coli and S. aureus CFU tended to be lower than for HR and eRA, whereas CFU for the less pathogenic commensal S. epidermidis tended to be higher.
Serum IgG to E. coli, S. aureus and S. epidermidis, and total Ig levels
There was no significant difference between the groups in serum levels of IgG to E. coli, S. aureus or S. epidermidis (results not shown). However, if the subjects were separated into those with and without a high CFU result (as shown in figure 2A), a pattern could be discerned (figure 2B). Among the HC, the anti-E. coli and anti-S. aureus IgG levels were higher in subjects with more colonisation, whereas among HR and eRA the opposite was noted, and laRA showed an intermediate result with no apparent difference between the two CFU groups. This pattern was evident also for anti-S. epidermidis among HC, HR and eRA, but the laRA patients showed the same result as the HC, that is, a higher IgG level in those with heavy bacterial colonisation. There was no difference in serum levels of total IgG, IgM or IgA between the subject groups (n=56–224) (figure 3A). In a smaller subject subset (n=16–40), the serum total IgE level was approximately twofold elevated in HR (p<0.01) and laRA (p<0.05), but with no deviation in eRA as compared with HC (figure 3B).
Plasma cytokine levels
In plasma obtained from subjects without signs of infection, levels of TNF-α, IL-6 and IFN-γ (not significant only with IFN-γ in eRA) were increased in HR, eRA and laRA as compared with HC (figure 4). A high level of IL-1β was detected in HR and less so in laRA. For TNF-α and IL-6, with monocytes considered to be a rich source, there was a tendency for eRA to show a lower concentration than HR and laRA. For IFN-γ, originating mainly from T cells, there was a similar pattern.
Granulocytes from HR, eRA and laRA displayed a normal level of spontaneous (figure 5A) and stimulated (figure 5B) generation of ROS; however, after stimulation with opsonised zymosan the time needed to reach peak ROS production was significantly prolonged in HR, eRA and laRA (figure 5C). The antibacterial activity of lysozyme secreted by granulocytes, as well as granulocyte phagocytosis of S. aureus, were markedly reduced in both laRA and HR (figure 5D–E); eRA samples were not available for analysis for these two immune parameters.
The quantity of overall infections was higher in the HR as compared with the HC group. It was further elevated in eRA, but lower in late laRA stage, even significantly lower than in the HC. The summary effect for the entire RA group was a slightly elevated (not significantly) infection quantity. Accordingly, there was an increase in infections in HR as they developed RA (n=26), and a decrease among RA patients after they transitioned from eRA to laRA (n=135). This strong correlation between infections and disease duration may have contributed to the previously published conflicting data on infection quantity in RA; for example, the relatively few hospitalised infections reported for methotrexate-treated patients may reflect a long disease duration.14
Because this study was designed to examine the possible role of exposure to microbial antigens in a broad sense, we examined some aspects of the commensal bacterial flora, and the scoring of infections was not limited to objectively verifiable and severe types, such as septic arthritis. We were encouraged by previous observations that self-reporting by patients can serve as a valuable indicator of common infections.15 ,16 At the same time we are aware of the impact which confounding factors can have on the scoring of most types of infections. For example, non-microbial inflammation may mimic infection. Drug usage may also have a confounding effect; consumption of antibiotics with activities other than anti-bacterial might have an impact on infection score.17 Furthermore, the more anti-inflammatory medication administered, the less severe the symptoms indicating infection. In fact, we did observe more infections among the eRA group (in whom infections during the 1-year period preceding diagnosis were scored) who were on less drug therapy compared to the laRA patients, who had far fewer infections and all of whom were prescribed DMARD. Nevertheless, we find it highly unlikely that our finding of fewer infections in late stage patients is due to DMARD usage. First, the observed extent of infection reduction (from 62 days in eRA to 12 days in laRA, figure 1A) is too large to be due to drug masking of signs of infection; second, the highly significantly increased infection load seen at time of diagnosis in the HR subjects developing RA (figure 1B) cannot be attributed to a decrease in DMARD intake. In conclusion, our data suggest true differences in microbial flora and infection quantity.
The high frequency of infections was accompanied by a high level of bacterial colonisation in both HR and eRA. This situation was different in laRA, where a marked reduction in infections was coupled with persistent strong colonisation. Some anti-bacterial defences were observed to function at a clearly subnormal level in both the early and late stages of RA, and also in the HR. These were neutrophil lysozyme activity, which was in accordance with a report of a markedly reduced (6.6-fold) expression level of the lysozyme gene in RA patient blood mononuclear cells,18 and phagocytosis of S. aureus by granulocytes. Another major anti-bacterial defence mechanism is production of ROS by granulocytes; we noted signs of reduced capacity in HR and RA patients, in line with findings that ROS protects against RA in the Ncf1DA rat model,19 and low antioxidant activity in RA patients.20
We acknowledge that it remains to be elucidated whether infections, and exposure to more or less immunogenic colonising bacteria, act as ‘driver’ or ‘passenger’ phenomena during RA development. Hypothetically, at least two scenarios can be postulated: (1) frequent infectious episodes and RA could be two causally independent consequences of an immune system disturbance; and (2) recurrent infections contribute to RA development. Since the correlation between RA activity and infection quantity in eRA is opposite to that in laRA, it seems that the second scenario is the most likely.
Our collected findings suggest the following model for the pathogenesis of RA. Some anti-bacterial defence mechanisms, operating at a subnormal level during all stages of RA, result in an RA-predisposing exposure to microbial antigens in the shape of commensals and infections. A set of compensatory immune reactions follow. An increase in other defence mechanisms eventually succeeds in curbing the high level of infections, while exerting less influence on colonisation. The model is supported by evidence indicating that monocytes and macrophages,21 as well as other cytokine-producing cell types,22 are key players in RA, and by more recent reports of non-specific and sustained immunostimulation during RA development.13 ,24 ,25 The composition of the commensal bacterial flora, and gut microbiota manipulation, is known to influence inflammatory diseases and not least RA.23–29 Data from genome-wide association studies provide evidence that numerous factors beyond those analysed by us influence the development and progression of RA.30 ,31 Notably, a high infection quantity was revealed by us in the great majority of, but not all, HR and eRA patients. So, microbial exposure might be a very important but not unique provoking factor.
In conclusion, our observations may prompt further studies on the clinical value of controlling infections and of manipulation of our commensal microbiota.
Contributors MIA, APT and AB: conceived and designed the study; MIA: conducted clinical examinations and selected the study subjects; MIA, AGG, RRM and YVF: performed the experiments; all authors: analysed the data; MIA and AB: wrote the paper.
Funding This study was supported by grants from the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (00-04-48224 and 04-09-97053), the Swedish Institute (01474/2007) and the Alfred Osterlund Foundation.
Competing interests None.
Patient consent Obtained.
Ethics approval All aspects of the study were approved by the ethics committee of Kazan State Medical University.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement No additional data are available.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.