Objective To describe the association between intraoperative tissue oxygenation and postoperative troponin elevation in patients undergoing major spine surgery. We hypothesised that a decrease in intraoperative skeletal muscle tissue oxygenation (SmO2) was associated with the peak postoperative cardiac troponin value.
Design This is a prospective cohort study.
Setting Single-centre, University of California San Francisco Medical Center.
Participants Seventy adult patients undergoing major elective spine surgery.
Primary and secondary outcome measures High-sensitivity troponin T (hsTnT) was measured in plasma preoperatively and on the first and second day after surgery to assess the primary outcome of peak postoperative hsTnT. Secondary outcomes included MINS and intensive care unit (ICU) admission within 30 days. Skeletal cerebral tissue oxygenation and SmO2 was measured continuously with near-infrared spectroscopy during surgery. The primary exposure variable was time-weighted area under the curve (TW AUC) for SmO2.
Results Mean age was 65 (33–85) years and 59% were female. No significant association was found between TW AUC for SmO2 and peak hsTnT (Spearman’s correlation, rs=0.17, p=0.16). A total of 28 (40%) patients had MINS. ICU admission occurred in 14 (40%) in lower vs 25 (71%) in upper half of patients based on TW AUC for SmO2, p=0.008.
Conclusions Decrease in SmO2 was not a statistically significant predictor for peak troponin value following major spine surgery but is a potential predictor for other postoperative complications.
Trial registration number NCT03518372.
- myocardial infarction
- anaesthesia in orthopaedics
Data availability statement
Data are available on reasonable request.
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study
Prospective observational study including 70 patients undergoing major spine surgery.
Contributing knowledge to potential predictors for myocardial injury and clinical implications of tissue oxygenation monitoring.
Applying skeletal muscle tissue oxygenation as primary predictor, decreasing risk of cerebral autoregulation modification of outcomes.
There is no clinical consensus of absolute threshold for tissue hypoxaemia, thus, population median for skeletal muscle tissue oxygenation was used as cut-off in this study.
Major non-cardiac surgery is associated with significant risks of postoperative complications which are sometimes asymptomatic such as covert stroke1 and myocardial infarction and injury.2 Cardiovascular events are the leading cause of morbidity and mortality3 with myocardial injury after non-cardiac surgery (MINS) being a major contributor to further postoperative complications.4–7 MINS is frequently caused by ischaemia and can be diagnosed from elevated postoperative high-sensitivity cardiac troponin, in the absence of non-ischaemic factors for troponin elevation.8 The 30-day mortality is increased up to eightfold in patients with covert stroke compared with matched controls9 and stroke occurs in 9% of patients with MINS, making it a substantial public health problem.10 Peak postoperative cardiac troponin has a linear association with 30-day mortality.7 Each year, 8 million surgical patients worldwide suffer from MINS but there is sparse knowledge about triggering causes and contributing factors to the magnitude of peak postoperative cardiac troponin.5 11
Intraoperative tissue oxygen desaturation is common in patients undergoing major spine surgery12 probably because of the substantial blood loss and haemodynamic changes that occur in this type of operation. Tissue oxygenation (StO2) can be measured non-invasively with near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS). Previous studies found that a decrease in intraoperative StO2 was associated with wound infection, stroke and renal failure,13 and that decrease in skeletal muscle tissue oxygenation (SmO2) was a stronger predictor for these complications than cerebral tissue oxygenation (ScO2) in spine surgery.12 However, current knowledge of how StO2 affects other important clinical outcomes, including MINS, is lacking. In this prospective cohort study, we hypothesised that a decrease in SmO2 was associated with higher peak postoperative high-sensitivity troponin T (hsTnT). The primary exposure variable was time-weighted area under the curve (TW AUC) for SmO2 and the primary outcome was peak postoperative hsTnT. This study was conducted with the aim of examining the association between intraoperative StO2 and postoperative troponin elevation in patients undergoing major spine surgery.
This prospective cohort study was conducted at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF). This manuscript adheres to the applicable Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology guidelines.
The patients were adults (≥18 years) undergoing elective spine surgery at UCSF from January to May 2018. The surgeries selected were scheduled to last for more than 2 hours and included instrumentation. Exclusion criteria were: American Society of Anesthesiologists Physical Status Classification System score >IV, surgery for tumour or infection, emergent or urgent surgery.
Patient characteristics, comorbidities, preoperative physical status and postoperative complications were extracted from the electronical medical record (KFB). Data were collected at two time points: prior to surgery and 30 days after surgery. A follow-up phone call to the patient was made 30 days after surgery to verify postoperative outcomes. Baseline values were defined as the preincision value. Intraoperative values were defined as data from incision to end of procedure when last suture was placed. Study data were managed using the REDCap (Research Electronic Data Capture) tools hosted at UCSF.
StO2 was monitored using a tissue oximeter based on NIRS (FORE-SIGHT Elite, CASMED, Branford, Connecticut, USA). Cerebral and leg skeletal muscle oxygenation was monitored via two cables connected to adhesive probes provided by the manufacturer. Probes were placed after tracheal intubation and a baseline was measured from placing of probe to incision. One probe was placed on the left side on the upper forehead to monitor one-sided frontal cortex ScO2. The second probe was placed on the left tibialis anterior muscle, four fingers below the tibial tuberosity and two fingers lateral to the anterior edge of the tibial shaft, to monitor the SmO2 of the lower leg muscle. The oximeter generated a data point every 2 seconds. The anaesthesia team was blinded to the oximeter. Data from the oximeter were used for StO2 indices derivation. Indices were maximum, minimum, median and TW AUC for SmO2 and ScO2, respectively. The primary exposure variable was TW AUC for SmO2. TW AUC was calculated for each participant as the area below the intraoperative median for the study population and divided by length of surgery. This was chosen because there is no international consensus on a universal baseline level or normal range for StO2.
A total of three blood samples for hsTnT were drawn. First sample was drawn by the anaesthesiologist in the operating room after placement of the arterial line prior to surgery. Second and third sample were drawn by a phlebotomist or nurse the first and second day after surgery, respectively. After the blood was drawn, the sample was centrifuged immediately and the plasma was divided into two cryo collecting tubes and placed in a −80°C freezer for storage. All plasma samples were sent to a specialised laboratory at Hennepin Medical Center (Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA) to be analysed for the Roche fifth generation, Elecsys hsTnT assay after the study was completed. The data collector was blinded to the results of hsTnT and laboratory personnel analysing the blood samples were blinded to patient data. Medical records and perioperative information (eg, ECG, laboratory values) were reviewed for patients with troponin elevation, to exclude a non-ischaemic aetiology.8
The primary outcome was defined as postoperative peak high-sensitivity cardiac troponin T (hsTnT). A secondary related outcome was MINS, initially defined as hsTnT ≥14 ng/L14 with factors for non-ischaemic aetiology excluded (eg, sepsis, kidney failure, heart failure). This MINS definition was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov, but during the course of the study and prior to hsTnT analysis of the blood samples, new data were published, where MINS was defined as an elevated postoperative hsTnT (ie, 20 to <65 ng/L with an absolute change ≥5 ng/L or a single hsTnT ≥65 ng/L) with factors for non-ischaemic aetiology excluded (eg, sepsis, kidney failure, heart failure).8 We, therefore, updated the protocol to the latter and current MINS definition. Other secondary outcomes were myocardial infarction, non-fatal cardiac arrest, new-onset arrhythmia (defined as new atrial fibrillation or other treatment requiring arrhythmia), heart failure, transient cerebral ischaemia, symptomatic stroke, sepsis, surgical site infection, pulmonary complications (including pulmonary infection, pneumothorax, atelectasis, pulmonary embolus and other pulmonary complication), creatinine elevation (>1.3 mg/dL for men and >1.1 mg/dL for women), intensive care unit (ICU) admission, length of hospital stay and mortality, all within 30 days after surgery. In addition, we analysed a composite outcome that consisted of all above mentioned postoperative complications.
Sample size calculations were based on clinical data and previous studies investigating StO2 as an outcome for postoperative complications.12 13 These studies evaluated all types of complications as primary outcome. Mean (SD) TW AUC for SmO2 was 1.59%×min×h-1 (2.35).12 We estimated a minimal clinically relevant difference to be a 36% increase in TW AUC for SmO2 for participants with high peak hsTnT (with a cut-off of 14 ng/L based on the 99th percentile of a healthy population)15 compared with participants with low peak hsTnT. Using a power of 80% and a significance level of 0.05, a sample size of 68 participants for this study was needed. We anticipated a low number of drop-outs, as the study design was observational, resulting in a total sample size of 70 participants.
Results are presented as mean±SD and median (IQR) when appropriate. Revised Cardiac Risk Index (RCRI) and corresponding risk of cardiac complications at 30 days after surgery were computed according to current criteria.16 Postoperative outcomes were compared stratifying the study population in two groups by median TW AUC for SmO2. Comparison between groups were based on χ2 tests for categorical variables, analysis of variance and Wilcoxon rank-sum test.
The primary analysis of the association between TW AUC for SmO2 and peak hsTnT was tested by Spearman correlation analysis. Univariable and multivariable logistic regression models were used in secondary analyses to examine the associations of baseline characteristics, intraoperative variables and StO2 indices with higher peak hsTnT which was dichotomised in high/low categories using median peak hsTnT in the study population as cut-off. Univariable and multivariable logistic regression was used to test the association between StO2 indices and MINS and the adjusted prediction for TW AUC for SmO2 and MINS was calculated. Variables for adjustment in the multivariable analyses were age, sex, body mass index, smoking, diabetes, hypertension, previous stroke, chronic lung disease, arrhythmia, valvular disease, chronic kidney disease, length of surgery, osteotomy performed, estimated blood loss, mean arterial blood pressure and mean heart rate.
Stata Statistical Software (release V.15; StataCorp) was used for all analyses.
Patient and public involvement
Patients or the public were not involved in the design, conduct, reporting or dissemination plans of this study.
A total of 70 patients undergoing spine surgery was included in this prospective cohort study. Mean age was 65 (33; 85) years and 41 (59%) participants were female. Mean (95% CI) risk of cardiac complications at 30 days after surgery, calculated according to RCRI was 7.7 (7.0 to 8.3) %. The median percentage estimated blood loss of estimated blood volume was 17 (IQR 8–31) %. A summary of patient characteristics, medical history, surgical information and values for StO2 are found in table 1.
Incidence of MINS and major outcomes
The median peak hsTnT was 19 (IQR 10–30) ng/L and based on a hsTnT of 20 to <65 ng/L with an absolute change ≥5 ng/L or a single hsTnT ≥65 ng/L, 28 (40%) participants had MINS (table 2). The number of participants with any postoperative complications were 41 (59%) and when MINS was included as a complication, 52 (74%) of participants had one or more postoperative complications (table 2). Estimated blood loss and length of surgery was associated with MINS (OR (95% CI): 1.001 (1.000 to 1.002), p=0.002 and 1.007 (1.002 to 1.011), p=0.004, respectively).
Relationships of StO2 to MINS and other outcomes
In the univariable correlation analysis of TW AUC for SmO2 and peak hsTnT, no significant association was found (rs=0.17, p=0.16, figure 1). There was a statistically significant association between higher TW AUC for SmO2 and the composite outcome of postoperative complications (participants in lower half: 21 (60%) vs participants in upper half: 31 (89%), p=0.006, table 2) but when logistic regression was performed, this association was not significant. Furthermore, a statistically significant association between higher TW AUC for SmO2 and ICU admission was found (participants in lower half: 14 (40%) vs participants in upper half: 25 (71%), p=0.008, table 2). There were no other statistically significant differences in outcomes between the two groups based on median TW AUC for SmO2. When testing the StO2 indices as predictors for higher peak hsTnT by logistic regression, the univariable analysis found that for every 1% increase in median and maximum SmO2, the odds of having high peak hsTnT decreased (OR (95% CI): 0.93 (0.87 to 0.996), p=0.039 and 0.92 (0.85 to 0.99), p=0.025, respectively, table 3). After multivariable adjustment for baseline and clinical variables, median and maximum SmO2 were not independent predictors for higher peak hsTnT (table 3). None of the StO2 indices were found to be significant predictors for MINS (table 3). Adjusted predicted probability was calculated based on univariable logistic regression and showed increasing probability for MINS with increasing TW AUC for SmO2 (figure 2) although this was not statistically significant (OR (95% CI): 1.00 (0.99 to 1.01), p=0.74). Although this was not systematically assessed for the purpose of this study, only one participant presented with ischaemic symptoms on the first two postoperative days according to medical records. This patient was not diagnosed with clinical myocardial infarction after examination, although hsTnT was 31 ng/L.
In a prospective cohort study of 70 participants, we investigated intraoperative StO2 as predictor for myocardial injury after spine surgery. We found that SmO2 and ScO2 were not independent predictors for elevated hsTnT or MINS. However, in exploratory analyses, some other indices for SmO2 were associated with higher peak hsTnT, whereas ScO2 indices were not.
StO2 is a result of the oxygen supply and demand of the specific tissue and is determined by multiple physiological factors including oxygen saturation, haemoglobin (Hgb) concentration and cardiac output.17 Measurement of StO2 with NIRS has been investigated in previous studies as predictor for a number of different outcomes. Several studies have examined cerebral oxygenation in patients undergoing cardiac surgery, whereas few studies have investigated SmO2 as predictor for clinical outcomes. In patients undergoing cardiac surgery, ScO2 was found to be associated with stroke, cognitive decline, length of hospital stay and mortality.18 19 One study found that decrease in ScO2 was not a predictor for delirium in elderly patients.20 A recent meta-analysis of 10 trials with a total of 1466 patients, found that NIRS-based algorithms for ScO2 did not reduce mortality or organ injury affecting the heart, brain or kidneys.21 Despite the lack of evident benefit for ScO2-guided clinical algorithms, ScO2 monitoring is routinely used in cardiac surgery.
Cerebral and skeletal muscle tissue have different physiological characteristics. Meng et al12 found that SmO2 was a stronger predictor than ScO2 for composite postoperative outcomes, including myocardial injury, stroke, pulmonary complications and creatinine elevation. Although findings in the current study were statistically insignificant, the exploratory analyses yielded a stronger association between SmO2 and outcomes as compared with ScO2. This aligns with the theory that SmO2 is a leading indicator for global desaturation due to low autoregulation in skeletal muscle tissue compared with the higher level of autoregulation in cerebral tissue.22 Of note, skeletal and myocardial autoregulation may not be the same and it is possible that myocardial autoregulation shows similar patterns to cerebral autoregulation in some physiological instances. The importance of preserved cerebral autoregulation is substantial. Brain tissue is more sensitive to hypoxia than skeletal muscle.17 One study showed that impaired cerebrovascular autoregulation was associated with increased morbidity and mortality within 30 days from surgery in patients undergoing major non-cardiac surgery.23 A study in healthy subjects suggested SmO2 to be an early indicator for impending cardiovascular collapse and showed that SmO2 declined in parallel with stroke volume.24 Perfusion of skeletal muscle tissue follows the same linearity in decline with decreasing cardiac output whereas cerebral tissue perfusion only decreases approximately one-third of cardiac output.25 This study found TW AUC for SmO2 to be almost three times larger than TW AUC for ScO2 (98% vs 33%×min/hour) indicating autoregulation in brain tissue. Of note, spine surgery patients at UCSF almost all receive anaesthetics that include very low amounts of inhalational anaesthetics, probably preserving brain autoregulation of blood flow. Despite these findings, the clinical implications of SmO2 monitoring is still yet to be determined. TW AUC for SmO2 was chosen as a predictor in this study as it maximises sensitivity by including all available data for the specific parameter (magnitude and duration of desaturation as well as covering the entire duration of surgery). Furthermore, it minimises the effect of potential error measurements on the StO2 value but because TW AUC for SmO2 is a calculated value it currently has limitations in regards of clinical utility.
StO2 was not statistically significant associated with MINS in the current study but other indicators of supply-demand mismatch, that is, estimated blood loss and length of surgery, were significantly associated with MINS and peak hsTnT. These are established predictors for MINS26 and contributes to the understanding of the pathophysiology for elevated troponin.27
In general, the majority of MINS are undetected (80%) as patients do not have ischaemic symptoms.4 10 In this study, only one participant presented with ischaemic symptoms. The type of surgery the participants underwent was comprehensive and many participants were treated with strong analgesics postoperatively which could be a contributing factor to the lack of ischaemic symptoms in the participants with MINS. The incidence of MINS among the participants in this study was 40%. In comparison the general incidence of MINS in patients undergoing non-cardiac surgery is 8%4 but this is not restricted to major surgery only and the incidence depends on the cut-off for troponin elevation used. Other groups found similar high incidence of MINS.28
As this was an observational cohort study it was not designed to determine causality between StO2 and postoperative myocardial injury. The study was not powered for all secondary outcomes, as we based the power calculation on a study with the outcome composite postoperative complications that included less severe complications (constipation, oliguria, etc).12
We found a high incidence of MINS in this study but the number of serious outcome events (eg, death, stroke, non-fatal cardiac, myocardial infarction) were sparse in the 30-day follow-up period. The participants underwent spine surgery which was not emergent, conducted as cancer treatment/tumour resection or indicated by any life-threatening condition. Thus, it is possible that participants were in a better physical condition when scheduled for this type of elective surgery than for other major non-cardiac surgical procedures. Changes in blood pressure and heart rate may trigger MINS. Extensive analyses of associations between these parameters an MINS were not possible in this study.
The NIRS method is non-invasive and tracks StO2 continuously. However, limitations in regard to the technology has been presented and includes bias regarding skin pigmentation, gender and assumed mixture of venous and arterial blood.29 With the equipment used in this study it was not possible to obtain data on different Hgb fractions (total Hgb, oxy-Hgb and deoxy-Hgb), which could potentially have qualified the analysis even further. Total blood loss was included in the predefined model to predict MINS but relative changes in Hgb concentrations, including those caused by transfusions, was not accounted for. Interindividual differences in saturation contributes to the difficulty of determining an absolute threshold for tissue hypoxia. In the calculation of the primary predictor of TW AUC for SmO2 we used the population median for intraoperative SmO2 as cut-off. The choice of cut-off should be considered when interpreting results of studies investigating the impact of StO2.
In summary, in this study StO2 was not a statistically significant predictor for peak postoperative hsTnT but is a potential predictor for other postoperative complications. Future studies should focus on determining a threshold for StO2 taking interindividual factors into account and apply NIRS technology with the ability of detecting different Hgb fractions. The frequency of MINS was high (40%) and related to blood loss, suggesting supply-demand mismatch aetiology in spine surgery. StO2 did not have the power to predict myocardial injury but other intraoperative indicators for supply-demand mismatch should be considered as potential predictors for MINS in future studies.
Data availability statement
Data are available on reasonable request.
Patient consent for publication
The study was approved by the University of California San Francisco Institutional Review Board (IRB 14-12996) and both verbal and written consent was obtained from all participants before surgery.
Contributors All authors participated in the initial drafting of the manuscript as well as the revised manuscript. All authors met the ICMJE criteria for authorship. Below is specification of author contributions: KFB: Conception and design, acquisition, analysis and interpretation of data, drafting, critical revision and final approval of the manuscript. CSM: Conception and design, analysis and interpretation of data, critical revision and final approval of the manuscript. PB: Conception and design, analysis and interpretation of data, critical revision and final approval of the manuscript.
Funding This work was supported by a grant from the Lundbeck Foundation Clinical Research Fellowship 2017–2018 for Katrine Feldballe Bernholm. Grant number not applicable. CAS Medical Systems provided the FORE-SIGHT ELITE Tissue Oximeter and probes at no cost.
Competing interests CSM has received institutional direct and indirect research funding from Boehringer Ingelheim, Ferring Pharmaceuticals, Radiometer and Merch, Sharp & Dohme, as well as lecture fees from Radiometer, all outside submitted work. The remaining authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Patient and public involvement Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, or conduct, or reporting, or dissemination plans of this research.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.