Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Protocol
Helminth infections, atopy, asthma and allergic diseases: protocol for a systematic review of observational studies worldwide
  1. Margarete Arrais1,2,
  2. Tiago Maricoto3,4,
  3. Philip Cooper5,6,
  4. Jorge M R Gama7,
  5. Bright I Nwaru8,
  6. Miguel Brito2,9,
  7. Luís Taborda-Barata10,11
  1. 1Department of Pulmonology, Military Hospital Luanda, Luanda, Angola
  2. 2CISA - Health Sciences Research Center of Angola, Caxito, Bengo, Angola
  3. 3ACeS Baixo Vouga, Aveiro-Aradas Family Health Unit, Aveiro, Portugal
  4. 4Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal
  5. 5Institute of Infection and Immunity, St George’s University of London, London, UK
  6. 6School of Medicine, International Univeristy of Ecuador, Quito, Ecuador
  7. 7Centre of Mathematics and Applications, Faculty of Sciences, University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal
  8. 8Krefting Research Centre, Institute of Medicine, Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden
  9. 9Health and Technology Research Center (H&TRC), Lisbon Higher School of Health Technology, Polytechnic Institute of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal
  10. 10Department of Allergy & Clinical Immunology, Cova da Beira University Hospital Centre, Covilhã, Portugal
  11. 11CICS - Health Sciences Research Centre, University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal
  1. Correspondence to Professor Luís Taborda-Barata; tabordabarata{at}fcsaude.ubi.pt

Abstract

Introduction Childhood infections, particularly those caused by helminths are considered to be important environmental exposures influencing the development of allergic diseases. However, epidemiological studies focusing on the relationship between helminth infections and risk of allergic diseases, performed worldwide, show inconsistent findings. Previous systematic reviews of observational studies published 10 or more years ago showed conflicting findings for effects of helminths on allergic diseases. Over the past 10 years there has been growing literature addressing this research area and these need to be considered in order to appreciate the most contemporary evidence. The objective of the current systematic review will be to provide an up-to-date synthesis of findings of observational studies investigating the influence of helminth infections on atopy, and allergic diseases.

Methods and analysis This systematic review protocol was registered at PROSPERO. We will search Cochrane Library, MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, AMED, ISI Web of Science, WHO Global Health Library, Scielo, IndMed, PakMediNet, KoreaMed, Ichushi for published studies from 1970 to January 2020. Bibliographies of all eligible studies will be reviewed to identify additional studies. Unpublished and ongoing research will also be searched in key databases. There will be no language or geographical restrictions regarding publications. Critical Appraisal Skills Programme quality assessment tool will be used to appraise methodological quality of included studies. A descriptive summary with data tables will be constructed, and if adequate, meta-analysis using random-effects will be performed. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses checklist will be followed for reporting of the systematic review.

Ethics and dissemination Since this systematic review will be only based on published and retrievable literature, no ethics approval will be sought. The multidisciplinary team performing this systematic review will participate in relevant dissemination activities. Findings will be presented at scientific meetings and publish the systematic review in international, peer-reviewed, open-access journals.

PROSPERO registration number CRD42020167249.

  • eczema
  • epidemiology
  • parasitology
  • allergy
  • asthma
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Strengths and limitations of this study

  • This is the first systematic review to address the relationship between a wide variety of helminth infections and atopy and the most frequent allergic diseases in children (ie, asthma, rhinitis and eczema).

  • A thorough search strategy using leading databases in medicine and public health will ensure that the relevant papers on the topic will be identified.

  • This protocol followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Protocols guidelines.

  • With no restriction by language or geography, this systematic review will provide a comprehensive and global picture on the topic and enables investigations into any regional differences.

  • Different epidemiological definitions of allergic diseases, as well as the consideration of a wide variety of helminth parasite species for which numbers of eligible studies may be limited, may affect the validity of any subgroup meta-analyses by parasite species and allergic outcomes.

Introduction

Intestinal parasites include a large group of micro-organisms of which protozoans and helminths are of most relevance to human health.1 Most prevalent are the nematode helminth group, including Ascaris lumbricoides, Trichuris trichiura and hookworms (Necator americanus and Ancylostoma duodenale).2 Prevalence varies by geographic region and is greatest in endemic areas of sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America, China and Eastern Asia, where such infections are linked to poverty and poor sanitation.1 3–5

Allergic diseases such as asthma and rhinitis, and eczema affect millions worldwide.6–8 Among environmental exposures considered to influence the development of allergic diseases are childhood infections including helminths. Helminths are capable of producing immunological mediators that modulate host immune responses, particularly allergic inflammation.9 10 However, results of epidemiological studies addressing the relationship between helminth infections and risk of allergic diseases, done in almost all geographic regions of the world, show inconsistent findings.11–18

There are only two previous systematic reviews of observational studies investigating the relationship between helminth infections and allergy: (1) a systematic review included 30 studies published up to 2006 in a meta-analysis of the relationship between helminths and asthma symptoms and showed overall no association but parasite-specific effects were observed—hookworm was associated with a reduced while A. lumbricoides was associated with an increased risk of symptoms19; (2) a systematic review of 21 observational studies published up to 2009, studied the relationship between helminths and allergen skin prick test (SPT) reactivity and showed an inverse association between helminths and SPT.20 Three other more recent systematic reviews have studied the relationship between Toxocara spp seroprevalence and allergy: (1) a meta-analysis from 2013 of 10 studies addressing the association between Toxocara spp and asthma showed an increased risk21; (2) a systematic review from 2017 concluded that children infected with Toxocara spp were more likely to have asthma22 and (3) a study from 2018 showed that Toxocara spp was associated with an increased risk of urticaria but not with atopy or eczema.23

Existing systematic reviews and meta-analyses investigating the role of various helminth intestinal parasites in atopy or allergic diseases are 10 or more years old and considered few allergic outcomes (eg, asthma or atopy). As detailed above, more recent systematic reviews have focused only on Toxocara spp infections. Given these important gaps and diverging results in the literature, the aims of the current systematic review are to identify, critically appraise and synthesise the evidence from observational epidemiological studies investigating the influence of various species and parasite burdens of helminth infections on the: (1) risk of developing asthma, rhinitis, eczema and/or atopy and (2) the expression of clinical outcomes and disease severity in patients with already established allergic diseases. Because of the recent systematic reviews addressing toxocariasis, Toxocara spp will not be considered here.

Methods and analysis

This study has been registered with the International prospective register of systematic reviews (PROSPERO). The review will be reported in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines for systematic reviews and MOOSE (Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology) guidelines for meta-analysis of observational epidemiological studies.24 25 Any modifications in the protocol during the systematic review will be reported.

Search strategy

We have developed a comprehensive search strategy for retrieving published and unpublished studies on the topic (online supplementary appendix 1). We will search the Cochrane Library (Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), Cochrane Methodology Register), MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, AMED, ISI Web of Science (Science and Social Science Index), WHO Global Health Library (which encompasses African Index Medicus, Index Medicus for the Eastern Mediterranean Region, Index Medicus for the South-East Asia, Latin America and the Caribbean Literature on Health Sciences and Western Pacific Region Index Medicus), Scielo, IndMed, PakMediNet, KoreaMed and Ichushi (updated by Japan Medical Abstracts Society). Search dates will be from 1970 (or from the inception of a database if this occurs later than 1970) to present. The bibliographies of all eligible studies will be reviewed to identify additional possible studies. We will identify unpublished and ongoing work and research in progress by searching key Internet-based relevant databases (www.clinicaltrials.gov; www.clinicaltrialsregister.eu; www.controlledtrials.com; www.anzctr.org.au). In addition, we will contact authors who have published in this field to ask for potentially additional papers. No language restrictions will be imposed; translations will be undertaken where necessary.

Inclusion criteria for study designs

We will include all observational and analytical epidemiological studies, including cohort, case–control and cross-sectional studies.

We will select all the studies that include participants of any age, in which the relationship between helminth infection and respiratory allergic diseases, atopic eczema and/or atopy has been studied and include studies investigating any type of helminth infection, including Enterobius vermicularis, A. lumbricoides, T. trichiura, hookworm (A. duodenale and N. americanus), Strongyloides stercoralis, Hymenolepsis spp (H. nana and H. diminuta) and Schistosoma spp (S. mansoni and S. haematobium). Toxocara spp infections will not be considered in this review given the recent systematic review that considered it. Where applicable, the comparator to helminth infection will be no infection. Some studies would have compared different types of helminth infections and load of infection; we will maintain these comparisons in the systematic review.

We will exclude discussion papers, non-research letters and editorials, randomised controlled trials, clinical case studies and case-series, and animal studies.

Study selection

Papers retrieved from the databases will be exported to a reference management programme where further screening will be undertaken. Removal of duplicate publications will be performed, thereafter, the titles and abstracts of retrieved papers will be checked by two investigators. The full text of all potentially eligible studies will be retrieved and independently assessed against the inclusion criteria (see above) by two reviewers. The reviewers will decide which of the studies fit the inclusion criteria. Any disagreements will be resolved by discussion, with a third reviewer arbitrating in the circumstance of unresolved discrepancies.

To ensure transparency, the process of selection will be summarised using a PRISMA flow diagram.

Data extraction and management

Data from selected articles will be transferred from their original presentation to a proper form made in Microsoft Excel software, with each study receiving a reference code. Each study will have its own extraction form. If necessary, we will collect indirect data from figures and charts, adapting their interpretation from two different authors by consensus and authors of original articles will also be contacted for further information and data.

For all included studies, we will be collect the following information: study design, number of participants and their characteristics (namely, wheezing due to early-life respiratory viral infections, early childhood respiratory infections, personal and family history of allergies, household smoking), country of study, year of publication, profiles of helminth infection (presence, load, duration of infection, types of parasites, monoinfection or coinfection, recent or ancient treatment, frequency of infection), geographical differences; estimates (HR, risk ratio, OR, 95% CIs, mean and SD) of the association between helminth infection and the study outcomes; confounding factors will also be analysed, if reported, namely malaria, tuberculosis or HIV coinfection, technical aspects of determination/operational definition of helminth infection.

Data extraction will be completed independently by two reviewers and discrepancies will be decided by a third reviewer.

Outcomes

Primary outcome

Estimates of association between helminth infection and incidence of asthma (either doctor diagnosed or wheeze in the past 12 months—eg, ISAAC (International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood) study definition or other comparable definitions), allergic rhinitis (doctor diagnosed or as defined in the ISAAC study or other comparable definitions), eczema (flexural dermatitis diagnosed by doctor or as defined in the ISAAC study or other comparable definitions) and atopy (assessed using allergen-specific IgE or SPTs).

Secondary outcome

Estimates of association between helminth infection and clinical outcomes of respiratory allergic diseases, including exacerbations, hospitalisations, severity according to clinical/symptoms evaluation (using any type of validated scale or questionnaire) and health-related quality of life (using any type of validated scale or questionnaire).

Quality assessment

Risk of bias assessment will be independently undertaken by two different reviewers, using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme26 quality assessment tool for the types of included studies. We will appraise different components of each study, including appropriateness of study design, potential for selection bias, measurement of exposures and outcomes and generalisability of the study findings. For each study, the grading of each individual components and the global study rating will be assigned categories of risk of bias: low, moderate and high. The global grading will involve taking an average of all individual components. Any disagreements not resolved by discussion will be arbitrated by a third reviewer.

Quantitative assessment

If necessary, and according to the available reported data on risk associations, a quantitative analysis will be performed to obtain effect estimations, heterogeneity and consistency tests. Forest plots will be used to graphically present the results of the meta-analysis. Funnel plots will be used to graphically assess small study effect, which is one type of publication bias. Heterogeneity between effect sizes of included studies will be assessed by visual inspection of forest plots and by using the χ2 test for heterogeneity (with a p value of <0.1) and inconsistency between studies will be described using the percentage of the variability in effect estimates that is due to heterogeneity rather than chance (I2). It is generally accepted that I2 values up to 25%, 50% and 75% represent low, medium and high levels of heterogeneity or inconsistency, respectively,27 28 although it is now clear that this statistics is not an absolute measure of such heterogeneity and rather indicates the proportion of observed variance that reflects variance in true effect sizes rather than sampling error.29 We plan to use Mantel-Haenzsel risk ratios with a random-effects model and 95% CI for dichotomous data. Continuous outcomes (such as symptoms or quality of life assessments) will be analysed as standardised mean difference values using a random-effects model and 95% CI, because the included studies may report different measurement instruments. We also plan to performed sensitivity analysis of the included studies and their impact on meta-analysis. If results from longitudinal studies allow, the primary outcomes (such as risk ratios or HRs) will also be analysed with an adaptation form trial sequential analysis using O’Brien Fleming monitoring boundaries approach, in order to avoid false positive or negative results of the pooled meta-analysis, thereby avoiding false or negative results.30 Subgroup analysis may be performed according to different reported species of helminths or diseases, rural versus urban settings, age groups, geographical regions and by study design.

Data synthesis

We will produce a descriptive summary table of all included studies in order to summarise the literature. For studies without required data (eg, relative risk estimates of effect of helminth infection and the outcomes), we will undertake a narrative synthesis of the data in which we use texts to describe the overall findings from the studies, highlight their strengths and weaknesses and make textual comparisons between the studies in this category in the light of the study question. For studies we judge to be reasonably clinically and methodologically homogeneous (ie, have used similar methods with regards to subject selection and inclusion, helminth definition and assessment, outcome definition and assessment and statistical analyses), we will perform meta-analyses using random-effects models to estimate the combined effect of helminth infection on each of the study outcome. The meta-analysis for the association between helminth infection and each outcome will be undertaken separately. We will quantify the heterogeneity between studies using the I2 statistic, which is a measure (range 0%–100%) used to quantify the proportion of variance in the pooled estimates attributable to differences in estimates between studies included in the meta-analysis.27–30 The between-study variance will be estimated using the Tau-squared (τ2) statistic derived from the DerSimonian-Laird approach.31 Where data are available, we will perform subgroup analyses according to rural versus urban settings, age groups, geographical regions of the world and by other potential characteristics, such as study design (cohort, case–control, cross-sectional studies). We will perform sensitivity analyses based on the sample size of included studies as well as on the basis of the risk of bias results in the studies in order to assess the robustness of our findings to different assumptions. In the case of sensitivity analysis on the basis of study quality, we will estimate the combined effect estimates from all studies regardless of their quality grading (low, moderate, high). Then we will exclude all low-quality studies, leaving the moderate and high-quality studies; we will then compare the results to the results when all studies were combined regardless of their quality. We will repeat the process by excluding the moderate quality studies, leaving only the high-quality studies and then we will compare the results to those from the previous results. We will assess evidence of publication bias using funnel plots and statistically using Begg and Egger tests.32 33 The meta-analyses will be performed using Stata statistical software (release V.13; StataCorp LP., College Station, Texas, USA). The PRISMA checklist will be followed for reporting of the systematic review.

Ethics and data management plan

No ethical approval required because the data to be collected and analysed will be based only on the published literature and therefore cannot be linked to specific individuals. Retrieved data will be kept in a database that will have protected access and will only be used by the involved authors. However, anonymised data will be placed in an open repository.

Patient and public involvement

Since this will be a systematic review, there will be no direct patient or public involvement.

Ethics and dissemination

This systematic review will allow us, for the first time, to synthesise the findings of observational studies addressing the associations between a wide variety of relevant helminth parasites and common allergic outcomes. The review will be based on publications published between 1970 and January 2020, and will allow us to analyse methodological aspects of selected studies namely study design, regarding the questions, methods used and risk of selection bias.

More specifically, our review will fill in an important gap since previous systematic reviews are either dated or focused on a single helminth (eg, Toxocara). Thus, our study will provide relevant up-to-date information on current knowledge of helminth-allergy associations in children and adults. This will be done by accessing information worldwide without geographical or language restrictions in which; (1) various parameters related to helminth infection will be analysed—types of helminths, infection load, frequency of infections, among other; (2) the relationship will be analysed between helminth parameters and not just a single allergic disease but on a broader context of atopy, asthma, allergic rhinitis and eczema and (3) the relationship will not only be analysed in terms of risk of disease development but also regarding disease severity.

We believe our results should allow us to draw meaningful conclusions about the relevance and type of effects involved in the relationship between helminth infections and atopy, asthma and allergic diseases in children and adults, and may have clinical and societal implications.

Our dissemination strategy will involve presentations at scientific meetings, as well as publication of article(s) in international, peer-reviewed, open-access journals. However, given the increasing relative percentage of children with atopy, asthma and allergic diseases worldwide, particularly in certain geographical areas, the relevant burden of helminth infections in certain parts of the world, we also plan to organise meetings with general practitioners and other healthcare providers, as well as with local communities (namely in Africa) to analyse and discuss our findings and their potential implications.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to acknowledge Professor João Costa, of the Portuguese Collaborating Center of the IberoAmerican Cochrane Network, Faculty of Medicine, University of Lisbon, Portugal, for his willingness to assist with planned searches for this systematic review in Cochrane Library.

References

Footnotes

  • Contributors All authors contributed to the design and conceptualisation of this review. MA drafted the protocol with primary support from BIN (review guarantor) and LT-B. TM, PC, JMRG, BIN, MB and LT-B were involved in checking various steps of the search strategy, including keywords, as well as the final version of the protocol. JMRG was involved in the statistical strategy for data analysis. MA, TM, JMRG and LT-B were involved in establishing eligibility criteria and data extraction forms. All authors provided feedback on the manuscript, at all stages.

  • Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Patient and public involvement Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, or conduct, or reporting, or dissemination plans of this research.

  • Patient consent for publication Not required.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.