Objectives Subjective sleep quality (SSQ) is defined by the satisfaction of one’s overall sleep experience and is composed of sleep depth and restfulness. It has not been clarified how poor SSQ is associated to changes in lifestyles. The purpose is to reveal the association of lifestyle pattern changes and poor SSQ.
Design A cross-sectional study.
Setting The data on basic attributes, SSQ and lifestyle such as presence/absence of smoking, exercise, physical activity, supper time close to bedtime, drinking habits and alcohol intake amount per day were obtained from database and questionnaire of specified medical check-ups in fiscal year 2014–2015 in Japan. The analysis was conducted in 2019.
Participants The subjects comprised 49 483 residents (26 087 men and 23 396 women), aged 40–74 years who had undergone an annual specified medical check-up from 2014 to 2015 in Fukushima Prefecture, Japan.
Outcome measure Status of SSQ in 2015 was assessed using a question asking whether or not the subjects usually got enough sleep. Poor SSQ in 2015 and lifestyle pattern changes in 2014–2015 were compared between those who were in healthy status both in 2014 and 2015 (referent) and non-referent, using binary logistic regression analysis.
Results Unhealthy lifestyle pattern for 2014–2015 was significantly associated to poor SSQ in 2015: ‘absent to absent’ in exercise for men (OR=1.472; 95% CI 1.316 to 1.647) and women (OR=1.428; 95% CI 1.285 to 1.587), physical activity for men (OR=1.420; 95% CI 1.270 to 1.588) and women (OR=1.471; 95% CI 1.322 to 1.638) and ‘present to present’ in supper time for men (OR=1.149; 95% CI 1.020 to 1.294) and women (OR=1.288; 95% CI 1.102 to 1.505).
Conclusions Healthcare workers may be able to contribute to the improvement of SSQ, focusing on changeable lifestyles.
- public health
- nutrition & dietetics
- sleep medicine
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study
This study provides important insight into the association between lifestyle changes and subjective sleep quality, categorising such lifesyle changes for 2 years into four patterns, which were used for analysis.
We employed a cross-sectional study design, instead of cohort, for the current research, because a cross-sectional study was considered to be more suitable than a cohort study in which the time of assessment of lifestyle and subjective sleep quality differs.
A limitation of the current study was that the duration of lifestyle habits was not measured, and thus the answers in each year may not reflect the actual duration of the habits in question.
Subjective sleep quality (SSQ) is defined by the satisfaction of one’s overall sleep experience and is composed of sleep depth and restfulness.1 2 Past studies have reported poor SSQ to be associated with several health problems such as sleep apnoea,3 depression,4 suicide,5 obesity6 and cardiovascular disease.7 Sleep disturbance such as low-quality sleep may cause an increase in medical costs in cases where it accompanies other diseases.8 Thus, poor sleep quality is considered to be a growing public health problem in many countries.
Previous studies have demonstrated that poor SSQ is prevalent among individuals with unhealthy lifestyles, such as those with a lack of exercise and/or physical activity,9 10 those who smoke11 and/or engage in binge drinking12 and those who eat meals close to bedtime.13
However, it has not been clarified how SSQ is associated to changes in such lifestyles. SSQ is fundamental to reports of insomnia and non-restorative sleep,2 and thus it is important to understand the mechanism of poor SSQ in relation to such changes for improvement of major sleep problems such as insomnia and non-restorative sleep. Previous studies have reported that lifestyle changes such as smoking cessation, increased physical activity and healthy diet contribute to the reduction of the sleep problems such as insomnia,14 obstructive sleep apnoea,15 difficulty of falling asleep16 and shorter sleep time.17 Although these sleep problems are not directly equivalent to SSQ, above-mentioned past studies may suggest that the lifestyle changes possibly have important role on poor SSQ.
The purpose of the present study was to examine the association between lifestyle pattern changes and SSQ using 2-year longitudinal data. We hypothesised that poor SSQ is associated to unhealthy lifestyle changes or keeping unhealthy lifestyle such as starting/continuing smoking and supper time close to bedtime, increasing the frequency and volume of alcohol intake or keeping binge drinking or reducing the frequency/continuous absence of exercise and/or physical activity.
Study design and participants
In this cross-sectional study, we used the data of 91 795 residents, aged 40 to 74 years, who had undergone an annual specified medical check-up in all years from 2014 to 2015 in Fukushima Prefecture, Japan, by the National Health Insurance Organisation. Of 91 795 residents, individuals who had poor SSQ in 2014 and whose data on age, gender, body mass index (BMI), blood pressure, fasting plasma glucose, haemoglobin A1C (HbA1c), habits of smoking, exercise, physical activity, eating meals close to bedtime, drinking (frequency and volume of alcohol intake) and sleep quality were incomplete and excluded from the present study. The analysis was conducted in 2019, and the total number of participants was 49 483 (26 087 men and 23 396 women).
The specified medical check-up included a questionnaire asking about lifestyles and SSQ. Together with the check-up data on basic attributes, the responses were recorded in the National Health Insurance Organisation’s database and used for this study.
These were basic information such as gender and age in 2015, and BMI, blood pressure, fasting plasma glucose and HbA1c in 2014–2015. Variables used after following classification were age (40–49, 50–59, 60–69 and 70–74 years), BMI by WHO criteria (<18.5 for ‘underweight’; ≥18.5 and <25 for ‘normal’ and ≥25 for ‘overweight’),18 blood pressure status according to the American Heart Association guidelines (systolic pressure <120 and diastolic pressure <80 for ‘normal’; systolic pressure 120–129 and diastolic pressure <80 for ‘elevated’; systolic pressure 130–139 or diastolic pressure 80–89 for ‘stage 1’ and systolic pressure ≥140 or diastolic pressure ≥90 for ‘stage 2’)19 and presence of diabetes according to the American Diabetes Association criteria (fasting plasma glucose ≥126 or HbA1c ≥6.5 for ‘present’).20 Of these variables, we dichotomised the following three variables for statistical analysis: hypertension (‘stage 1’ or ‘stage 2’ for ‘present’ and ‘normal’ or ‘elevated’ for ‘absent’), drinking habits (‘everyday’ or ‘sometimes’ for ‘present’ and ‘rarely drink (cannot drink)’ for ‘absent’) and alcohol intake amount (20 g or more for ‘binge’ and <20 g for ‘moderate’).
The habits in 2014 and 2015 of exercise, physical activity, smoking, eating meals close to bedtime and drinking (frequency and volume of alcohol intake) were assessed using the following six respective questions used in the previous studies,21–23 with yes–no response or single answers from multiple response options: for exercise, we asked ‘Have you been exercising regularly for over 30 min at a time, during which you sweat lightly, two or more times weekly, for over a year?’; for physical activity, we asked ‘In your daily life, do you walk for more than 1 hour a day or perform an equivalent amount of physical activity?’; for smoking, we asked ‘Have you smoked a total of over 100 cigarettes or smoked over a period of 6 months or longer, and if so, have you been smoked in the last 1 month?’; for supper time, we asked ‘Do you have an evening meal within 2 hours of going to bed, 3 times or more per week?’; for drinking frequency, we asked ‘How often do you drink alcohol?’ with response options of ‘everyday’, ‘sometimes’ or ‘rarely drink (cannot drink)’; for alcohol intake amount, we asked ‘How much do you drink per day, in terms of glasses of refined sake?’, with response options of ‘<1 glass per day’, ‘1–2 glasses per day’, ‘2–3 glasses per day’ or ‘≥3 glasses per day’, using the following example sentence ‘“a glass (180 mL) of refined sake (rice wine) is equivalent to a medium bottle (500 mL) of beer, 80 mL of shochu (alcohol content 35%), a glass (double, 60 mL) of whiskey or two glasses (240 mL) of wine’. The ethanol content for each drink type was calculated to be equivalent to 20 g.
Subjective sleep quality
In this study, SSQ was assessed using the following question with yes–no responses to briefly understand subjects’ sleep depth and restfulness: ‘Do you sleep well and enough?’ Sleep quality was considered to be ‘poor’ when the subjects answered ‘no’.
The characteristics of the subjects were assessed by descriptive statistics, and then further exploration was conducted using bivariate and multivariate analyses. The association between SSQ in 2015 and the change in patterns of lifestyle factors and basic attributes from 2014 to 2015 was then analysed by χ2 test using the following four change patterns from 2014 to 2015: for BMI (normal to normal, underweight/overweight to normal, underweight/normal/overweight to underweight, underweight/normal/overweight to overweight); for hypertension, diabetes, smoking, exercise, physical activity and drinking habits (absent to absent, absent to present, present to absent and present to present) and for alcohol intake amount (moderate to moderate, moderate to binge, binge to moderate and binge to binge). When statistically significant association was found in χ2 test, then residual analysis was conducted to clarify that category had great contribution: the cells were considered to have significantly more people than expected when the adjusted standardised residual values were greater than 1.96 and to have significantly fewer people than expected when the values were lower than 1.96. The association between SSQ in 2015 and age was examined by Mann-Whitney U test.
To examine the association between lifestyle pattern change with SSQ by gender and to control confounders such as basic attributes, binary logistic regression analysis was employed using the referent. Subjects who had healthy status continuously from 2014 to 2015 were categorised as the referent: ‘normal’ for BMI; ‘absent’ for hypertension, diabetes, smoking, supper time close to bedtime and drinking habits; ‘present’ for exercise and physical activity and ‘moderate’ for alcohol intake amount. Explanatory variables comprised of age in 2015 and changes in patterns of lifestyle factors and basic attributes between 2014 and 2015, and response variable was poor SSQ in 2015. Three models were built in the following steps: first, one-on-one association of explanatory and response variables was created as a crude model to obtain fundamental information (model 1); second, an age-adjusted model was built (model 2); finally, a multivariate-adjusted model (model 3) was created by using all factors regardless of their significance in models 1 and 2 in logistic regression analysis. In order to test our hypothesis, a direct method was used for all models. Model 3 was selected as the final logistic regression model in the present study. The Hosmer-Lemeshow test showed the good fits in model 3 both for men and women (p=0.977 and 0.933, respectively).
The variance inflation factor (VIF) was used to test multicollinearity for model 3. Among men, VIFs for age, changes in the patterns of BMI, hypertension, diabetes, smoking, exercise, physical activity, supper time, drinking habits and alcohol intake amount were 1.079, 1.033, 1.041, 1.015, 1.053, 1.499, 1.473, 1.029, 1.382 and 1.414, respectively. Among women, VIFs for above-mentioned explanatory variables were 1.125, 1.042, 1.047, 1.024, 1.050, 1.367, 1.336, 1.017, 1.188 and 1.232, respectively. None of the VIF values reached 10, and the mean VIF of the model was less than 6. Thus, there was no collinearity.
Significance level was set as 5%, and OR and 95% CI were calculated for gender and age, and also those in relation to the referent were calculated for other explanatory variables. All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS statistics V.25 (IBM, Armonk, New York, USA) in April 2019.
Patient and public involvement
The participants were not involved in the development of the research question, outcome measures, design, recruitment and conduct of this study.
As shown in table 1, the proportions of men and women were 52.7% and 47.3%, respectively. In 2015, the most common age group was the 60s (50.0%). Both in 2014 and 2015, the most common BMI category was ‘normal’ (67.1% and 66.7%, respectively). The proportions of subjects who had diabetes were approximately 10% both in 2014 and 2015 (9.1% and 10%, respectively).
In bivariate analysis among men shown in table 2, the age was significantly lower in individuals who reported poor SSQ than those who did not (p<0.001). The changes in patterns of BMI and hypertension had significant association with poor SSQ (p=0.003 and 0.012, respectively). For BMI, result of residual analysis indicated that the number of individuals with poor SSQ was significantly low in the pattern ‘underweight/overweight to normal.’ For lifestyle factors, the change in the patterns of smoking, exercise, physical activity, supper time, drinking habits and alcohol intake amount had statistically significant associations with poor SSQ (p=0.027, <0.001, <0.001, <0.001, 0.03 and 0.006, respectively). For supper time, the results of residual analysis indicated that poor SSQ was significantly associated to the pattern ‘present to absent’.
As shown in table 3, for women, bivariate analysis indicated that age, changes in patterns of smoking, exercise, physical activity, supper time and drinking habits were significantly associated to poor SSQ (p<0.001, 0.007, <0.001, <0.001, <0.001 and <0.001, respectively). For supper time, the results of residual analysis indicated that the numbers of individuals who reported poor SSQ were significantly high in every pattern except ‘absent to absent’.
As shown in model 3 in table 4 for men, of basic attributes, statistically significant associations were found between poor SSQ and age (OR=0.990; 95% CI 0.985 to 0.996) and the change in patterns of BMI ‘underweight/normal/overweight to underweight’ (OR=1.305; 95% CI 1.047 to 1.625). Of lifestyle pattern changes, significant associations with poor SSQ were found in ‘present to absent’ (OR=1.469; 95% CI 1.273 to 1.695), ‘absent to present’ (OR=1.211; 95% CI 1.038 to 1.411) and ‘absent to absent’ (OR=1.472; 95% CI 1.316 to 1.647) for exercise, ‘present to absent’ (OR=1.620; 95% CI 1.421 to 1.847) and ‘absent to absent’ (OR=1.420; 95% CI 1.270 to 1.588) for physical activity and ‘present to absent’ (OR=1.374; 95% CI to 1.210, 1.560) and ‘present to present’ (OR=1.149; 95% CI 1.020 to 1.294) for supper time close to bedtime.
As shown in model 3 in table 5 for women, significantly high ORs compared with the referent were found in the category ‘present to absent’ (OR=1.563; 95% CI 1.352 to 1.807) and ‘absent to absent’ (OR=1.428; 95% CI 1.285 to 1.587) for exercise, ‘present to absent’ (OR=1.416; 95% CI 1.236 to 1.620) and ‘absent to absent’ (OR=1.471; 95% CI 1.322 to 1.638) for physical activity, ‘absent to present’ (OR=1.254; 95% CI 1.068 to 1.472), ‘present to absent’ (OR=1.250; 95% CI 1.069 to 1.461) and ‘present to present’ (OR=1.288; 95% CI 1.102 to 1.505) for supper time close to bedtime and ‘absent to present’ (OR=1.386; 95% CI 1.176 to 1.635) for drinking habits. Smoking habits did not significantly associate to SSQ.
This study was conducted to examine the association between lifestyle pattern changes and poor SSQ. We discovered that poor SSQ was significantly associated to the change in lifestyle patterns of exercise, physical activity and supper time both in men and women; in addition, reduction of BMI for men and presence of drinking habits for women were gender-specific factors associated to poor SSQ. The findings of the present study may contribute to the enhancement of SSQ, since the improvement of lifestyle patterns may be practically approached.
The proportions of men and women were similar, median age was 68 and the most common age group was the 60 s. For BMI, the ‘normal’ was the most common category. The number of subjects with diabetes was small. For the interpretation of these results, it is necessary to discuss the association of potential confounders with Poor SSQ. Although several health problems such as sleep apnoea, depression and suicide are associated to poor SSQ,3–5 and thus are considered to be potential confounders, the present study did not measure these health problems. Therefore, our results could not provide the data for precise interpretation. However, in light of past studies that reported that ageing is risk factor of sleep apnoea,24 whereas prevalence of mood disorder including depression among Japanese was higher in individuals aged 20–64 years old than those aged 65 or older,25 the study subjects may have both healthy and unhealthy attributions related to poor SSQ taking their median age and common age group into account.
Our bivariate analysis showed that age of individuals with poor SSQ was significantly lower than those without poor SSQ both among men and women, while past studies reported that poor SSQ is associated with ageing and is prevalent among the older population.26 Importantly, the difference of median age between individuals with and without poor SSQ was just a year, and thus there is few practical/clinical suggestion even though statistical difference was found. Association of age and changes in the patterns of lifestyle such as exercise, physical activity and supper time to poor SSQ presence require further investigation via multivariate analysis.
In multivariate analysis, results are discussed in detail using four patterns of lifestyle change, including healthy/unhealthy lifestyle change and keeping healthy/unhealthy lifestyle that we defined.
Among men, the results of logistic regression analysis indicated that the unhealthy change of BMI ‘underweight/normal/overweight to underweight’ was significantly associated to poor SSQ. Past studies indicated that high BMI/obesity is associated to sleep problems such as sleep apnoea, short sleep duration, low sleep quality, less efficiency, daytime sleepiness and inadequate timing of sleep,27 28 and these sleep problems are considered to be components of low SSQ. The results of our study were inconsistent with such past studies, and thus the presence of unexpected confounding factor is of suspected. Importantly, mental health problem such as depression is associated to both weight loss and sleep problem.4 29 The change to ‘underweight’ may be actually associated to such mental health problem, not to SSQ.
For exercise among men, ORs were significantly higher in all patterns than in the referent. The pattern ‘absent to present’, which was theoretically considered to be healthy lifestyle change, was rather associated to poor SSQ, and thus this result is not consistent with the hypothesis. It is important that the healthy change pattern ‘absent to present’ had lower OR than those of unhealthy lifestyle change and keeping unhealthy lifestyle. Subjects in ‘absent to present’ might be in the middle of improving direction of SSQ, but not fully achieved such improvement. This interpretation brings practical suggestion that the engagement in exercise at least for 2 years may contribute to improved SSQ.
The results regarding physical activity among men were consistent with our hypothesis: unhealthy lifestyle change and keeping unhealthy lifestyle were associated to poor SSQ. Although it is impossible to discuss the causal relationships between physical activity and SSQ due to the research design, the results indicated that continuation of physical activity for at least 1 year may be equivalent to 2 years of continuation. Considering that physical activity is defined as any bodily movement30 and was defined as engagement in walking or equivalent physical activity in this study, the habit of physical activity may be practical for SSQ improvement since physical activity can be more easily incorporated into daily life than exercise.
For supper time close to bedtime among men, significant associations were found in ‘present to absent’ and ‘present to present’ compared with the referent, and these results represented that poor SSQ was statistically prevalent in the subjects both who had healthy lifestyle change and kept unhealthy lifestyle. These facts seem like a contradiction and thus should be interpreted carefully. Past studies reported that meals within 3 hours of bedtime are positively associated with nocturnal awakening,13 and that nocturnal awakening is associated to daytime sleepiness.31 In light of these past studies, subjects in the patterns of ‘present to absent’ and ‘present to present’ may have had daytime sleepiness in 2014 due to lifestyle of supper close to bedtime, such daytime sleepiness may have lasted and thus they reported their poor SSQ in 2015. Although there is a possibility that the perception of reduced SSQ motivated the improved lifestyle regarding supper time, our interpretation that association between supper time close to bedtime and sleep problem in previous year may carry over into following year may have practical implication for improvement of SSQ.
For exercise and physical activity among women, the results were consistent with our hypothesis: unhealthy lifestyle change and keeping unhealthy lifestyle were associated to poor SSQ. The OR of ‘absent to present’ category of exercise did not have statistical significance, compared with the referent, whereas that among men had statistical significance. Among women, the engagement in exercise and physical activity in a certain year may have an equivalent effect to continuation of them, or the absence of poor SSQ may contribute to the presence of exercise and physical activity.
For supper time close to bedtime, the pattern ‘present to absent’, the healthy lifestyle change, was associated to poor SSQ, contrary to our hypothesis. This result does not necessarily mean that women should avoid the healthy lifestyle change in order to improve their SSQ, because continuous absence of supper time close to bedtime is possibly associated to good, or moderate SSQ, as we showed in the referent defined as 2 years of continuation of absence of such lifestyle. Subjects in the pattern ‘present to absent’ may have the improved SSQ when they keep healthy lifestyle for supper time, that is, they may be in the middle of improvement process. For drinking habits, the results were partially consistent with our hypothesis since poor SSQ was statistically prevalent only when subjects were in the pattern “absent to present,” unhealthy lifestyle change. Whereas, it is important to note that no association was found between SSQ and the pattern ‘present to present’, defined as keeping unhealthy lifestyle. There may be a difference of background between subjects who started unhealthy lifestyle and those who kept it. Past study indicated that women more precisely recognise their sleep problems and thus more actively manage to such problems than men.32 In light of this past study, it is assumed that women subjects in the pattern ‘present to present‘may have carefully self-monitored regarding their drinking habits, and thus the degree of such habits may have been controllable or manageable; poor SSQ may not have been prevalent even if they had drinking habits.
Although we hypothesised that poor SSQ is associated to starting/continuing smoking, this hypothesis was rejected, whereas past studies indicated that smoking habit was associated with low-quality sleep,33 our results suggest the possibility that poor SSQ may not be explained by smoking. Although our results did not reveal the cause-and-effect link between lifestyle change and SSQ, it may have practical suggestion: the focus on the improvement of exercise, physical activity and supper time both for men and women, rather than smoking, may contribute to the solution of poor SSQ.
In regards to the generalisability of present study, this study had following two potential biases. First, the subjects were extracted from database of National Health Insurance Organisation. The consumer of National Health Insurance Organisation was commonly comprised of individuals who were in self-employed, retired or non-standard employment.34 It is assumed that there are gaps between our study subjects and Japanese and also global population. Second, the results of present study might be influenced by the Great East Japan Earthquake in 2011, since the study subjects comprised of individuals who lived in Fukushima Prefecture, Japan, in 2014–2015. Past studies reported psychiatric sequelae such as insomnia, anxiety, depression and alcohol misuse after the disaster.35–37 These psychiatric sequelae may be associated to lifestyle change and SSQ. It cannot be denied the possibility that the subjects in present study were under the long-term effects of such psychiatric sequelae, whereas, it is reasonable to say that our study subjects might include the individuals who did not experience the disaster since the large sample size, approximately 50 000. This possible variety of sampling might contribute to the reduction of bias in the present study. Therefore, we believe that our study could present a useful result in line with the study purpose.
The present study has the following four limitations. First, we could not measure the duration of lifestyle habits. The responses from the subjects were collected via annual health check-ups, and thus the answers in each year may have not reflected the actual duration of the habits in question. Second, data based on the subjects’ experiences in their social lives that were possibly associated to SSQ were not collected. For example, a previous study indicated that job stress is associated with low-quality sleep.38 Future studies should collect information related to social life such as job stress, domestic trouble and financial problems. Third, the present study had flaws in adjustment of potential confounder such as musculoskeletal pain, depression and insomnia and in outcome measurement. In regards to adjustment of potential confounder, the integrative analysis using broader medical records in addition data of medical check-ups may be a solution. Finally, the data were collected cross-sectionally, and thus cause-and-effect relationship between lifestyle change and SSQ was not pursuable. It is required that future study should employ more elaborated research design such as cohort to provide robust evidence regarding the association between lifestyle change and SSQ than current study.
Poor SSQ was observed in men who did not engage in exercise continuously over 2 years, did not engage in physical activity at the given year and had a supper time within 2 hours before bedtime in previous year, and in females who did not engage in exercise and physical activity at the given year, had a supper time within 2 hours before bedtime over 2 years and started the drinking habits in the given year. In public health, sleep quality is emphasised not only for prevention of other health problems but also as an important health outcome. Healthcare workers may be able to contribute to the prevention of poor SSQ, focusing on the improvements of changeable lifestyle habits, such as exercise, physical activity and supper time both for men and women, and as drinking habits for women.
We are grateful to NHIO for their assistance with data acquisition.
Contributors TH created the study concept and design, analysed and interpreted the data, drafted the initial manuscript and critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content. HK, SE, YM and TK provided technical support and critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content. AT and MK collected the data. TF provided administrative support, acquired and interpreted the data and critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content.
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient and public involvement Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, or conduct, or reporting, or dissemination plans of this research.
Patient consent for publication Not required.
Ethics approval The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of Fukushima Medical University, Fukushima, Japan (Application No. 2974).
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data availability statement Data are available in a public, open access repository. Extra data can be accessed via the Dryad data repository at http://datadryad.org/withthedoi:10.5061/dryad.31zcrjdjn
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.