Table 1

Definitions of interventions and control groups (adapted from Clare and Woods1)

Cognitive trainingRepeated guided practice
Uses standardised tasks
Theoretically motivated strategies
Range of difficulties (adaptive)
Aim for improvement in isolated cognitive domain with possibility of generalisation to non-trained task
Cognitive stimulation:Wide range of activities
Group format
Significant emphasis on social interaction
Aim for general improvement in cognitive function
Not adaptive
Significant use of reality orientation or reminiscence therapy
Cognitive rehabilitation:Individualised goals
Aim to improve everyday function/ADLs
Compensatory approach
Control group
 Active control groupIntervention matched for time/social interaction
Intervention contains cognitive content not directly related to cognitive outcome measure
 Non-active control groupWaiting list/treatment as usual or minimal intervention not matched for time/social interaction/no specific cognitive content
  • ADLs, activities of daily living.