Table 4

Risk of bias of the included trials

TrialSequence generationAllocation concealmentBlindingIncomplete outcome dataSelective outcome reportingAcademic biasSponsor bias
DCCT/EDIC 19833–46AdequateAdequateAdequateUnclearAdequateInadequateAdequate
Franklin et al104AdequateAdequateInadequateAdequateUnclearAdequateAdequate
Hvidovre 198268UnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearAdequateUnclear
Kroc 1984112–117UnclearUnclearAdequateAdequateUnclearAdequateAdequate
Linn et al 110AdequateUnclearUnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclear
Linn et al 69UnclearUnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateInadequateUnclear
Microalbuminuria50 51UnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearAdequateAdequate
Minnesota DCCT 198383–86UnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearAdequateAdequate
Oslo 198673–80AdequateUnclearAdequateUnclearUnclearAdequateInadequate
Oxford 1983111UnclearUnclearAdequateAdequateUnclearAdequateAdequate
Perlman et al105UnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearAdequateAdequate
Service et al81AdequateUnclearUnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclear
Shah et al101AdequateUnclearAdequateAdequateUnclearAdequateUnclear
Steno 1a 198272 119–121UnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearUnclearAdequateInadequate
Steno 1b 198670–72UnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearInadequateInadequate
Stockholm 198587–98AdequateUnclearAdequateUnclearUnclearAdequateInadequate
Verrillo et al82UnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclear
Hershey et al102 and White103UnclearUnclearUnclearAdequateUnclearAdequateAdequate
  • DCCT/EDIC, Diabetes Control and Complication Trial/Epidemiology of Diabetes Interventions and Complications; Minnesota DCCT, Minnesota Diabetes Control and Complication Trial.