Overview of systematic reviews of ERAS for colorectal surgery
| Review | Minimum definition of ERAS intervention | Search cut-off date | Included RCTs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wind et al7 | At least four elements required | December 2005 | Anderson et al,8 Delaney et al,9 Gatt et al10 |
| Eskicioglu et al11 | Not stated | May 2008 | Anderson et al,8 Delaney et al,9 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al12 |
| Gouvas et al13 | At least four elements required | July 2008 | Anderson et al,8 Delaney et al,9 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al12 |
| Walter et al14 | At least five elements required (preoperative, perioperative and postoperative) | January 2007 | Anderson et al,8 Gatt et al10 |
| Varadhan et al15 | At least four elements required (preoperative, perioperative and postoperative) | November 2009 | Anderson et al,8 Delaney et al,9 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al,12 Muller et al,16 Serclova et al,17 |
| Adamina et al18 | Documented compliance with at least four of five key elements | June 2010 | Anderson et al,8 Delaney et al,9 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al,12 Muller et al,16 Serclova et al17 |
| Rawlinson et al19 | At least four elements required (preoperative, perioperative and postoperative) | February 2011 | Anderson et al,8 Delaney et al,9 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al,12 Muller et al,16 Serclova et al17 |
| Spanjersberg et al20 | At least seven elements required | Unclear (January 2011?) | Anderson et al,8 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al,12 Serclova et al17 |
| Lv et al21 | Not stated | April 2012 | Anderson et al,8 Delaney et al,9 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al,12 Muller et al,16 Serclova et al,17 Vlug et al22 |
| Zhuang et al6 | At least seven elements required | July 2012 | Anderson et al,8 Gatt et al,10 Khoo et al,12 Muller et al,16 Serclova et al,17 Ionescu et al,23 Vlug et al,22 Garcia-Botello et al,24 van Bree et al,25 Ren et al,26 Wang G et al,27 Wang Q et al,28 Yang et al29 |
ERAS, enhanced recovery after surgery; RCT, randomised controlled trial.