Table 2

Unsatisfactory cervical cytology smear rates in populations using the ThinPrep platform

Lead authorYearTotal number of cervical cytology smearsNumber of unsatisfactory smearsPercentage of unsatisfactory smearsLocation of study
Davey et al21200752 6657951.5Australia
Roberts et al22199735 5602350.7Australia
Shield et al231999300196.3Australia
Halford et al24200987 2847580.9Australia
Duggan et al2520062288100.4Canada
Belison et al262002145015810.9China
Zhao et al920111033151.5China
Yeoh et al27199916 541930.6Hong Kong
Cheung et al282003190 6676080.3Hong Kong
Grace et al2920021000131.3Ireland
Treacy et al1200941 31213423.2Ireland
Ronco et al30200722 7085832.6Italy
Rahimi et al31200846791.9Italy
Luthra et al3220011024363.5Kuwait
Siebers et al33200846 0641530.3the Netherlands
Williams34200678 06414931.9Scotland
Taylor et al3520063184702.2South Africa
Tuncer et al3620054322721.7Turkey
Kitchener et al13201123 4364561.9UK
Narine and Young14Unpublished58 97312502.1UK
Alsharif et al15200954191242.3USA
Nance17200788 5755670.6USA
Bentz37200223 7902090.9USA
Bentz37200215 1541971.3USA
Bolick and Hellman38199810 694310.3USA
Wachtel et al3920092890772.7USA
Harkness et al4020033000802.7USA
Duby and DiFurio41200955 43810271.8USA
Duby and DiFurio41200953 2097831.5USA
Zhao and Austin422009222 24232301.4USA
Total1 148 75515 5931.3