Table 1

Inclusion criteria based on the PICOD framework

PICODSpecific details
PopulationPatients who received intravenous or intra-arterial non-ionic iodinated CM*
  • High-risk population

  • Low-risk population

  • No risk-stratified population

Interventions /Comparators and co-interventionsPharmacological interventions†
  • 12 or 13 hours oral corticosteroids with or without antihistamine

  • 5–11 hours IV corticosteroids with or without antihistamine

  • Any premedication less than 5 hours using corticosteroids, antihistamine or both


Non-pharmacological interventions
  • Change of CM that caused prior type B hypersensitivity reaction

OutcomesRates of acute (<1 hour) type B hypersensitivity reactions‡
  • Acute reaction-related deaths within 30 days

  • Severe reactions only

  • Moderate and severe reactions only

  • Upgraded reactions compared with the index reactions

  • All hypersensitivity reactions


Rates of adverse events induced by preventive interventions
Predictors of acute adverse reactionsPatient-level characteristics
  • Prior type B hypersensitivity reactions

  • Prior type A physiologic reactions§

  • Allergic diathesis (eg, asthma, food or drug allergy, etc)


Intervention-level characteristics
  • Types and regimens of interventions

  • Dosing of specific premedication drugs

  • Change of CM (specific class/product and/or dosing)

DesignsAny study designs including at least 10 patients
  • Randomised controlled trials

  • Non-randomised trials

  • Prospective and retrospective cohorts

    • Comparative (two or more-group) design

    • Single-group design

  • *Per-study defined risk criteria are allowed.

  • †Both guideline-recommended and ad-hoc regimens are allowed, but will be analysed separately. Guideline-recommended oral regimens are defined as follows2: 13 hours regimen: prednisone 50 mg PO at 13, 7 and 1 hours before CM injection+/−optional diphenhydramine 50 mg IV, IM or PO at 1 hour before CM injection; 12 hours regimen: methylpredonisolone 32 mg PO at 12 and 2 hours before CM injection+/−optional antihistamine. Guideline-recommended urgent regimens are: methylprednisolone 40 mg or hydrocortisone 200 mg IV every 4 hours until CM injection (minimum cumulative duration 5 hours)+/−diphenhydramine 50 mg IV at 1 hour before CM injection. Any premedication that does not include corticosteroids or that is less than 5 hours in duration is non-standard.

  • ‡Grades of type B hypersensitivity reactions are defined as follows2: mild reactions include limited urticaria/pruritus, cutaneous oedema, limited ‘itchy’/‘scratchy’ throat, nasal congestion, sneezing, conjunctivitis and rhinorrhea; moderate reactions include diffuse urticaria/pruritus, diffuse erythema with stable vital signs, facial oedema without dyspnoea, throat tightness or hoarseness without dyspnoea, and wheezing/bronchospasm with mild or no hypoxia; and severe reactions include diffuse oedema, facial oedema with dyspnoea, diffuse erythema with hypotension, laryngeal oedema with stridor and/or hypoxia, wheezing/bronchospasm with significant hypoxia and anaphylactic shock (hypotension+tachycardia).

  • §Grades of type A physiologic reactions are defined as follows2: mild reactions include limited nausea/vomiting, transient flushing, warmth, chills, headache, dizziness, anxiety, altered taste, mild hypertension and vasovagal reaction that resolves spontaneously; moderate reactions include protracted nausea/vomiting, hypertensive urgency, isolated chest pain and vasovagal reaction that requires and is responsive to treatment; and severe reactions include vasovagal reaction resistant to treatment, arrhythmia, convulsions, seizures and hypertensive emergency.

  • CM, contrast medium; IM, intramuscularly; IV, intravenously; PICOD, populations, interventions, comparator interventions, outcomes and study designs; PO, orally.