Table 2

Summary of included studies on differentials in breast cancer survival outcomes by residential location

Author, yearLocation*Period (follow-up)Sample sizePoorer survival
UnadjustedAdjusted†
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, 201312 National1982–2007 (end 2010)NSNon-metropolitanNR
Wilkinson and Cameron, 200445 SA1977–1993 (to 2000)NSNon-metropolitanNR
Cramb et al, 201232 Qld1996–200725 202Non-metropolitanNo difference (s, d)
Dasgupta et al, 201236 Qld1997–2006 (end 2007)18 568Non-metropolitanNo difference (s, d)
Hsieh et al, 2016b47 Qld1997–2007 (end 2008)9741Non-metropolitanNo difference (s, d)
Tervonen et al, 201742 NSW1980–2008 (end 2009)88 768Non-metropolitanNo difference (s, d)
Tracey et al, 200843 NSW1980–2003 (end 2004)59 731Non-metropolitanNo difference (s, d)
Mitchell et al, 200639 WA1999 (end 2004)899Non-metropolitanNo difference (s, t)
Supramaniam et al, 201441 NSW2001–2007 (end 2008)27 850Non-metropolitanNo difference (s, d, t, c)
Roder et al, 2012a28 National1991–200662 082Non-metropolitanNo difference (d)
Hall et al, 2004a37 WA1991–20017117Non-metropolitanNo difference (d, t, c)
Spilsbury et al, 200540 WA1982–200011 445Non-metropolitanNo difference (d, t, c)
Taylor, 199746 NSW1980–1991 (end 1992)25 793No differenceNo difference (s)
Bonett et al, 199029 SA1980–1986 (end 1988)2565Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan (s)
Chen et al, 201530 NSW2000–200836 867Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan (s)
Cramb et al, 2016a34 Qld1997–2011NSNon-metropolitanNon-metropolitan *(s)
Cramb et al, 2016b33 Qld1997–201134 231Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan (s)
Hsieh et al, 201348 Qld1997–2007 (end 2008)23 766Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan (s, d)
Hsieh et al, 2016a38 Qld1997–2007 (end 2008)23 766Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan (s)
Yu et al, 201544 NSW1987–2007 (end 2007)63 757Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan (s, d)
Clayforth et al, 200731 WA1989, 1994, 1999 (end 2005)1729Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan (s, t)
Cramb et al, 201735 Qld1997–2004 (end 2005); 2005–2012 (end 2013)38 204Non-metropolitanNon-metropolitan
  • *National: all states/territories. NSW, New South Wales; Qld, Queensland; SA, South Australia; WA, Western Australia.

  • †All adjusted for age except Bonett et al, 1990.29

  • (s) Also adjusted for some measure of spread of diagnosis, such as stage at diagnosis or tumour diameter.

  • (t) Also adjusted for treatment-related factors.

  • (d) Also adjusted for area disadvantage.

  • (c) Also adjusted for comorbidities.

  • NR, not relevant; NS, not stated.