Table 1

Trial characteristics

CharacteristicAll articles (n=247)Articles reporting a treatment effect (TE) that was not statistically significant, the CI of the TE and a value for the TE that the authors considered to be clinically meaningful (n=78)
Journal
 New England Journal of Medicine105 (43%)31 (40%)
 JAMA61 (25%)22 (28%)
 The Lancet50 (20%)11 (14%)
 British Medical Journal13 (5%)8 (10%)
 JAMA Internal Medicine11 (4%)1 (1%)
 Annals of Internal Medicine7 (3%)5 (6%)
Design
 Parallel group245 (99%)78 (100%)
 Cross-over2 (1%)0 (0%)
 Number randomised480 (224–1195)730 (311–1880)
Medical specialty
 Cardiovascular55 (22%)23 (29%)
 Infectious disease38 (15%)12 (15%)
 Cancer31 (13%)4 (5%)
 Neurology (including pain)22 (9%)7 (9%)
 Pulmonary13 (5%)6 (8%)
 Psychiatry12 (5%)1 (1%)
 Other*76 (31%)25 (32%)
Type of intervention
 Treatment183 (74%)52 (67%)
 Prevention64 (26%)26 (33%)
Sponsor
 Industry134 (54%)36 (46%)
 Other113 (46%)42 (54%)
  • Values are n (%) or median (IQR).

  • *Other includes areas represented by fewer than 10 trials including urology, orthopaedics, diabetes, immune disorders and so on.