Table 1

Characteristics of the primary studies and prevalence ratios of high serum Legionella antibody (IgG) level assessed using extracted data

StudyCountryDental healthcare working categoriesOccupationally unexposed individualsProportion seropositives (dental healthcare workers)Proportion seropositives (occupationally unexposed individuals)Prevalence ratio (95% CI)
Fotos et al 3 USADentists, clinical-level students, assistantsGeneral population20.0% (54/270)10.4% (7/67)1.91 (0.91 to 4.01)
Oppenheim et al 65 UKDentists, clinical-level studentsLast-year medical students, young doctors5.9% (9/152)1.4% (1/70)4.15 (0.54 to 32.08)
Reinthaler et al 18 AustriaDentists, assistants, techniciansWhite-collar workers, non-dental students33.6% (36/107)4.7% (5/106)7.13 (2.91 to 17.47)
Luck et al 66 GermanyDentists, assistantsGeneral population6.9% (15/218)5.5% (16/293)1.26 (0.64 to 2.49)
Pankhurst et al 32*UKDentistsBlood donors0.4% (1/246)2.4% (12/500)0.17 (0.02 to 1.29)
Vogt et al 33 USADentistsClinically unexposed volunteers8.6% (93/1076)9.1% (2/22)0.95 (0.25 to 3.61)
Borella et al 8 subset aItaly (Turin)Dentists, clinical-level studentsWhite-collar workers26.9% (32/119)32.9% (23/70)0.82 (0.52 to 1.28)
Borella et al 8 subset bItaly (Bari)Dental healthcare workersWhite-collar workers31.8% (14/44)9.1% (4/44)3.50 (1.25 to 9.80)
  • *Legionella pneumophila antibodies.