Data collection form*
| Title of review | Low-value clinical practices in injury care: a scoping review | ||
| Reviewer | |||
| Date of review | |||
| Form version | 1.0 (2017-01-16) | ||
| Contact with author | Date, reason, resolved | ||
| Notes | |||
| Study identification | |||
| Report number | Last name first author—year of the reference | ||
| Study number | Last name first author—year of the primary reference | ||
| Title | |||
| Author(s) | |||
| Source 1 | □ research article □ abstract □ conference proceeding □ non-research article □ review □ guideline □ recommendation other (eg, unpublished data): | ||
| Source 2 | □ MEDLINE □ EMBASE □ Cochrane □ BIOSIS □ ClinicalTrials □ ISRCTN □ Thesis repository □ Website □ Reference listing Other (grey literature): | ||
| Year | |||
| Volume | |||
| Page (start-end) | |||
| Contact | |||
| Country | |||
| Language | |||
| Funding | □ NA | ||
| Notes | |||
| Eligibility of study in the review | |||
| Inclusion criteria | □ Injury population | ||
| □ potentially low-value clinical practice | |||
| Notes | |||
| Study details | |||
| Setting | Country(ies)/province(s)/state(s); trauma system(s); number and level of centres | ||
| Period of study | Dates start-end | ||
| Study inclusion | □ Age | Criteria: | □ NA |
| criteria | □ Injury severity | Criteria: | □ NA |
| □ Injury type | Criteria: | □ NA | |
| □ Other | List all other inclusion criteria | □ NA | |
| Study exclusion criteria | List all exclusion criteria | □ NA | |
| REB approval | □ yes □ no □ unclear | ||
| Study design | □ prospective cohort □ retrospective cohort □ population-based □ unclear Other: | ||
| Notes | |||
| Study data | |||
| Primary data source | |||
| Secondary data source | |||
| Other data sources | |||
| Notes | |||
| Population characteristics | |||
| Sample size (n) | Patients : | ||
| Age | e.g. n(%)≥65 yoa, mean (SD), median (quartiles) | ||
| Gender | n(%) male | ||
| Injury mechanism | e.g. n(%) penetrating, motor vehicle collision | ||
| Injury severity | e.g. n(%) Injury Severity Score>15, Maximum Abbreviated Injury Scale score>3 | ||
| Injury type | e.g. n(%) traumatic brain; spinal cord; thoracoabdominal; orthopaedic; multisystem blunt | ||
| Notes | |||
| Low-value clinical practice (one per practice) | |||
| Practice | |||
| Type of practice | □ consultation □ screening □ diagnostic procedure □ monitoring □ therapeutic procedure Other: | ||
| Type of overuse | □ inappropriate for a specified clinical indication □ inappropriate for clinical indication in a specific population □ excessive service intensity or sophistication given expected clinical benefit □ inappropriate for clinical indication in a specific population □ excessive frequency of service given expected clinical benefit Other: | ||
| Frequency | e.g. n(%) | ||
NA: not available, MEDLINE: Medical Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online, EMBASE: Excerpta Medica database, BIOSIS: Biosciences Information Service, ISRCTN: International Standard Randomised Controlled Trials Number
*Adapted from Cochrane Consumer and Communication Review Group Data extraction template.