Table 2

General characteristics

All articles (n=168)Including NEJM protocols (n=61)
Characteristicsn (%)n (%)
Journal
NEJM61 (36)61
Lancet64 (38)
JAMA19 (11)
BMJ8 (5)
Annals of Internal Medicine5 (2)
PLoS Medicine7 (4)
Archives of Internal Medicine2 (1)
JAMA of Internal Medicine2 (1)
Year of publication
 201026 (15)9 (15)
 201127 (16)9 (15)
 201229 (17)8 (13)
 201339 (23)19 (31)
 201427 (16)10 (16)
 201520 (12)6 (10)
Type of intervention
 Drug112 (67)44 (72)
 Surgery22 (13)7 (11)
 Other34 (20)10 (16)
Randomisation
 Patient163 (97)59 (97)
 Cluster5 (3)2 (3)
Power
 80%6 (36)19 (31)
 85%11 (7)5 (8)
 90%65 (39)26 (43)
 71–99% (excluding the above)21 (12)11 (18)
 Not reported/unclear10 (6)0
Composite outcome
 Yes78 (46)37 (61)
 No90 (54)24 (39)
Disease
 Heart disease30 (18)13 (21)
 Blood disorder19 (11)6 (10)
 Cancer16 (10)8 (13)
 Diabetes11 (7)2 (3)
 Thromboembolism6 (4)6 (10)
 Skin infection (non-contagious)3 (2)2 (3)
 Urinary tract infection3 (2)0
 Arthritis3 (2)1 (2)
 Opthomology3 (2)1 (2)
 Pneumonia3 (2)1 (2)
 Complications in pregnancy3 (2)0
 Stroke3 (2)2 (3)
 Testing method3 (2)1 (2)
 Appendicitis2 (1)1 (2)
 Depression2 (1)0
 Other non-infectious disease18 (11)7 (11)
 HIV18 (11)2 (3)
 Tuberculosis6 (4)4 (7)
 Malaria4 (2)1 (2)
 Skin infection (contagious)2 (1)0
 Hepatitis C2 (1)2 (3)
 Other infectious disease8 (5)1 (2)